Im talking about the Murat going down (worse then the hunter F.1), and as stated prevoiusly the Murat is worse then all the other 8.7 if we talking about game impact.
Very unlikely it’s worse than Hunter F1
Bro have you even played it yet ?
1 Like
No, I do not plan to grind this jet. Hence why I said “very unlikely” and not “It is not”
No way you are out here arguining about a planes BR when you have not even played it, that is crazy.
1 Like
I am allowed to have an opinion, especially when it is presented as one and not as me saying something “is” the way it is.
Though since you’re trying to silence my opinion based on this, I will go ahead and do the same to you.
You have 21 whole entire games in the Hunter F1. You have not played it.
You have ONE (1!) game in the HF-24 Marut.
You are a joke.
And you have zero games in it.
1 Like
This is not some clever zinger when I already said what I said was just my opinion (one of which is based PARTIALLY on what the sikh guy himself has said about the aircraft…) and that the opposite person has 1 entire whole game…
1 game and a hour in test flight, also its not just me with this oppion, watch DEFYNs video on it, he calls it a slightly better f84 and rips on it.
2 Likes
Agree. The Marut at 9.0 is an absolute boat. I would rather fly the Hunter, MiG 15 or G.91 at 9.0 than the Marut. I cannot understand why they did not add the reheat prototype or even the proposed RD-9 engined one as the event aircraft, those would have made the aircraft a better fit for the type of air combat in WT than this underpowered light attacker.
2 Likes
Its deffiently the worst 9.0 ATM in the game, A32A/J29F and FFA-P16 all are better in someway and so can play off those strengths.
1 Like
Dont be surprised if a mod locks your thread btw, mine was locked and with the comment to “use the official thread” on this exact subject with a poll showing a majority support for 8.3/7 BR.
But yeah, its BR could come down, especially so for GRB in my view.
1 Like
as soon as i saw what plane was coming I know it would be DOA because it would be overtiered.
Its worse than a Scimitar and that thing is 8.7, hasn’t got any guided munition either so should be 8.3
1 Like
it would still be rough at the same BR as vampire, a 1943 plane
1 Like
There is an argument for that, as in an uptier it’s too slow and too unmanoeuvrable, and in a downtier it’s just even more unmanoeuvrable, even if it can catch the odd enemy. And as for the guns, they are good, but equally useless as the rest of the jet because you just don’t have the nose authority to aim. In my games with the jet before I gave up on it, I only got 2 kills, both of which I just got lucky and managed to trade in a frontal. I didn’t even survive the kill, and that was me getting lucky! I have to ask what Gaijin thought they were doing with its BR.
2 Likes
I GEed it because it was unique, but I have been very disappointed with it as the most unique thing about it is how incredibly awful it is. For its BR, it has a decidedly average subsonic top speed, poor acceleration, okayish ordinance load, terrible energy retention, awful manoeuvrability, no guided munitions of any variety, no RWR, no radar, no ballistics computer and no countermeasures; all while facing supersonic, afterburning jets with AAMs who are more manoeuvrable than you, have radar, ballistics computers and possibly even primitive air to ground missiles. Oh and just to top it off its fuel selection and timing is bugged, but I can’t even be bothered to report that as the aircraft is so hopeless to begin with. They seem to have made a habit of doing over BRed strike aircraft as event vehicles (starting with the Jaguar IS, which I earned) even since they brought in different BRs for different game modes. For some reason they only put the strike aircraft up in ground, not down in air even though many of them need it. I can’t understand their logic.
You know things are bad when 2 air specialist War Thunder YouTubers agree on the pitiful state of the aircraft.
2 Likes
Maybe, but I am certain that (being a strike aircraft) it is more usable in ground than air, even if it is still terrible.
Sadly not so much, no smart weapons, no rwr, no flares, going to be facing constant uptiers in that BR zone vs SAM systems and proxy fuse SPAA.
Going to be rough I think.
1 Like
Clarksooonnnn!!!