The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

German tanks are very good and I played a lot of them.
Let’s take for example DF105 vs all ruskies, 5s reload, fast, many times I survived frontal hit, because of the engine at the front and it just eats the T54s, IS-3s and other ruskie cans for breakfast.

My Panther D / Tiger H1 mix pair is one of my all time most succesfull tanks.
Pumas succesfully can dominate two first tiers of SB battles.
KV I 756 - that was a total dominator before nerf and people learned how to fight it.

Listen, genius—we’re talking about the absolute monsters that the Tiger II (H) and its peers have to face. The game is live right now; go see for yourself.

The Tiger I (H) and the Panther D-series are fine vehicles, but the developers tried to “balance” things by pitting them against agile, slippery tanks like the ARL-44, M18, and T20—not to mention those wretched, overpowered KV-1 variants.

1 Like

I went and saw for myself:

Although I preffer do rat stuff with Fox today, I tried one game with Tiger II H + Jgdpanther G1.
I like the fact that I didn’t have to aim much at weakspots, IS-2 or T-44-100 just blew up.

1 Like

You can’t draw conclusions about the whole based on a single game.

I also have matches where I get 10 or 12 kills.

I don’t I draw conclusion on what I saw during 13 years in this game.
I never suffered with Germans, well maybe top tier I don’t play in general because of he he russian bias :D

1 Like

So, are you saying that the French series of medium tanks—which feature an autoloader, high mobility, a fast-rotating turret, superior ammunition, and better armor—are worse than the Panther series?

In my opinion, you are lying so as not to lose the advantage you have.

Same here i guess…

[Axis] you mean italy. And yes, “technically” right now Allies can’t buy [in game] a jet that matches MB-326B, but that doesn’t mean it has no counters. Let me remind you of P-59A “zero” of the jets, Strikemaster Mk.88 that ws ruining matches before 326 and last, but not least BI the busted rocket fighter.

Brother it’s not an Air SIM where you get a ton of free space before contact. Me262 doesn’t have an acceleration. Yes, give him time and he’ll get to that point, but on most maps: you take off and can see enemies airfield. Just don’t give him the opportunity.

Tu-1/2’s- no comment
Pe 8- no comment [4.0-5.0]
TIS MA- no comment [4.0-5.0] (K*S!)
A-26’s- no comment
Lincoln/Lancaster- no comment

We can go lower, find another busted planes 90% of them on ally side.

Don’t make me laugh, outside of countering M551(76), Pt76-57 and Fox, it doesn’t do anything. By the way it can be 50.called…so yeah what a bummer.

That is a bigger problem that needs explanation. Short answer: low player pool. P.s. some of those players with “fake german” tanks are lvl 57-80, so basicly: bought accs.

Yes and yes they are toxic AF and should be moved to cold war presets.

But with what you sad just there, these vehicles also comes to this “list”: Pt76-57, Pt76, ASU-85, M53/59, object 416, SU-100P, by the way BR-412D for 100mm guns is from 1954.
M36B2, ECL bis/901, M51, Fox…and the list goes on and on.

Yes, there is no “perfect” balance, but i think you are wearing some sunscreen glasses.

Your conclusion is simply dumb, where did I mention French tanks at all?
I don’t even have French tanks.

Again, Germans are not suffering any more than other countries.

If current 6.3 BR battle had P-59A then I would happily try to clear the MB-326B spam.
Who owns BI anyway? I saw it once today and to be honest I never saw it before in battle or it was so long ago I don’t even remember.

All the bombers should get gunner view unstabilized and attached to the airplane, not the current 3rd person view stabilized to the horizon.
All the bombers should get manually set up bombsight, not this CCIP computer they always had.
Only then they should be allowed into SB. But that’s not going to happen sadly.

1 Like

My friend, you’re playing the German tech tree—are you really unaware of the enemies you’re facing?

I suspect you know perfectly well, but you’re choosing to feign ignorance.

Here’s a task for you: go open up the Tank Simulator mode right now, look at the Tiger II (H), and examine the French, Soviet, and British vehicles it faces. We’ve given you countless examples, yet you continue to insist on doing things your own way.

Still, for the sake of people like you, I’ll explain it again.

In Simulator battles, where the Tiger II (H) serves as the primary heavy tank, German medium tanks fall short. The opposing team can easily destroy the Panther series without even needing precise, careful aim.

Furthermore, the enemy’s medium tanks—many of which entered production after 1950, during the Korean War era—are far more agile, faster, possess superior turret traverse speeds, and carry much better ammunition.

Even though the Tiger II might seem flawless on paper, its sluggishness makes it difficult to secure good positions, leaving it highly vulnerable to ambushes.

To put the current state of German medium tanks into perspective, consider this:

A Panther D facing a T-34 (76mm).

What really bothers me is that some players in the German tech tree act as if there’s no problem at all. Some even come here and claim there’s no issue—which, in your case, feels like a deliberate choice.

After encountering these French “monsters,” I stopped playing the Tiger II (H) entirely. Now, I mostly fly the Ju 288—not because I enjoy it, but to accumulate enough currency to acquire vehicles in future events.

Again some generic texts, is AI generating them for you?

How would you balance the sheer volume of players who want to play T2H, Jagdtigers, Ferdinands if they faced only tanks that cannot even pen them from the front?
Because what I see is you are complaining that you cannot simply drive T2H forward and bounce everything…

1 Like

They all have counterparts—take the Tortoise or the T28, for example.

Furthermore, these heavy tanks aren’t effective, given that the game essentially boils down to urban combat.

Every time I log in, the matches are flooded with Tiger IIs. If a player makes one careless mistake or takes a single hit from an explosive shell, they’re effectively out of the match. Because of this, they end up playing timidly; meanwhile, opponents can take a risk, survive a near-miss, and then easily neutralize these heavy tanks.

Look at how you’re dishonestly steering the conversation away from the point.

My friend, there are no German medium tanks in the game—that’s the whole problem. The enemy’s medium tanks are far more functional. Take the Centurion Mk. 3 or the Sho’t Mk. 3, which entered service in 1948—they can punch right through anything, including the Tiger II. The same goes for the French “automatic” monsters and the Soviet T-44. As for the Americans, the M26—while its ammunition might not be as potent as the others—at least represents the most realistic and balanced tech tree.

I’ll say it again:

THERE IS A CRISIS REGARDING GERMAN MEDIUM TANKS IN THE GAME; THEY ARE WOEFULLY INADEQUATE.

Even though counterparts exist, the game features superior tanks on the opposing side. Playing the German tech tree is a form of torture—it essentially serves as “fodder” for other players, as if they were just fighting bots.

There is only one solution: bring back the tanks that were removed from the tech tree. If the game can include “paper ships” (fictional or blueprint-only designs) like the H-39, or maps/scenarios based on Stalingrad or Sevastopol, then these vehicles should be brought back as well.

1 Like

Me when naval has different requirements for vehicles to ba valid for addition :3

Big skill issue. That’s it, the whole topic is a one big skill issue rant. Can be closed.

2 Likes

It’s not a matter of skill or anything like that.

The vehicles it faces are simply much better; there is a fundamental problem with the medium tanks.

Enemy tanks can easily destroy their counterparts—and even heavy tanks.

At lower tiers, the Panther D series might also get blown up, but at least there are more agile vehicles available to counter that. When it comes to the German tech tree, they usually take every precaution—sometimes even adding absurd prototypes to the game—but that’s not the case here.

In this situation, the opposition is more agile, possesses superior ammunition, has faster turret traverse and aiming speeds, and the vehicles themselves have a smaller profile.

Whoever designed the original “Simulation” battles must have taken these factors into account, as they included the Panther II, the Tiger 10.5 cm, and the 37mm Panther-based anti-aircraft vehicle to maintain balance. These vehicles are no longer in the game.

It’s all complete nonsense.

And you, for your part, are lying right to my face.

So, if I understand you correctly, you’re claiming that the Panther F and G series can compete on equal footing with the T-44-100, French tanks with 4-second autoloader reload times, and British tanks equipped with ammunition capable of 380mm of penetration? These medium tanks are faster, aim more quickly, and carry better ammunition—capable of penetrating from any angle without requiring any precise aiming.

The French autoloader-equipped vehicles entered service from the 1950s onwards, and the Centurion, which entered service in 1948, uses ammunition with 380mm of penetration.

It is a matter of skill, or to be precise - lack of it.

Your topic in essence became now a rant: “I don’t have Panther II, please give me Panther II and it will change everything”.
The experienced players in Panther IIs are already winning battles for Axis in this event. Giving them to anyone will create total superiority for Axis. Especially that it is such a fantasy tank that didn’t even exist in this form in any design/paper/concept. Gaijin initially mixed up couple of designs together to create this monstrosity, similar story with Coelian and Tiger II 10.5 and recently removed Ho-Ri. Still those vehicles are in game and in every battle there are at least 3-8 of them per team.

You talk about medium tanks crisis for Germans?
British in this even have only one medium - Charioteer which dies from a fart with 3 person crew, is inferior in everything other than speed and pen, to Panthers, and when you manage to get first shot on anyting, you pray the shell does not shatter and you at least kill the gunner. Otherwise there is no second shot for you.

Now the tanks you call “Monsters”, let’s see:
Centurion Mk.3/FV4202 compared to Tiger II H:
The only way to damage Tiger II frontally at any distance, using 20pdr with your mythical 380mm penetration, is turret cheeks. Even then you pray that RNG does not decide your shell shattered because this happens very often to APDS shells, out of nowhere, sometimes even firing at turret side. Frontally you need at least 3 shots, hoping the Tiger II player does not have maxed crew, otherwise his gunner will swap before you reload. If you are lucky your shell might reach the rear ammo rack and if german player is bad, then it might be full of ammo.
At 34 km/h Centurions are slower than any Tiger II especially the 46km/h Sla 16 one, which is a total dominator here.
Now with centurion, you won’t bounce anything only the gun mantle has a chance of stopping german 88mm. So while you have to aim at a weakspot and pray for luck, any german tank with 88mm will just one shot kill you anywhere in the LFP, UFP, turret top, turret cheeks.
Yeah Centurion such a monster…
If Cent 3 was not in this event, then let’s say we move it to next one, it will face T-54s and historically 20pdr was not good enough to kill T-54s, and surprise - in game it would stand no chance.

To summarize: Centurion mk3 - slower than Tiger II, worse armor than Tiger II, worse gun accuracy and post pen damage than Tiger II, the only stat it has advantage - mythical penetration which is prone to RNG shell shatter and often ricochets.

Angled Tiger II on an upper ground at a distance has all the advantages vs 20pdr.
Now even with Panther II or Jagdpanther in 1vs1 scenario, Centurion fires first, if you don’t kill gunner or don’t disable the gun, then in few seconds you are dead with 1 shot in the LFP/UPF ammo rack.
Even Panther F/G can kill it firing at turret top.

There… a “Monster” XD

French AMX and Lorraine 40T have even worse gun and only advantage they have is speed. They die from just looking at them and frontally against an angled Tiger II they stand no chance really if Tiger II player is good.

Basically against allies, the Germans have long 88mm which 1 shot kills all allied tanks, at any distance, with virtually no requirement to aim for weakspots. On many maps they can occupy high ground, with no way to flank them. Add Jagdtiger to the mix and frontally there is very little an allied team can do in an open frontal attack.
The only way is to flank.

Now since you think penetration is such an important value, the Axis team in this event has all those:
Type 61, STA - 1/2/3, M36, M36B - 305mm HEATFS,
FIAT6614, Type 60 - 433mm HEAT
All with good and very good mobility, which allied tank can even survive this hit from any angle/distance?

My advice:
LEARN TO PLAY GERMAN HEAVY TANKS.

1 Like

First of all, Mk3 ammunition is available for other models as well.

And, interestingly enough, they are capable of penetrating the hull.

Furthermore, as you know, the gameplay takes place at absurdly close ranges.

You just don’t want to get it. You claim the Tiger hits a speed of 46 km/h—well, what’s 46? The Tiger II is practically flying along at 66 km/h; there’s no stopping it! To even reach that 46 km/h, it needs a 1–2 km stretch of perfectly flat, open ground.

Yes, the Panther F and G have to aim for the top of the turret—hah!—rather than the front, but you’re overlooking one thing: the opponent can aim much faster, and they don’t even need to target a specific weak point—a single shot to the hull is enough.

But you’re overlooking something—and you’re intentionally trying to mislead people. In battles where the Tiger II (H) appears, you might occasionally see a few Japanese or Italian vehicles—though, in my opinion, those vehicles actually disrupt the integrity of this tech tree. Yet, you stubbornly insist that the Centurion Mk 3s and the French vehicles don’t disrupt it at all.

Oh, and the Panther series is supposedly “so good” that everyone in the game chooses the F or G variants, right? The game just turns into a “Tiger II party.”

No, sir—the Panther II, the 10.5 cm variant, and the 8.8 cm/3.7 cm-equipped vehicles do not disrupt the balance; on the contrary, they help establish it. They might pose a challenge for the American tech tree, though.

The Tiger II is not as mobile as the Tiger I—and that includes the diesel-powered Tiger II variant.

Because these vehicles are sluggish, and since almost every other nation’s tech tree features agile medium tanks, those tanks end up dominating the game—simply because there’s nothing to effectively counter them.

This isn’t a matter of “skill”; it’s a matter of data. You seem to assume everyone else is as amateurish as you—the kind of person who would try to take on a Tiger head-on. These fast tanks use their numerical superiority and maneuverability to easily reposition and corner the Tiger II.

You’re well aware of all this, yet you deliberately choose to deny the reality of the situation.

And what I don’t understand is why we don’t see the people who actually complain about this in-game showing up here to speak about it.

And there is a double standard in the game, too.

They can add made-up ships like the Stalingrad and Sevastopol to the game, yet when it comes to the Axis side, they can simply remove tanks—and they don’t see any problem with that.

And you are lying, plain and simple. You’ve adopted the handle “Sputnik” while defending the German tech tree.

Very convincing.

We shall see whether this double standard remains in effect when a comparable game is released.

In tank battles with a 3.3 Battle Rating (BR) limit, models like the XA-38 and B-18B—which were produced in 1944, 1945, and even 1946—are absolutely wrecking us.

Take this XA-38—or whatever it’s called—this American plane: it’s got 12.7mm machine guns on the top and bottom, it can drop bombs, and it’s equipped with a 75mm cannon. It’s basically a “Death Star,” and it’s making our lives miserable.

I guess it’s time to quit the game; what is this, anyway? Why not just drop the Ju 288 down to 3.3 BR while you’re at it, just for the fun of it? How can you be this shameless? Just because no one says anything, does that give you the right to go this far?

They’re wreaking havoc in the sky like gods, while I’m left here trying to fight back with a pathetic, 1940-era F1.

I really hope a new simulation game comes along so we can finally be free of this Russian nonsense—what on earth is going on here?

What?

Yet Germany has more unfinished ships - With H39 incoming this upcoming patch - than the RU naval tree.

Very odd strawman.

1 Like