You make it sound like AIM-54 is some kind of super bias missile, when the only missile that ever was a super bias missile was R-27ER. No one questioned it 1 year ago. R-27ER has been nerfed along the way, but the nerf didn’t make it worse than AIM-7F/M by any means.
Even if you can’t just ignore an AIM-54, it’s still easy to dodge it or notch it. At long range it’s easy to dodge/notch any missile and at close range AIM-54 really isn’t effective. It’s a very heavy missile that needs some space and time to accelerate. When you launch it it kind of just drops and then starts flying.
Close to medium range missile jousting is the most important characteristic in a plane, in which R-27ER used to trash AIM-7F/M, and now it’s just better. At long range no missile can give a high chance for a kill and dogfights expose you to 3rd parties. Close-mid range missile jousting is the best way to quickly and easily stack up kills while staying safe. Previously it couldn’t be really utilized as effectively because of multipathing.
MiG-29 is faster on the deck than U.S. planes, which allows you to do exclusively missile jousting and returning back to base when you run out of missiles. When you run away F-14s can’t even see you on radar, so no risk of AIM-54 splashing you.
An F-14 or an F-15 can force the MiG-29 to go defensive with ARHs and/or by having more SARHs, but if they use this to push, they just expose themselves to close-mid range missile jousting, where they are inferior.
The radar won’t make a significant difference in missile jousting. I really doubt the “7-14 seconds to find you again” part. If you get very close you have ACM/HMS.
MiG-29 has a limit of only 2 R-27ERs, so it can’t really dominate the lobby. I bet on average you would get 1.5 kills per flyout. It’s a bit like an A-10, it has 2 very good missiles and really nothing else, except MiG-29 is probably the fastest plane on the deck, unlike A-10. If Su-27 was a 13.0 instead of a 13.3, it would destroy lobbies.
I really wish MiG-29 was fixed, had a competitive flight model, had it’s R-73s and was limited to R-27Rs, instead of being carried by the R-27ER, but it is what it is. I see no reason why F-16A ADF is a 13.0. Sparrows alone really don’t make a plane 13.0 worthy, if the R-27ER doesn’t. F-16A and F-16A ADF always had the same BR, one was multirole and the other was for air to air combat.
TL;DR
R-27ER is still fast, AIM-7F/M is still slow, AIM-54 is still fat, missile jousting > long range BVR. F-16A and F-16A ADF should always have the same BR (12.7 in current state of the game), one is multirole and the other is for air to air combat. Actually fix Russian gen 4s, instead of sweeping their issues under the rug with the R-27ER.