The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

The Spitfires have harder FM’s in general than 109’s. You play on a PS5 controller like me I’d imagine. I can fly a 109 as straight as an arrow. Now pull some sharp turns in the Spitfires and observe how you’re skidding all over the place.

If you want realistic engine controls then you might be shocked to notice that 109’s that rely on the engine computer/auto prop pitch would be atrociously bad. Both old accounts and modern flight reports state that the auto controls on 109’s were sub par at extracting the actual performance of the aircraft and green pilots were easy to spot as they lagged behind those more experienced that manually adjusted pitch etc.

If we want to get into how German pilots apparently have it bad in regards to FM’s I’d love it if Gaijin added more realism into the 109’s FM. Say goodbye to your somewhat generous high speed mobility and welcome slat snatching in early 109’s along with increased torque effects in later 109’s so they crab similarly to the Spitfires. As it is at the moment the 109E’s slats might as well be F models as they work perfectly no matter how you abuse the aircraft and I can keep all 109’s flying straight just with aileron correction… something that absolutely should not be possible as seen with the Spitfires.

Also as a final note I use AEC and whilst the early 109’s can overheat the later models are much more robust, on average they’re much more idiot friendly than Spitfires. Go take the Mk1 Spitfire for a spin and observe how it almost instantly overheats with WEP and then continues to burn itself out on 100%. To make matters worse for whatever reason they also completely ruined its roll rate over 200mph. Off memory the time it takes to roll is not far off of double that of what it could do in reality.

1 Like

As someone who plays il2…

Lol.

Yaks and spitfire engine controls are easy. You dont need spreadsheets for them.

@IrzDüşmanı you really should try playing other games or getting familiar with the aircraft before making questionable statements.

Manual engine controls are nowhere as challenging as people imply then to be. Most aircraft operate quite well on a set and forget basis too.

The only complication tends to be fuel consumption which is a non issue in wt and even in il2 it is usually a non issue even on combat box. It is mostly just “do i run my engine cold but waste fuel or do i run my engine in a safe hot range and minimize fuel consumption”. Oh and maybe for yaks you need to dial back mixture with altitude nut you rarely go high enough for it to matter. Western planes usually adjust mixture automatically.

Some western planes like Dstangs only got 1 mixture setting: run. Technically 2 due to idle cut off but that isnt rly a relevant setting.

Thats it. That is all the mixture settings you need to think about.

2 Likes

I played a bit in the P-51 D-10. It’s great that they get on my tail but can’t catch up.

Also, I managed to out-turn a Bf 109 G-2—without even using my flaps—and shot it down. Yep.

Who knows what the even lighter C-10 variant might be capable of.

I have this sunday and monday off. We can try in customs. I tried to contact you last saturday but you have chat off.

For what it’s worth, the average EC and Ground SB player does not fly their planes optimally.

Craziest example: AegleFinder in his Yak-3 taking out 2 Spitfire LF Mk IX in a dogfight.

But a more grounded one…

I have once did some bf 109 F-4 vs bf 109 F-4 practice vs a random guy in wing’s discord and they constantly got outturned by my Bf 109 F-4 because I was more willing to pull my virtual stick back and hold it there.

1 Like

I’ve actually got to make a correction here, I’ve just flown the F Mk IX in test flight and a lot of that torque is gone, it feels much more controllable now. Has anyone else noticed this?

The Mk I still rolls like a bomber though sadly above 240mph. Odd considering our Mk I has the metal ailerons I believe.

Only straight ahead from the top, slighly angled and the shells bounce off all the time or shatter.

My longest kill is 3600m, there are lots of open maps and my average engagement distance is around 500-800m.

And british heavies 33km/h while they can be pierced in the hull while angling or not by any tank with 88mm which are a lot in german tech tree.

long 88mm is available for a lot more german tanks in this event and it wrecks everything it meets frontally from any distance with one shot.

They will flank sluggish british heavies and kill them with one shot, the same as other allied meds can flank german heavies. Now 1vs1 frontally with french tanks is a matter of who fires first, HE filler in panther’s long 75mm makes the first shot more likely to destroy french tank than other way around.

another stupid claim, Allied mediums can be countered by all German/Italian/Japan mediums in this event.

I’m not lying, showing you facts. I see you are getting more annoyed now that all your statements are so easily crushed when confronted with facts. Just learn to deal with your emotions and understand the text.

I am now convinced you don’t have Panther II and just cry to get it, right?

Yeah I fly spits a lot actually and now you said that, yes at takeoffs recently I noticed I don’t have to counter and trim that heavily anymore, to be honest in turns MkIX feels kind of heavy now.
Still MkIXLF even though it is awesome… in 6.3 event facing Ki-84 has no chance. I have actually once been outturned by MB-326, although it was this russian squad, always 2-3 of them in most OP airplanes in SBGF, usually wrecking over half of enemy team. I don’t complain, I usually try to challenge myself and shot down at least one of them.

On the other hand I noticed P-59A has been added to the 6_1 lineup in that event, when did this happen? When I checked 3-4 weeks ago, I am sure it was at 6.7BR in SB and I could not pick it up to counter MB-326. I took it recently for few battles and to be honest I have outturned Ki-84 in P-59A against a very skilled Ki-84 abuser ;) and after 3min dogfight with him, once… he won the second time.

1 Like

It’s quite interesting that you only log into the game two days a week, yet you come here to offer advice—and you’re wrong most of the time, too.

For the record, I use a joystick; I have no experience with a mouse and keyboard.

Yesterday, I was up against an FW 190 A-4, a 109 F-4, and that notorious American beast, the P-51 C-10.

The 109 F-4 was on the P-51’s tail—it had likely won the turn fight—but as soon as the P-51 went into a dive, it quickly pulled away. Even though I was in an A-4 with an energy advantage, I chased it until my engine was on the verge of cracking—with my radiators set to zero—but I still couldn’t catch it; it just kept pulling away.

That’s exactly what I’m talking about. These guys don’t bother with turning; they just fly away, and you can’t catch them. If the pilot had been better at maneuvering, he might have even out-turned the F-4.

Furthermore, the person I was fighting was a simulation player who handled his aircraft quite well. I had a similar duel with the person I got into an argument with on this forum—he was using the C-10 in the exact same way.

In short, trying to analyze an aircraft based on a 1v1 duel is absurd. It has no real-world equivalent in a typical match; once you get into a dogfight, someone else is bound to swoop in from the side and take you out.

The last thing a P-51 C-10 pilot would ever do is get into a sustained dogfight with you.

Let’s also keep in mind that the P-51 C-10 entered service in early 1944, marking the beginning of American dominance. And don’t underestimate the P-38s, either—they possess incredible maneuverability.

You go right ahead and keep living in your 1v1 fantasy world.

Let’s talk about you, Sputnik. From what I’ve seen in-game, you don’t actually know how to play—you just camp.

And you mostly play Allied vehicles.

The Mk.3 shell does penetrate; you’re lying. Matches often take place at close range—just look at how many urban combat maps there are. I couldn’t care less about your records; the common complaint among most tankers is that engagements happen at such close quarters—which is perhaps to be expected in a city, though it creates an unfair disadvantage for others. I don’t know.

The Germans, encircling British forces? In matches featuring the Tiger II (H)? You’re a total amateur. You have no idea how the game works. Honestly, I suspect you’re doing this on purpose.

You refuse to grasp the point: in matches involving the Tiger II (H), players almost exclusively choose the Tiger II (H) or tank destroyers, because medium tanks are simply ineffective.

For instance, I played some matches yesterday and today at the Tiger II (P) tier, where the G and F series [Panzer IVs] can actually be useful. Sure, there are still issues there, but I’ll address those another time—like, what on earth is the AMX M4 doing in this tech tree?

But in matches with the Tiger II (H), it’s blatantly obvious that medium tanks are completely ineffective.

And it is precisely because of this problem that models like the 10.5cm Tiger, Panther II, and various anti-aircraft vehicles were added—in an attempt to fix these issues—though, in my opinion, even these models fall short in certain respects.

You are someone who lies blatantly, plays as the Allies, and distorts the truth as if there are no problems with the game at all.

You stubbornly refuse to talk about the French auto-loaders.

In reality, I suspect the root of the problem lies with the developers, who seem to have the mental maturity of 14- or 15-year-olds. They’ve turned the game into something akin to Resident Evil.

The second group to blame consists of the Axis players who have simply accepted everything as it is.

The solution is actually quite simple: stop playing.

For any new developers, this is a massive opportunity.

If only they could rescue us from all this nonsense.

So what do you want, the Americans to have no advantages or Germany to have all of them? You just stated that in a turning fight you beat him… with that Mustang having more speed it’s not just more realistic it’s also balanced.

In another note having the Mustang extend from your 109 is somewhat similar to 190A’s running away from every Spitfire they encounter until the LF IX.

Be above them and dive on them then if they aren’t in a furball. I believe the F-4 outclimbs the C-10 along with out turning it.

In the same way that in your 109 you should never attempt any prolonged dive after a C-10.

We’ve debunked this already, even War Thunder’s own wiki states: " Deliveries of the P-51C to the US Army Air Force (USAAF) began in August 1943". Once again your F-4 is running 1943 engine settings so it’s pretty on point.

Having a job is cringe, m’kay.

2 Likes

I mean it didn’t with the v 1650 7 engine, v 1650 3 yes.

Eventually you grow up, get a positive win rate and a K/D above 3 in your Tiger II and you realise that all the complaints like this thread are pointless.

Unfortunately some people can apparently play the game for 14 years and never learn.

That’s why you need to know how to end the fight.

Also, I saw someone record fights with you. Watched those.

You have lots of room to improve. I do too.

Difference is, I try to find people who are better than me and challenge them to beat me repeatedly over, and over, and over again so that the next time I get beaten slightly less embarrassingly. I take pride in my willingness to try and fail.

Whereas for you, your complaints are all about “X can MAYBE beat me.” For you, the mere notion of being able to lose seems to be a travesty beyond all atrocities.

If you made an effort at self-improvement rather than tilting at windmills, your complaints would be reduced significantly.

There are legitimate issues in the game and your complaining is diluting our collective messaging towards gaijin. Gaijin sees people refusing to learn and improve and make complaints and can consequently assume all complaints derive from the same font of learned helplessness.

You could instead make complaints about lobby shopping, about bomber damage models, about botting, about people J-ing out to deny kills intentionally, about broken spotting systems, against crew skills and other nonsense.

But no.

You refuse to seek self-improvement and complain that other people MAY beat you in a fair fight. You want unfair fights. You want to fight I-16 or Lagg-3 with a Gustav or other nonsense.

1 Like

You’re wrong to make such definitive claims.

Some even say it entered service in early 1944.

What’s this nonsense about a “43 engine setting”? Could you explain that?

Since you can’t come up with any other arguments to defend your position, you’ve started making things up.

For the record, I don’t claim to be superior in every aspect—the Allied team, facing the German tech tree, doesn’t exactly leave room for that anyway.

Even the base P-51 is in a strong position regarding its dive performance, top speed, and armament. Its energy retention is incredible—much like other P-51 variants—allowing it to “hang” in the air, similar to a Yak-3.

Honestly, if you can’t catch an enemy due to their high speed, having a better turn rate or a better climb rate doesn’t really offer any advantage.

The British, the Russians, and these American P-51 models all turn well—so what are the Bf 109s and Fw 190s supposed to do? “Dive from above and climb back up”—well, any plane can do that. The difference is that the aircraft from those other three nations can still climb effectively even after a turn, without losing their energy.

By the way, we are talking about SIMULATION BATTLES.

And finally, Auren—your kill-to-death ratio doesn’t tell us anything about the game as a whole.

Are you a little kid, trying to brag about yourself?

Not once have I mentioned the I-16 or the LaGG-3.

Don’t be dishonest.

My point is that equivalent models—counterpart aircraft—should be balanced against one another.

The La-5FN or La-5F could be a match for the F-4; however, you can’t pit a Yak-3 against a Bf 109 G-6—the Yak-3 is on the same level as a G-14.

Besides, the topic here isn’t Soviet aircraft.

If you want to broaden the scope, then yes—I do want to see the T-34-76 facing the Tiger I.

You’ve started resorting to underhanded, dishonest tactics.

The P-51C-10 doesn’t belong at a 4.0 Battle Rating (BR); it should be at least 4.7. The standard P-51 is a perfectly capable and well-balanced opponent for the F-4.

You did by crying about historical match-ups.

I-16 or Lagg-3 were contemporaries of 109 F-2 and 109 F-4 at Muscow.

The Yak-3 can be beaten by a Bf 109 F-4. I could demonstrate this to you in 5 hours.

Your origin is wrong.

However, the P-51C could go up to 4.3 or 4.7.

AT THE SAME TIME.

P-51D5 could go down to 4.0

Or 4.3.

The D5 mustang is pitiful.

The Fw 190 suffers.

The Bf 109 F-4?

It turns better than american planes that aren’t captured planes or early war nonsense.

You get into a fight the the p-51, end it as fast as you can then reset to altitude.

Here’s a random ancient Bf 109 F-4 game I had.

Allied planes very very s c a r e e.

And this is a very old video I have where I was much worse at the game. You probably are better than i was at this time.

That’s a 3.7-4.7 BR day btw. At least 4.3 minimum, given the yak-3s. Got a 5 kill life in the 109 F-4 with somewhat competitive opponents (KrinnyTTV)

For some reason, the C-10 is missing; why don’t you also record a video of yourself taking down a C-10—even if it’s just an amateur pilot flying it?

Besides, a Bf 109 F-2 could also shoot down a Yak-3; does that make it a good plane?

And what about high-speed maneuverability—which one turns better? Which one has a better top speed, and which one has shells that are absurdly more effective? Which one handles more smoothly?

I’m tired of having to come up with counterarguments to your nonsensical claims.

It seems like a keyboard and mouse setup might actually be the way to go; perhaps we’re just being fools for playing with a joystick.

Don’t underestimate the D5 series so much; I mentioned that I outturned a G2 using a D10. Their gameplay is similar.

This is not me, this is a buddy in her Fw 190 in sim:

Recorded in replays.

These are me:

this is a P-51D:

Random 109 K-4 nonsense:

Just a random cool moment:

Random 109 nonsense:

Now a random 109 G-2 too.

This is from when i was very new to sim - 109 G-2 vs P-51D:

https://old.reddit.com/r/WarthunderSim/comments/1jqllhx/german_planes_are_fun_shouldve_died_a_hundred/

Anyway, 109 F-4 vs your yak-3? In 1 hour? 2 hours? 3 hours?

I told you to add the amateurs.

Yeah, you added them. Bravo—you’re such a “big-time” player.

Look, my friend, we’ve taken down plenty of C10s ourselves; it seems you’ve never actually faced any real professionals.

You asked?

Hell, in one of the earlier videos you can see Feetpics kill me in my 109 F-4 with a P-47.