Alright, we’re both saying the same thing.
However, regarding the Bf 109 F-4 and the P-51 C-10, there’s a specific issue:
*We aren’t starting on equal terms.
First of all, the P-51 C-10 was produced in 1944 and designed based on lessons learned; it’s much more agile than the earlier, basic P-51 model (which I actually think is decent, though it struggles if you try to fly it like a Yak-3—whereas the P-51 C-10 and later variants hardly struggle at all!).
To begin with, this aircraft has a top speed of 708 km/h. In terms of maneuverability—partly because it carries fewer guns—it’s quite capable; it’s actually more agile than most D-series Mustangs (with the exception of the D-30).
When we get into a turn fight, the P-51 C-10 starts with a clear advantage—it enters the engagement at a much higher speed. Meanwhile, if I try to turn, a single misstep can cause my plane to wobble. The P-51 C-10, on the other hand—likely due to its wing design (a trait also seen in the Bf 109 E-series)—can execute a turn perfectly, staying locked on without any deviation. Honestly, I don’t recall ever fighting a C-10 while flying an F-4, but I have struggled against one while in a Bf 109 G-2—even though the G-2 has better speed and climb performance.
When we get into a turning duel, this guy starts with an advantage over me; he enters the engagement at a much better speed. As for me, the moment I start turning, a single wrong move makes me prone to wobbling. This fellow—likely due to his wing design, which is also a feature of the Bf 109 E series—can turn perfectly straight without any deviation. Honestly, I don’t recall ever fighting a C-10 while flying an F-4.
However, I did have a long, drawn-out fight against someone flying a 109 G-2. His aircraft held energy exceptionally well—both in the vertical and horizontal planes—so while I began to lose momentum, he kept flying as if nothing had happened, much like a Yak-3. There were moments where he gave me an opening, but I missed my shot—and he missed his, too—but eventually, as my 109 ran out of steam, I just bailed out.
To be frank, in my experience, the G-series has consistently underperformed against players who know how to handle the C-10 series well.
Also, you mentioned that I should “apply pressure.” :D But I can’t even catch the guy—how am I supposed to apply pressure? If I try to intercept him from above, but he’s positioned slightly higher, he just dives and pulls away. If I get on his tail, my wings snap; besides, it’s not just me he’s dealing with—he’ll simply shift his focus to another target. Even if you catch him at high speeds, he pulls a sharp maneuver to change direction, and by the time you recover, he’s already put distance between you. You don’t get it.
What I mean is this:
Imagine an aircraft: it’s significantly faster than the Bf 109 F-4, boasts an excellent turn radius at high speeds, maintains energy remarkably well even at low speeds, features lethal long-range weaponry, climbs impressively, and can return to its original altitude—or even higher—after a dive-and-attack maneuver. In short, it’s a bona fide “super-plane.”
The P-51 C-10, which entered service in 1944, is powered by the legendary Merlin engine and sits at a Battle Rating (BR) of 4.0.
The Bf 109 F-4 entered service in May 1941; it was the best of its time and is often cited by experts as the “best 109” variant—also at a BR of 4.0.
As for those turn-rate charts, they are practically meaningless in the context of this game. The P-51 is superior to the F-4 in every single category. Surely, the F-4 should at least be allowed to hold its own in a turn—though even that is debatable, given the various factors at play, most of which tend to disadvantage the F-4 (which is balanced based on its 1941 specifications).
This is a well-established fact, both in-game and historically. When the P-51 arrived, the only German aircraft capable of challenging it were the K-4, D-9, and Ta 152—and even then, the D-9’s effectiveness is questionable, while the K-4, despite some improvements, still suffers from similar issues (save for a slight edge in speed).
In their own reports, the Germans noted that the P-51 was still faster than the D-9 series. The Ta 152 is strong in terms of speed, energy retention, and incredible acceleration, but as a high-altitude interceptor, its wing design makes its maneuvers somewhat sluggish.
Honestly, I can’t even get any actual gameplay in because I’m too busy writing posts like this.
By the way—are you actually suggesting that the F-4 and the P-51 C-10 are equals? * They are absolutely not equal, not by a long shot. The P-51 C-10 is superior in every way. *
And in games with a 4.0 BR cap, those flying the 109 F-4 really struggle—you could even include the G-2s in that, too.