The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

Since you’ve already admitted that the Yak-3 turns better, there’s no point in a duel—though I suppose you could still do it just for fun.

Of course, in duels, people manage their WEP and toggle their radiators—what are you even talking about? They even use propeller-pitch tricks to force the enemy in front of them!

The P-51 isn’t just great; it’s absolutely fantastic.

Its weight actually works to my advantage when I dive to chase an enemy—haha, it just feels more powerful and faster to me.

And I’ll say it again: the stat cards mean absolutely nothing. The P-51 C-10 will almost always find itself in a more favorable combat situation. It’s not going to get into a simple turning circle fight with you like some novice player would; instead, it’ll use its superior initial speed to out-turn you and take you down.

I mean, I just don’t get it—are you trying to argue that the F-4 is better than the Corsair F4U-4B, even though you’re pushing the F-4 up to a 5.7 BR?

Honestly, it’s like people who play the German tech tree are suffering from Stockholm syndrome, or maybe the Pollyanna principle—or perhaps you’re just masochists.

You’re out here defending the 109 F-4, even when it’s clearly inferior to the other plane.

I just don’t understand this kind of resignation.

Some people defend the Tiger II (H) and the Panther series against vehicles produced around 1954—tanks that feature much faster firing rates, superior turret traverse speeds, and better ammunition.

It’s truly baffling.

They seem to have accepted the idea that it’s “unfair” to face vehicles designed for entirely different operational concepts—one built for the context of World War II, the other for the post-war era.

Sure, the Bf 109 F-4 (May 1941) might be decent in those tight, low-speed “turn fights,” but the P-51 C-10 (early 1944) is objectively better.

As for taking a tiny advantage and clinging to it for comfort—well, we have a perfect expression for that in my country; perhaps it’s made its way into your language, too.

“züğürt tesellisi”

A couple more additions;

The P-51 C-10 should be at a minimum BR of 4.7,

and air simulator battles are effectively dead.

Have fun with the eremin Yak-3 (4.3 br 1944 jully) !

If entry dates mean so much then a Toyota Prius would stomp a Tiger 2 right? Or a Boeing 747 would annihilate a F-14. Oh wait, entry dates mean jackshit!

It rates better long-term. It can be beaten with proper use of flight paths and flaps.

These aren’t stat cards I’m handing out. I literally gave you measurements over a consistent 5 minute period to average out my skill issues.

Not the -4B. -4B is a crazy good plane.

It is however quite competetive vs F4U-4.

The 109 F-4 is not inferior. It’s a hyper-fun plane that in the average EC lobby can find a niche against almost everything. I love that bird.

It’s not resignation. I initially started Warthunder as an america main (F4U-4, P-51C, P-51) before deciding to give the 109 a try to understand my enemy better. I fell in love with it. She handles like a right dream.

You need to learn what objectively means because it does not mean what your translator software thinks it means.

Again: Long-term rate yak-3 probably wins if equal skill. However, during the initial first few turns the 109 F-4 can beat the yak-3 if equal or superior skill. If significantly superior skill, the F-4 might even win a prolonged fight.

Yes, american planes do well in dives. It’s even an adage taught by IdahoBookworm: “Never fight a hellcat into a downhill engagement: It will win.”

Same is kind of true of the P-51s too, but not universally. Before I started actually practicing with people much better than me, I have had a Bf 109 K-4 vs P-51D dogfight that was a weird descending spiral/scissor. I managed to sit right on the P-51D’s six by camping 6.1G turn the whole time. Ace crew OP.

Also trim can get very, very stupid. I tried it once in a dive and it surprised the spitfire. Only woe is I don’t know if the spitfire blacked out or not so I can’t exactly cite it as proof as a lot of open EC videos of mine can be excused as “your enemy forgot they had thumbs” and also that I only started practicing properly ~8 months ago and the stuff from before that is… a good lesson in what not to do even if I did win them lmao.

1 Like

On the contrary, F-14 gets soloed by Lancaster B

1.28 global k/d btw

And none of the armor, cramped crew spaces (and less total crew), can’t bounce a damn thing (Unless the odd magical bounce) and can probably instadie to 7.6cm (or smaller!) HE to the turret ring (EBR 1954).

But yes, let’s ignore that to try and make a point when the complained about vehicle also sits at a higher BR (in sim) than the Panzerkampfwagen VI Ausfuhrung B.

I’ve been playing since before the tank tech trees were even added to the game.

The C10 was added within the last three years, and the Yak-3 (at 4.3 BR) was also added relatively recently.

The tank called the T20 was added recently, too.
Back in the day, when I first started playing Simulator Battles in my Tiger II (H), I was shocked to see French monsters with autoloaders among the enemy lineup. Ever since that day, I haven’t touched ground vehicles; I only fly the Ju 288 for bombing runs.

Because of people like you, everything just gets normalized.

I’m expecting to see the F-86 Sabre soon—they’ve already added the Fireball, which is a smaller version of it.

According to your logic, a Bf 109 F-4 could probably go toe-to-toe with an F-86. I’m fed up with this romanticized view of yours.

I don’t play anything other than the German tech tree—not because I’m some die-hard “German fanboy,” but because I’m just stating the facts as they are.

You’re a lost cause.

Because of people like you, Air Simulator Battles are effectively dead.

Honestly, Gaijin might as well just shut down Air Simulator Battles altogether.

And here I thought this thread was over. But clearly, just throwing passive-aggressive insults at everyone. Just like the rest of the wackos like you. If I had a quarter for every time, I’d have a bag of quarters; it’s not much, but it’s funny that it occurs more than twice.
@Pacifica

2 Likes

Frankly, sir, as long as this injustice remains unresolved, this matter will not be closed.

If it is closed, a new one will be opened.

They’re a damn site harder to hit than what Germany has to do to most of its opposition, just aim centre mass and that allied tank is gone in most cases. Yet you highlight this to a German main they’ll still state how “hard” German tanks are to play.

No it isn’t and no that round doesn’t easily bounce at all. Go into test drive and fire at the T-34 with and PzIV with the long gun and the entire front of the tank no matter if it’s the turret or the frontal plate gets melted clean through. To back this up go into the armour viewer and even at 500m the round easily penetrates the entire tank from the front.

Now do the same against the PzIV(H) with the T-34 1942 which has the exact same BR off memory. Those tracks stop your APHE from penetrating and they of course cover most of the tank.

I’m just highlighting facts.
Which round over performs the most in WT? APHE.
Which nation on average has the highest penetration with APHE within “WW2” tiers? Germany.
Which nation on average has the best armour within said tiers? Germany.

Germany also has reasonably fast reloads with said highly destructive cannons and the TD’s on average whoop everyone else’s. Russia’s TD’s used to be good before HE was nerfed into the ground because how dare someone have an effective weapon that they can fight back with.

The Tiger II is still superior to the Pershing, Super Pershing, Centurion and the Caernarvon not to mention the poor old IS-2. All of these are one-shot by the long 88mm whilst they have to aim for the turret cheeks and hope for the best. The APDS from the British tanks should be an excellent counter but “shell shattered”… also add in the woeful accuracy of British tanks in general for reasons unknown.

The Panthers are a bit more balanced here but the Panther II has more or less the same armour as western heavies… yet it gets 3 spawns.

I’ll gladly swap an early gen stabiliser for armour that works, an almost guaranteed one-hit kill weapon with a relatively fast reload and average to above average speed. Not many people are willing to expose themselves driving at 20mph whilst trying to aim for the small weakspot of a Panther or Tiger’s turret, or even the small non-track protected areas of the PzIV(H). Because whilst you’re juggling these the other guy is just going to aim centre mass.

The Panther’s are also already very smooth to drive without the stabiliser, if you let off the throttle it stabilises itself even when it’s still rolling.

The truth of the matter is that German tanks aren’t as slow as you think they are. The Panther is more or less as agile as a US Sherman and the Tiger is no slouch neither, like I said go into 3rd gear with the Panther and do a full rotation then take it over some hills. Yet this tank has better armour on average than anything it faces with a one-hit kill highly penetrating gun with three spawns. It’s a medium tank that’s heavier than some “heavy tanks”. I don’t see how Germany suffers.

It isn’t slow. Considering the weight it’s rather agile as another poster has mentioned.

The IS-2 isn’t weak but it isn’t strong neither, it’s arguably worse than anything Germany has. As you’ve said the Tiger II is pretty much out right superior to it. Yet we’re lead to believe that Germany suffers…

The Panther D fights a lot of T-34’s in SB. Even the T-34-85 is an objectively worse tank. You still have to aim for the turret cheeks whereas the Panther can aim basically at your entire tank to kill you. You can flank marginally better in the T-34 but good luck doing that on most of our maps. It’s much easier to kill the T-34 than the Panther. Which can delete you at all ranges with no real effort required with the exact same reload speed.

The point is you’re having to aim for small weakspots and praying to the RNG gods that you hit one of those spots. Meanwhile the Panzer can hit you anywhere at pretty much any range and you’re dead… big difference.

As above you’re aiming for small weak spots. The Panzer isn’t… and he also reloads faster than you and will kill you with a hit anywhere at almost any range.

The turret has tracks either side of the gun.
image
Any hit from a T-34 (or heaven forbid you drive most British tanks) that hits those tracks doesn’t penetrate. This is the problem and yet another reason why despite the consensus Germany is in fact in a lot of tiers an OP nation. You can survive almost any shot frontally for at least one hit.

Already debunked. The Sherman gets close to it but that’s it. The T-34 is far behind.
Pen when launching OPHE is a massive advantage for any tank. Especially when it’s mated to strong armour, fast reload speeds (5s spaded which is the exact same as the M4A2) and above average mobility.

That, sadly is exactly how that works. With British tanks etc I’m very cautious in regards to aiming. It’s very rare with a German gun that I need to worry about shot placement. The entire tank can be penetrated starting from the Puma in reserve tier battles.

It’s a late 1943 aircraft, the 109F4 is also using 1943 engine setting as is the G-2.

" The first XP-51B flew on 30 November 1942. Flight tests confirmed the potential of the new fighter, with the service ceiling being raised by 10,000 ft (3,000 m), with the top speed improving by 50 mph (43 kn; 80 km/h) at 30,000 ft (9,100 m). American production was started in early 1943 with the P-51B (NA-102) being manufactured at Inglewood California, and the P-51C (NA-103) at a new plant in Dallas, Texas, which was in operation by summer 1943.".

P-51Bs and P-51Cs started to arrive in England in August and October 1943.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

1 Like

You have been reported.

Furthermore, Danaryan, you keep bringing up the Tiger II (H), yet you fail to share your thoughts on French autoloaders, the T-44-100, or the IS-2M/IS-44.

The tanks mentioned here can easily penetrate the hull of the Panther series—much like how the Panther D punches through T-34s—and they can also pierce the turret of the Tiger II (H). (By the way, the turret traverse speed of the Tiger II (H) is quite good.)

Also, the Panther II is not available to players who joined recently.

As for the Panther D, its turret traverse speed is laughable. I usually play this vehicle while on the move—without coming to a stop—as it’s more effective that way; whenever I do stop, the gun mantlet gets destroyed by incoming fire.

Moreover, it feels like the Panzer IV (H) was buffed for the sake of balance. There’s this “monster” variant that uses the 75mm KwK gun—you might know it; it used to be in the tech tree and dominated the game—it seems the Panzer IV (H) has taken its place. Or perhaps it was always this heavily armored; I don’t recall.

In any case, the Panzer IV (H) is so vulnerable that it can be penetrated from the side even by 12.7mm machine guns. While a T-34 can at least cause shells to ricochet, the Panzer IV (H) takes the hit directly. Its turret is also poor.

They say the Germans had the best armor.

Nonsense. The Russians had the best armor. The T-34, on its own, fundamentally changed the course of the war; it only met its match—and was eventually surpassed—by the Panther. And that was only addressed by increasing penetration power to overcome the T-34’s sloped armor. We could even talk about the IS-3 or T-44 models, if you’d like.

Well, of course they had high penetration power—that’s just historical reality. Does even that bother you?

Maybe we should play using Panzer IIIs—the ones with the short 50mm barrels.

As for the aircraft, the whole thing is a complete fabrication. They claim to be using a 1943–44 setup—that’s a lie.

I suppose you’ve just gotten used to the status quo. Keep it up, then—and let Gaijin keep it up, too. A P-51C-10 from 1944 sits at a 4.0 BR, while the Soviet Yak-3 (from July 1944) is at 4.3 BR, and the Yak-1B (from October 1942) is at 3.3!

Thanks to you, air simulation battles are effectively dead.

I’ve written so much about this whole engine business, yet you’re still just doing things your own way. Honestly.

The Bf 109 currently uses the DB 601E engine; the G-2 uses the DB 605A, and the G-6 uses the DB 605 AM.

If they used the same engine, they would deliver the same performance; even if its top speed appears lower, the G-6 has excellent acceleration.

Corsair, do me a favor—don’t bother explaining anything else to this guy.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

No, no it wasn’t the best armor.

The T-34’s advantage was how quick it was to produce on a relatively decent platform. It was MISERABLE for the crew in cross country conditions.

The concept of sloped armor existed long before the T-34 and it only forced standardization.

Looks inside German TT C-3602 at. 2.7 (1944), Ta-154 A-1 at 4.0 (1944), IA.58 Pukara at 4.3 (1969), BV 155 B-1 at 4.0 (1944).

None of what you wrote has basis in reality.

And you should play every tech tree and probably spend some 10 hours flying your enemies’ aircraft each, ideally against people good enough to force you to not make mistakes to win. Such makes you a better pilot.

I started flying the 109 f4 to get better at defeating it and i gell in love with it because she handles like a right charm.

As for your hyperbole: i bring measurements. What do you have to bring?

Look, my friend, I don’t just play on weekends like you do; I play pretty much all the time.

I feel like a little kid asking, “How many hours do you have on Steam?”

Believe me, I’ve gone up against P-51C-10s far more times than you have.

We’ve explained things to you at length, yet you’ve fixated on a single claim regarding turn-fighting—a scenario that happens maybe once in a thousand matches. In that situation, the P-51C-10 actually has the advantage; even if an opponent—like a Yak-3—stubbornly tries to force a turn-fight, the P-51C-10 is unlikely to lose. It has incredible energy retention and stays in the fight remarkably well.

Just to reiterate: P-51C-10 (1944) versus Bf 109 F-4 (May 1941).

There’s no point in continuing this discussion with someone as fanatical and romanticized in their views as you.

*In fact, I’m playing right now.

  • You’re claiming—though even that is debatable—that it has better acceleration and turn rates starting from zero speed; yet, that is the very last thing the P-51 series would ever rely on. You’ve skillfully lured me into this trap and steered the entire discussion toward this specific point.

#However, in almost every other respect, the P-51 C-10 is a superior aircraft to the Bf 109 F-4.

ju 288, 1940
*Let’s say it was 1942. Something was done using DB 610 engines.

The kind used in the He 177.

I don’t like the aircraft you call the “Pucará,” and I don’t think it was the right decision to add it to the game.

To be honest, factors like the era of production—whether it’s WWII, the post-war period, or the Cold War—the design philosophy behind the vehicle, and how these machines actually encountered one another on the battlefield are far more important to me.

In short, you’ve come around to my point of view.

Vehicles designed for the conditions of WWII (such as the Yak-9 or Tiger II) should not be pitted against vehicles built for post-war conditions that incorporate later technological advancements (like the Pucará, Char 25t, or AMX-50 TOA100).

Parry, are you saying that the Panzer IV has a better potential for deflecting shots than the T-34?

Ah, so first we complain about differences in 1 or 2 years as if it is extreme bias, but when Germany gets the same examples, it suddenly changes to era of production. I am sure that means you want to remove the only light vehicles that can compliment the Tiger 2, the M41 and JPz 4-5, right?

They are, after all, cold war developments