The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

The T-44 can pen the Tiger 2 Scheinturm in the MG port(risky shot due to volumetric) and cupola if you get a angle where u are above the Tiger 2 yet the depression will let you aim down. (I don’t actually have T-44 but I have the STP with the same ammo)

1 Like

Irrelevant, they are at higher BRs

3 Likes

Pot meet kettle.

Irrelevant.

If a tank can pen the tank in question in arcade or realistic, it can do so in simulation. There is no difference other than camera position.

So go ahead, flag me a third time as 'off topic".

2 Likes

Folks, I’m talking about SIMULATION BATTLES.

The tank in question—the Tiger II (H)—is among the playable tanks available.

Go to the lobby, click on “Stream and Replay,” and search for my name. From there, look for the “Battle of Alaska” event on October 22nd—check it out for yourself and see whether it’s there or not.

How can anyone be this ignorant? Stop just spouting nonsense without knowing the facts.

And two people even “liked” it—what a joke, sounds like a bunch of teenagers.

As for you, “Parry”—tell me, is there really no change in engine power, maneuverability, or turret traverse speed?

Or let me ask you this: have you ever actually played a simulation battle?

Actually, I’ll ask all of you: have any of you ever played in simulation battles?

Someone once said that the percentage [of players who do] doesn’t even exceed 1%—I guess they were right.

Conversations with the T44 100 become completely pointless.

Says the one that’s been doing nothing but spouting passive aggressive backhanded comments since they started this thread. The average age among the playerbase as a whole seems to be late 20s to mid 40s.

This wasn’t the scope of the conversation, don’t shift the topic.

1 Like

It’s ridiculous to try to use Sim Battles as an excuse to try to discredit others. Its not that different from Realistic, the tanks weakpoints dont change.

4 Likes

what?

and if what you mean by this is

then stop talking about T-44s and the conversation will leave T-44s as a topic

1 Like

I’ve heard enough. Maus to 13.3

3 Likes

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

The Tiger II and T-44-100 can also see each other in realistic battles and no one complains about it there. I know whats different about Simulator and Realistic. What’s NOT different is ballistics. Rangefinding, aiming, and armor are all exactly the same as realistic. If a vehicle is overpowered in Realistic, it will also be overpowered in Simulator but its very rare for a vehicle to be balanced in Realistic and overpowered in Simulator. Haven’t you noticed by now that no one else complains about the EBR amd T-44? You are the only one that struggles against these vehicles and is has nothing to do with game mode.

That only happens in arcade, you have barely played ground realistic at all, you dont even properly understand the scouting mechanics.

3 Likes

I’ve been playing this game since tanks were first added—and even before that.

The mechanics are quite clear. In simulation battles, you have to put in more effort just to see your surroundings. When you mark an enemy in sim battles, it doesn’t show up in the game world; you can only see their location on the map. I hope you can grasp how significant a difference that is.

As for the T-44, if you had read the previous messages, you’d know the discussion was about whether or not a Tiger II’s turret could be penetrated. We established that the ammunition used by the T-44-100 actually has better penetration capabilities than that of the IS-2.

Also, please don’t try to mirror my own arguments back at me.

The exact same problem we’re seeing now occurred when tank simulation battles were first introduced. Back when the Panther D was active, the T-34-85 was pitted against the Panzer IV H. Just like you’re claiming now, nobody on the forum was raising any objections back then either. I brought it up, and subsequently, the Panther D series was added to that battle bracket.

Just because no one is talking about it doesn’t mean there isn’t a problem.

There is a problem, plain and simple.

There were even people here who defended the initial bomber patch—back when you couldn’t bring down a bomber even after emptying all your ammo (like 4x MK 103 rounds) into it. In reality, a bomber would explode after taking just 3 or 4 hits, but for the sake of “buffing” them, they were turned into something akin to the Death Star.

Just stick to “Realistic” battles and have your fun there. Don’t worry—the tiers of the vehicles you like won’t be raised in Realistic mode.

The topic here is SIMULATION BATTLES.

Irrelevant for armor penetration

Which is why its at a higher battle rating. You keep moving the goalpost as well, you originally complained about the original T-44, then switched to the T-44-100 when others proved you wrong.

And yet you dont have ANYONE agreeing with you. You are not the only one who plays Sim battles

Yes thats what im talking about

2 Likes

Let me break this down point by point. Vehicles like the T-44-100 and the Char 25t are participating in battles that also feature the Tiger II (H) and various Panther models (A, G, and F).

There is no issue with the T-44-100 being present; however, while another forum member previously argued that the T-44 stands no chance against a Tiger II, I pointed out that the “100” variant actually possesses ammunition with better penetration capabilities than even the IS-2.

In short, German medium tanks fall short when facing these vehicles. Consequently, players often turn to the Ferdinand, Jagdtiger, or Tiger II—but the inherent sluggishness of these machines becomes their undoing. Agile medium tanks that manage to flank or infiltrate the front lines can easily ambush them; French vehicles equipped with autoloader systems, in particular, turn the experience into a nightmare.

And that’s not even mentioning the French medium-heavy tanks.

Furthermore, I maintain that the T-44 is more effective than the Panther series, thanks to its superior mobility, compact profile, and frontal hull armor. Historically speaking, it is clear that the T-44 was developed specifically as a counter to the Panther series.

Furthermore, since the front section of the T-44’s turret is somewhat narrower and the turret itself rotates more quickly, it can aim much faster.

It is also worth noting that the front armor of the IS-2 '44 and ‘M’ models is not particularly easy to penetrate.

I need to explain certain points to you in the finest detail.

Let’s also look at the “mirroring” aspect: the T-44 has a higher Battle Rating (BR) than the Panther series—6.7 compared to 6.0.

And for the record, you once accused me of being the only one speaking up about this.

Well, nearly 12 years ago—back when the Panther D was already in the game, but the Panzer IV h served as the primary battle tank against the T-34-85—I argued on the old forum, just as I am doing now, that the situation was unfair and that the Panther D should be included in those specific simulation battles. and then it had been added.

Unless what I have written is deleted by the forum administration, this is the final response you will receive from me.

Writing lengthy, detailed, and substantial texts in response to your two- or three-sentence posts is a waste of my time.

Happy forum-ing.

I offered a counterpoint and you just repeated yourself and ignored my entire argument. I understand what you are saying but you still have not given any meaningful reason as to why this is relevant only to simulator battles.

No one is forcing you to write so much. Sorry for being concise I guess

2 Likes

Bf 109 F-4 is one of the best 4.0 aircraft. What the hell are you on about @IrzDüşmanı

Why are you complaining that the 109 F-4 is higher than Yak-1B? It can beat it consistently.

It can even beat the 4.7 Yak-3 if both pilots are of comparable skill, although it is a toss-up.

Hell, the 109 F-4 can do well way up to 5.7 as long as you leave the spitfires alone.

As for the 109 F-4 vs P-51C: Sure, P-51C might turn better at 800 km/h. You know what you can do better?

If you are chasing a P-51C and it does a break turn… go up. High-yoyo. Barrel roll. German planes are incredible at “going up” to nullify issues with closure and radius.

If you feel like cheesing things, apply nose up trim. Nose up trim overcomes control stiffening and allows you to do some very stupid maneuvers.

If you do not believe me regarding 109 F-4 Vs Yak-1B or Yak-3, I am more than happy to demonstrate against your yak-1B or Yak-3.

K-4 and G-6/-14 do quite decent against their own respective P-51s as well. I mostly stick to my F-4 though, but I can assure that your complaints about “they retain energy too well” likely has to do with tactics based on ill-informed foundations. I recommend finding someone much better than you and throwing yourself at them until you start scratching their paint. Your complaints for random EC matchups will evaporate unless it’s LF Mk IX/Ki-84/Ju288.

Don’t bother trying to get 1v1 from him. I’ve tried multiple times.

2 Likes

It’s not as easy to abuse APHE when you’re going up against 200mm of armour attached to a cannon with over 230mm of penetration. People complain about T-34’s but the “weak” PzIV from the F-2 onwards can frontally penetrate said “OP” T-34’s without even aiming, the entire front of the tank is a one-shot kill other than a teensie slither on the gun mantlet that is barely a pixel wide.

It does when said armour is also mounted to an extremely high penetrating gun with an overwhelming one-shot kill capability and average to above average mobility.

USA tanks lack the firepower and armour of Germany.

No, they aren’t. I had a debate about this a while back with another forum member where we discovered that the Panther has a faster turning circle (without neutral steer) than the supposedly “more agile” Sherman Firefly, it’s also very competent cross country losing very little speed over hills. The Tiger II is also far from a slow tank.

No it doesn’t and why is the Tortoise bad?

Because it doesn’t have broken APHE to abuse and it’s slow, it’s also arguably less armoured than the Ferdinand. Meanwhile the Ferdinand can fight at lower brackets than the Tortoise… but Germany suffers, right?

In regards to the T-95 you said armour didn’t matter as much as other stats. So considering that’s the T-95’s only strength (the gun only has 20mm more pen than the 88mm) I find this odd.

But you’re admitted that the “op” Russians do have it worse?

The Panther will annihilate a T-34 at ranges where the T-34 can’t even scratch it. The Panther is also no slouch where speed is concerned and has very competent armour. The T-34 has to aim for the turret it most instances and pray to the snail that RNG is on his side as the Panther has a bouncy turret… the Panther can fire centre mass and delete the Russian, big difference.

As above. Take the Firefly and count the time it takes for a full circle. Now do the same with the Panther, use 3rd or 4th gear and it’s noticeably quicker.

Nope as mentioned above. Test it yourself. The Panther holds its speed just as well over hills too.

I’ve seen plenty of Panther II’s, but this would be just anecdotal from the pair of us at this point.

Go into the armour viewer against the 4.0 T-34 and observe how the T-34 can’t penetrate the UFP nor the turret where the tracks sit at 500m in regards to the PzIV(H). Now do the same in reverse and observe how the Panzer can one-shot the T-34 literally everywhere from the front.

Not with the turret but with the UFP with tracks the armour is over 100mm. Considering the T-34’s are largely firing rounds that have almost dead on 100mm pen off memory at 10m I’d say that’s pretty damn strong. Even the M4A2 Sherman only gets APHE with 104mm of pen which again can’t penetrate it beyond point blank. Meanwhile the Panzer can kill that through the tracks aiming centre mass.

50mm + 25mm tracks. Doesn’t sound like much but it’s still enough to shrug off low pen rounds like that of the T-34’s are firing at all but stupidly close range (96mm pen/T-34 1942). Meanwhile once again the Panzer can kill anything without aiming for weakspots. I fail to see how Germany gets dunked on.

It’s worse than the Sherman whilst being similar to the T-34. It also doesn’t even need to aim as mentioned above, just go centre mass and click.

Not really, it’s worse than the T-34 and more or less on par with the Shermans. I’d gladly swap that teensie bit of extra weight if it means I can bounce most of what is thrown my way whilst having 30-40mm more penetration with OPHE than my rivals.

So have I, we’ll have to agree to disagree on this one.

Tiger 2 has the same weakspots to everybody and they aren’t that hard to hit. This is the only tanmk you’re referring to

Yeah, except that shell can also easily bounce, and the T-34 is a better tank overall in the game outside of this matchup

You are just massively overrating german tanks.

No they don’t. 6.0-6.7 has plenty of it. Before that, USA is better because of stabilizers, mobility, and soft stats

Yeah, they are. No two ways about it.

Yeah believe it or not the firefly isnt the pinnacle of mobility being the worst mobility sherman even behind the Jumbo

You are just lying. SImple. All wrong information. Especially the part where you try to claim the Tiger 2 isnt slow

Yes, it does.

You shouldn’t. I don’t make the game

I never said russia was OP. I did say they are balanced into Germany, and they are. The Tiger 2 is just stronger meta wise but the IS-2 is not weak.

These aren’t even the same BR tanks except for the T-34-85 STP and that thing has a stabilizer and can pen the Panther no matter the angle so I’d like to see you beat it anywhere up close

Uhh, they are slow. Once upon a time they were faster. They have been nerfed, even very recently.

Try using the non-slowest sherman tank in the game

I have massive experience in this game. I’ll trust that considering I’ve played every single one of these vehicles and spaded all of them

You pen the UFP when there arent tracks, you pen the turret face anywhere there is no tracks, and you pen the side armor even if you only see a sliver of it

Ok? So shoot all the spots where it’s 80mm or 50mm on the turret. OR 30mm on the side

No. 50mm. That’s it. There is always naked turret.

Because you think pen is all that matters while the Panzer 4 has the weakest armor of the 3 mediums, the weakest mobility of the 3 mediums, reloads slower than the sherman, doesnt have a stabilizer, has worse soft stats across the board, etc.

Not how that works

I’m not going to have a followup comment here as you are just blatantly misrepresenting the tanks

It’s slower now after the horsepower nerf but for a heavy I’d still argue it’s fairly quick.

There’s definitely faster heavies though.

1 Like