The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

Feet plays well. I’ve faced off against him in a G2. Perhaps it has auxiliary applications; I’m not sure.

But one-on-one duels are a different matter entirely.

As I said, even an F-2 series plane could potentially take down a Yak-3. Does that make it a good plane?

I’m fed up with your egos. I’m talking about the overall situation.

Let’s reach an understanding.

Yes, the F-4 is a beast of an aircraft.

Otherwise, you’ll never get tired of the spamming.

It’s worse than 109 F-4 because worse gun.

But she’s more than servicable.

If anyone has ego, it’s the one who bases their balance arguments on “X can beat me/counter me, therefore X is bad” and refuses to listen and keeps moving the goalpost.

It’s a capable plane at a neat battle rating and is capable against enemy fighters that aren’t Spitfire Lf MK IX or Ki-84 or the like.

It can be beaten.

That’s a good thing.

It can beat others but needs to do it smartly*
*aka: more work than ki-84 or lf mk ix.

That’s also a good thing.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

Do you know how to read?

Buddy you have played 16000 battles and Sputnik has played 23460 battles. I’m not sure you have the right to look down on him because of experience

Don’t worry, I was already playing on PS4 even before the tank tree was added to the game.

The usual “if you play less than me your opinion is worthless” and on the opposite side of the spectrum “if you play more than me then you have deviated so far from the norm that your opinion is worthless”

Hypocrisy really. “Respect my authoritah but I won’t respect yours”

For some reason, you always come here looking for a fight.

I’m not going to concern myself with your personal issues.

I’ve seen how Sputnik plays—he just camps at the base and defends the German tech tree.

And he’s only doing it out of dishonesty; he’s afraid of losing the advantage they’ve gained.

Sputnik, defending the German tech tree—Lenin must be spinning in his grave.

When a new game comes out, I suppose you’ll just end up playing against bots.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

Yes, it wobbles more. Decrease sensitivity, it gets more appeasable.

M&K.

I’m shocked to find out that 109’s had engine computer!? Oh wait i’m not, because 109’s didn’t have mechanical computer [kommandogerat], it was used on Fw190’s/Ta152’s basicly on BMW and Jumo engines [Ju87, 88, 188 used different unit] Bf109’s had VDM until E7, where they added an engine governor with linkage to a throttle which controlled power output and governor RPM limit.

For Commandogerat system, read through NACA report.
For what it was, this stuff was ahead of it’s time, sure not everything worked “flawlessly”, but knowing germanies 1944-45 quality control, it did “flawlessly”.

Nonsense, early 109’s [until F4/G] had problems with fuel efficiency so veterans used manual blade pitch.

In the battle of britain, one of the advantages 109 had over Spitfire was high speed turn and better G tolerence. Spitfire’s pilot would black out if he tried to pull the same stunt, why? Different sitting position.

All slats in WT don’t work

…K4 [9/11%] aileron trim Mk24 [-11/-13%]. 3 blades vs 5 blades. What are you talking about? They have allmost the same torque, i’d say with blade difference, K4 has more torque.

…and? F8F will burn itself out as well as Do335. Su11 will burn if left on 100%. Is it hard to understand to turn the power down if you’re not in combat? Better ask yourself, “did it had problems like that IRL or not?”

It’s not the best SIM out there lol.

Only if you deck hug.

While il2 is better in terms off Simulation [if we compare to WT] it’s still “simplifed”.

German tech tree is fine, a few lacking spots at top tier like a heli and a good light tank (the only one got nerfed the last patch so it’s no longer a viable option). Mid and low br german tree is pretty strong. The problem you’re experiencing (I assume) - is that german tech tree is pretty strong but in a very conventional way. Strong armor, good guns. But it is lacking the thing that could be summed up in one word, but it’s a medical term and it’s prohibited here. But it includes all the HEAT, APDS, fast moving rats etc. Game’s balance moved to strongly favor those types of vehicles. Which Germany is lacking. It doesn’t mean that the tree sucks. At worst it’s off meta, but I wouldn’t say so because you still can make it work.
I’m not an ARB prop player so I’m saying it from GRB perspective - German fighters do suck, a lot. Energy fighting, boom’n’zoomi’n whatever, they suck for GRB engagement ranges. I personally think that they got nerfed way too much over the years, but I doubt anything would be done about that.
Funnily enough there’s another nation that suffers the same fate (only with ground tree though) at the same br’s and it’s rusia. Ironically enough fighting against them as Germany at br’s 1.0-7.7 is the most fun you could have.
Just my two cents, doubt you could call my opinion biased or anything, just experience.

Slats work in WT tho? You can literally see them deploy and the best performance turns are literally indicated by having your slats fully deploy (they deploy around 13.0 AOA and best performance is at around 14.5-15.5 deg AoA. It’s not a perfect indicator, but it’s something a lot of people could benefit from as they don’t pull nearly hard enough.)

And from what I’ve heard from others, the Bf 109 K-4’s sustained turn performance matches that of real life tests. Given that the optimal turn relies on the slats, I think we can safely assume the slats do work.

If the reasoning is that in Il-2, 109s seem to stall much later… Tell me if this 109 behaviour looks physically consistent to you.

Bf 109 does post-stall maneuvers with flaps

https://youtu.be/MIEhZWyzeAw?si=Hjr5tWFbELV3eg90
From Combat Box discord:
image
image
This is an Fw190 but it was the only funny german cobra screenie I could find easily.
image

Not Bf 109, Bf 110 but similar german nonsense in il2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwXXQrNffgs&t=57

That’s where the objectives are on both Combat Box and Wings of Liberty are.

Also that’s how you avoid Radar Control Intercept on Combat Box. Fly high and the entire enemy team knows where you are.

Fly low hugging the rivers and mountains and you can get in, climb up to ~2km altitude, dive bomb their airfield, and get out before enemies can respond.

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

1 Like

Decreasing sensitivity is the last thing you want to do, it’ll just make your issues worse.

Really? Because here’s a modern flight report of a pristine 109E with the pilot mentioning how the prop pitch had to be constantly adjusted for maximum performance.

image

A recent update has tweaked the Spitfire’s torque to be lower than it was before. In the past rudder control was absolutely necessary to keep the Spitfire flying straight whereas the 109’s can be flown straight with aileron correction.

The point I’m making is that the 109’s engines for the large part are more idiot friendly than the Spitfires are, which is true. The Mk I in particular is atrociously bad. This is a response to the OP saying Germany has it bad which it most certainly does not (except for the D-9 underperforming).

“Just turn the power down when not in combat”, yeah no sjit Sherlock. The issue is what are you going to do when you’re fighting another aircraft and your engine starts to splutter without even touching WEP? Or you dare to use WEP for 10 seconds and then you need to somehow fight back at 80% throttle when in reality it should be able to use WEP for 3-5 minutes. Even the Mk V Spitfire overheats far too quickly compared to the official manuals.

Yes they do, they just don’t have the negative aspects of them modelled such as snatching as mentioned or speed loss, as mentioned here:

image

Once again that’s a pristine 109E with a pilot that’s clearly flown WW2 aircraft before.

Once again, not true.
image

It’s pretty widely known that the 109’s used to lock up at speed and that even at higher speeds the Spitfire had a sensitive elevator. It’s true that the 109’s seating position allowed the pilot to pull more G’s but that won’t help you when you don’t have the strength nor the room to create proper leverage on the stick to make use of it at very high speeds… also in regards to that seating position, the Spitfire had something similar to that later on:

They don’t. Yes, slats are deploying on visual model, but in files/coding of the game they don’t or stay “allways on”.
Basicly game dev’s been “snails” just coded so that any aircraft with slats gets “+X” in turn pull. It DOES NOT matter if slats deployed or not.

1 Like

Oh, so the only problem these folks have is that they can’t fly their planes in a straight line. How tragic.

Yes, that’s our only problem.

These guys are up against vehicles from '43, '44, or even '50—across both land and air—while flying models from '40. We’ve managed to solve everything else; this is the only issue left.

Never mind the fact that a Spitfire can turn like a snake—apparently, the problem is that it can’t fly straight. Right.

Look, here’s an idea: let’s just give everyone a Yak-3. The French and the Russians already have them; let’s give one to the Americans and the British for “testing purposes,” and hand a captured one over to the Germans—problem solved.

What a load of absolute nonsense.

Please, let’s focus on the actual topic.

Why does year of time matter for you?

It doesn’t affect anything.

What matters is relative performance.

And for relative turning (sustained rate, instantenous rate, rate with flaps, turn radius, turn radius with flaps), climbing, time to speed and max speed we have this:




(added SEP10 m/s line for turns where you can shallow climb or regain energy at on top of optimal sustained rates
Added SEP-10 m/s line for turns where you burn energy for better instantaneous turn, for instance in a diving spiral.

I chose to include these as these two values on top of optimal sustained turn demonstrate the tradeoffs quite visibly).

Based on this, I dare say the 109 G-6 (4.6), 109 F-4 (4.0) and P-51C (4.0) make for well balanced matchups with different niches and capabilities that lead to fun combat where both parties have an equal chance to kill the other if their opponent makes a mistake.

All values are at sea level unless stated otherwise.

I dare say acceleration (rather than raw thrust) at different speeds is a very telling graph.( As an aside, It’s why the Spitfire Lf Mk IX and Ki-84 are so awful to fight: they dominate in acceleration as well as turn performance as well as climb at 5.0.) Back on topic, P-51C may have better top speed but it loses at acceleration if it loses its speed. The little dip at 100-200 km/h I’m assuming is AEC vs MEC difference based on this graph for the 109s.)

image

Try to use M&K and see for yourself

Tested E3 model didn’t have engine governor.

They don’t. Coding for planes with slats done by “+X” to turn pull/ performance. Basicly, they are “allways on”, even though they didn’t deploy.

Yes, but you could overwite it with trimmer.

Stick travel on Bf109’s was smaller, that means pilot needed less force.

Knowing that last Spitfire Mk24 had 2 sets of rudder pedals [one above other], i’d say no, they didn’t. Just took more “easy” route.

Well, why don’t you mention the P-51’s top speed, its diving speed, its armament (the 12.7mm—which is actually more effective than a 20mm cannon, a real joke that is), its incredible maneuverability at high speeds, and the fact that it retains energy better even during turns?

Look, even in the values ​​you’ve provided here, they are nearly equal. In fact, since the P-51 almost always operates at higher speeds, it’s consistently the one with the advantage.

You’re framing this as a 1v1 scenario. A P-51 pilot generally won’t engage in a duel with you; they’ll just fly away—that’s what these planes are designed for. All this talk about spiral climbs or spiral dives? Pilots who truly understand their aircraft don’t bother with that nonsense; they execute a dive, pull away, and leave you trailing far behind, empty-handed.

For instance, I once out-turned and shot down a Bf 109 G-2 while flying a D-10—even though the D-10 is heavier. We were both at low speeds during that duel. And the opponent who shot you down while you were in a P-47? They were flying a Bf 109 G-2, which has roughly the same level of flight performance as the one I used in my duel.

You’ve effectively exposed yourself with these charts.

The P-51 C-10 entered service in early 1944. It has a Battle Rating (BR) of 4.0.

The Bf 109 F-4 entered service in June 1941.

The P-51 C-10 is objectively superior to the F-4. With this aircraft, the Americans picked off the Germans with ease; only the K-4, Ta 152, and D-9 were somewhat capable of standing up to it.

You’re acting more like a than an actual German. And don’t even try to bring up things like fuel shortages—stop looking at this through an emotional lens.

The year of production absolutely has an impact on performance. You shouldn’t evaluate an aircraft solely based on its maneuverability; factors like armament, high-speed handling, and many others also come into play.

Following your logic, the I-16 would be a better aircraft than the F4 because it’s more maneuverable. But how does it fare in terms of acceleration, armament, climb rate, and turn performance at high speeds?

An aircraft’s Battle Rating (BR) in the game isn’t determined by your 1v1 duels.

In short, the P-51 C-10 is an aircraft that entered service in early 1944. Even if it were to perform slightly worse than the F-4 (which entered service in June 1941)—as your dubious little charts might suggest—it is, in fact, a vastly superior aircraft. It consistently maintains higher speeds, which compensates for any minor performance gaps; it is capable of incredible maneuvers at high speeds, performs better in a dive, is significantly faster, and boasts a higher top speed.

Given that it isn’t an intermediate or transitional variant, its Battle Rating (BR) should be 4.7—the same level as the G-6.