From certain game modes.
Having a squad filled with crop dusters in a 14.3 ARB game just shouldn’t happen.
1 Like
Doesn’t mean you aren’t being a jerk when you do that.
If you did suggest this in general, then I would not be surprised. It would only make sense in air realistic.
In other modes, it may even be counter productive: I find it way more grieving when people come to a naval battle and have no way to cap the objective. It would be nice if a squad had a player for air defense and shallow waters, if the others just Bismarck around.
In GRB as well.
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
It can take quite a while before Suggestions are handled. if you no longer see a “pending” as an option on your forum profile then it has most likely been denied. You can send a private message to one of the Suggestion Moderators to get the reason for the denial and a copy of the suggestion so that you can re-make it with corrections (I personally had to do the same, took several months before my suggestion got accepted in the end).
Click to reveal instructions for how to contact the moderator teams
You can find all the teams and the areas they handle listed here: (Who is who and Reporting Procedure). If you don’t get an answer within a few days you can add more moderators from the list to the original message instead of sending a new message (that way you preserve the date of the message and it doesn’t look like a new request), adding one of the moderators to the message every 2-3 days or so until you get an answer.
Please do not to add the seniors until you have tried all other regular moderators, the Seniors likely won’t answer unless they are added and pinged by the regular moderators but if you’ve added all the regular moderators with no answer then you can add the seniors.
Not sure what you are getting at here.
I play mostly ground now. If a squad comes into a 5.3-6.3 battle and two of that squad ONLY have reserve tanks, they are handicapping their own team. Those reserve tanks will die easily and help opposing team remove tickets.
That is what my suggestion was referring to. Squad players should only be allowed into battles if they have AT LEAST one vehicle within the BR range.
We can’t force them to use that ONE vehicle, but then again Gaijin can’t force me to stay in a battle when team-mates refuse to play the objective.
Really wish to know where all the low BR people are in top tier battles, the way you guys talk about it you’d think it was a full on epidemic and not something that happens every 50 battles
I am not sure if that would actually solve the structural problem. If someone wants to play an air vehicle, he needs to get enough spawn points. I don’t quite see the difference if he takes a higher tier light/spaa to cap and j-out to then fly the chopper/plane. If he wants to do that, he can do it. Or do I miss something?
Yes - my suggestion no longer appears as “pending” in my activities.
I did contact a moderator as suggested in your pop-out but no response.
I can’t find any emails on it and do not have a link to my original suggestion. Is it still “actionable”?
Then add more of them from the list to the original message as i wrote above. Sometimes some of the moderators are less active due to real life stuff, especially around the holidays and vacations. We are all volunteers and have real life jobs/school families/hobbies/etc outside of War Thunder.
The Suggestion Moderators have some way of retrieving a copy of your suggestion to give to you, i don’t know how though. So if it is denied then you will have to re-submit with corrections and changes.
1 Like
Did you suggest this mode specific or not? If you suggested in in general, it would make no sense, as in say Naval the situation is totally different. Often a team loses because none of the ‘champs’ is able to spawn a reserve dinky. Having a squad member with lower BR coastal vehicles isn’t bad. Maybe it is more evident by the fact that top rank in naval has over 100% BR variability.
Also in air arcade, many functions can be done very well by propeller planes with less BR. Including killing jets for 30k SL.
If you don’t really play these modes, don’t just assume they all work the same or have the same needs.
That should also be prohibited.
General - since it applies to AT LEAST two of the 3 modes (Air / Ground). No idea about naval as I never played it.
EVERYONE has access to lower BR vehicles if they somehow are needed for the mode.
Prop planes are at a huge disadvantage vs jets. Coming into a battle without ANY vehicles in the battle BR range with the sole intention of vying for the “god mode” accomplishment is griefing as they will more often than not just reduce their own teams tickets.
Now apply this logic to bad vehicles and spawning SPAA
You need to elaborate more.
People spawn SPAA or generally bad vehicles then instantly die without doing anything useful far more frequently than people spawning in low br vehicles
Not arcade air.
When hitting ground targets? Props work just fine.
And ground mostly wins arcade.
Arcade respawn is only crew limited. You can spawn many props. I rather have 5 props than 1 jet as support in arcade.
As warthunder can’t mind read yet, we won’t know. But these squads usually are “friends on a sight seeing tour” to visit jet combat. Yes, I wouldn’t mind their absence but I am not willing to pay any price for it, that may come up in the process.
If it would be restricted to air RB, OK. I can see the benefits there, as you have no respawn and ground doesn’t matter.
IMO this definately shouldn’t be allowed in ARB. For GRB is debatable because game allows player to form any kind of lineup anyways so it probably wont change.
1 Like
Not something that be controlled by the game.
having players enter battle with AT LEAST one vehicle in the BR range can be controlled.
1 Like