The Suffering Endured By German Tech Tree Players " SİMULATİON WARS "

Cold war era isn’t exactly the scope of my knowledge, so it makes sense I wouldn’t know this.

I’m genuinely surprised the Panzer IV lasted to 1967 in active service to be fair.

Quite a long service, honestly. I mean, heck, the M4 Sherman lasted till 2018. Some of the Shermans today are thanks to those countries that had no choice but to continue producing and servicing em. While that either or even lived as long as they did.

No, the Tiger 2 has to weakspot snipe american same BR tanks too. It can’t just UFP them. Besides that, vehicles are a MIX of PROS and CONS and the germans have plenty of cons to make up for their high penetration and armor. (And armor only on specific tanks at that)

Yeah it is

It definitely can, especially in a real match and not protection analysis

No, you’re just massively exaggerating german pros while massively exaggeratin german downsides while doing the same but opposite to everybody else

Yeah, this doesn’t matter by itself. There are other stats to a gun

PZ4 has the slowest reload of all medium tanks at its BR besides the T34 to my knowledge

Not really. Just average.

yes

sure, but t26e1 is still pretty good

no

absolutely not, this is a much higher br tank

IS-2 does fine in current game

88mm has to aim for weakspots on everything you mentioned besides the basic M26 as well. The Tiger 2 also gets 1 shot by everything you mentioned if they penetrate too, and they likely will because they can all, besides the M26, penetrate you frontally

APDS is historically inaccurate

In exchange for its own downsides, the turret is infinitely weaker than western heavies btw, its just the ufp, side armor is still garbage too

That’s just you, most higher end players want the stabilizer. You should not be seeking to be shot at in any tank.

Germans dont get this

Not to an actual stabilizer

They are

It isn’t.

it is

No, not really…its just good armor

Nobody said they did

It is. Fact. End of. Disagreeing with this just makes you non-credible

This never matters. This is a video game.

Yes. In minor ways.

Nobody said this. You are swinging at the air

It is not difficult

With its own giant set of downsides

Not accurate

Hey so you see all the spots the tracks dont cover? 50mm

No.

Frankly man I’m not gonna respond again, I think you are just way too wrong about specific things that you haven’t actually tested. Agree to disagree

Are you saying the Yak-3 loses this fight in WAR THUNDER?

tövbe estağfurullah.

That’s impossible.

What I mean is, if a P-51 C-10 finds itself in a difficult spot and starts turning continuously—much like a Yak-3—it can potentially defeat its opponent.

Against what?? P-51s have bad long term dogfight capability. They require high speeds to turn well and you’re only going to maintain that high speed for so long unless you spiral downwards the entire fight

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

At the very least, they turn quite well compared to their German counterparts.

Of course, they aren’t as good as the Yak-3, the Japanese series, or British aircraft.

However, they are much faster than British, Japanese, and Russian planes, and they possess an incredible ability to turn at high speeds—though perhaps some later-model British aircraft might be able to turn just as well.

I don’t think you need to read it.

It’s enough for the game developers to read it.

In the early days of tank simulation battles, the Panther D wasn’t included in matches featuring the T-34-85, even though it was present in the tech tree.

Back then, we voiced our complaints—much like we’re doing here—and they corrected their mistake.

I have a new GPU, installed. Everything is stable.

I am home.

It is currently 15:54 in Hungary as of writing this forum post.

When are you available? I can invite you into a custom lobby.

I’d be down to try in 1 hour at <t:1793462400:t> (discord timestamp) (UTC+0 15:00)

debatable
Soviets have KVs and IS tanks starting at 3.7

The king tiger is the only tank that actually has good armor in germany tbh. And it isn’t even that good, it is just very well covered in the front, so a lot of stuff just can’t go through it with their primary shell

I’d say it’s a matter of balancing. Gaijin doesn’t care about prop tiers at all whether it’s Air or Ground SIM.
Allmost all BR changes are for top tier only.[Yes they did some changes in Ground SIM this october-november, but 99% of them were uselless. It didn’t change the presets they were in].

If we talk about “Historical matchmaking” for Air/Ground SIM. As a guy who sits in “historical” discord servers, i’d say it will work, but the maps need to be much bigger.

And lastly just to “think about” or “words thrown into wind”. Right now Air SIM is just Air RB with fixed view camera [planes with gunners are exeption].

How about forcing “Manual engine controls” and actually modeling them. Now, suddenly!, A “no skill to win Yak’s and Cheatfires” have to have spreadsheets for mixture settings. What?!, forgot to change mixture while chasing poor Fw190A’s from 4km to 1km alt, well get ready for the knocking and engine going “red” real fast. Set on 100% and be fine?, damn i wonder why am i so slow higher up…and why my fuel economy feels like i’m flying a “HUMMER”?
Prop pitch. Right now: manual prop pitch on German engines-over rev=engine Dead. Any other engine with engine governors: slap 100% and forget about it, slam the throttle!, “magical” governor saves your ass from blowing up, engine manifold gauge is in Red?, who cares, right? Only 1 nation and their engines can blow up, no one elses.

And that’s just the tip of the iceberg, there is a lot more. + i’m playing on PS5 i can’t mod the game or look at the files to see usage of GM-1, WM-50 boosts or are they even modeled to begin with.

P.s. Yes, every plane has his quirks, it’s not black and white. But right now, it is black and white. When two planes have different flight performances, but 1 has to make 10 adjustments while dogfighting and the other 60, now for a better plane it’s not that simple to just turn inside and win, unlike right now.

Jagdpanther, VK 3002, pretty much all the Panthers, Tiger H1, Tiger E, Ferdinand/Elefant, Jagdtiger, Panzer IV/70, Jagdpanzer 38(t), and Jagdpanzer IV.

1 Like

Oh Germans suffer the most with 6.3 ground SB battles:

  • Ju288
  • Panther II
  • Tiger II 10.5
  • Me264
  • Me-262A

But they are also paired with other suffering nations, which have absolutely worst performing vehicles, like Italy with:

  • MB-326B

A team of 3 competent pilots in MB-326B and Me-262A mops the floor with whole allied team, which can do nothing, I mean absolutely nothing about it. Add some Ju-288 player who has, I don’t know, maybe most his SIM air kills in a Ju-288 (wink, wink) and then complain on forum how badly they suffer.

On a serious note though… I cannot think of any serious SIM pilot who has been in this game long enough, to complain about 109F4 at 4.0 - one of the easiest to fly, most forgiving and most competitive airplanes out there. The fact I kill those a lot in Spit mkV or Firefly! is only due to it being a noob loved airplane and they just want to dogfight with combat flaps on.

The Me 262 and 264 are useless.

I don’t believe those who play the Italian jet are playing fairly.

The Panther II, the 10.5 cm Tiger, and the 37mm anti-aircraft Panther are only in the hands of a select few.

Meanwhile, the opposition has highly mobile French vehicles with a 4-second reload time; the Soviets have the T-44-100; The American tree is a bit more balanced, the British have the Centurion Mk 3 (with ammunition boasting 381mm of penetration!)—and that’s just the tip of the iceberg; feel free to go and check for yourself.

Then there are the poor German players, stuck with the Tiger II—which can barely move—and the Panther F and G, which take hits from any incoming shell, regardless of where it lands.

I have to question the sanity of anyone trying to play the Tiger II or the Panther F and G against these enemy tanks.

It’s an absolute disgrace. There’s no other way to describe it.

1 Like

What game are you playing? I killed you twice in a single game this morning, you seemed to be unaware of your surroundings so I guess maybe you don’t pay attention?

Allies have no jet to match air power of Axis in today’s 6.3 BR.
MB-326B - just take it to the test flight, you can literally pull it all the way to your balls and it does not stall just turns in circles at constant 300km/h.
Me-262A is untouchable when it stays fast and it succesfully strafes even heaviest allied tanks from sides/back with 50mm cannon.
Ju-288 - really no comment.
I saw games where 3 pilots flying above aircraft, had 5-7 ground kills each with no death, decimating whole allied team.

Then we have Wiesel 1A4 - thermals at this BR and it is fast as a fart, I succesfully took it against T-54s in the past and it is more than enought to deal with anything light even medium Allies have.
At least half of germans in those matches have Panthers II - those are a lot more common than regular panthers at those BRs, the same FlakPnzrs and KugelBlitz - every single game you will meet them.

Hmmm but what about other offenders, time travellers and just disguisting tanks worth mentioning?
FIAT - 100km/h + 433mm penetration HEAT
Type 60 - pen as above, small and mobile little rat
Type 61 - 320mm HEAT, what year is this?
R3 - just try flying close to battlefield in any allied prop, they will toast you togetther with above Wiesel.

But just in case germans had no enough AAA firepower, there it is the:
Leopard 40/70.

1 Like

Honestly, I hadn’t noticed you—whoever you are. I’m not one for lurking.

I am opposed to using vehicles produced long after WWII in simulation battles against actual WWII-era hardware. This applies regardless of whether it’s the Axis or the Allies; these vehicles were built based on entirely different design concepts.

That said, it’s worth noting that the Axis side tends to be heavily populated by German vehicles.

The vehicles you mentioned are essentially there to encourage players to explore those specific national tech trees.

Frankly, aside from those Japanese light tanks, the situation isn’t nearly as extreme as you’re making it out to be.

Your arguments are quite weak—you’ve cited vehicles that, in the context of the game, are generally ineffective.

I mean, are you suggesting that a vehicle like the Wiesel is out there blowing up tanks by hitting their frontal armor? And what about the equivalent vehicles on the opposing side?

Interestingly, you also failed to mention that the Panther F, Panther G, and Tiger II are actually superior to the vehicles you brought up earlier.

Well, that’s a step in the right direction, folks!

That’s some generic mumbling.
There is no essence in your statements, no facts, just personal opinions.
The fact is every nation has time travellers, every nation has weaker vehicles, useless vehicles, OP vehicles.

Germany does not suffer any more than other nations and at some BRs it dominates.
I remember this game when a rock or stump would throw your track off, we had many topics to have historical battles and we even got some in the past. But that’s all in the past and no meaningless rant topic will change the situation.

1 Like

I suppose you’re the one who decides that.

It’s probably time to look at other games.

Well, it’s clear that the game developers and the spoiled players have joined forces—practically holding up banners and shouting:

“Hey, you German-tank-playing fool! You’re just going to play with those heavy, useless vehicles and serve as fodder for the rest of us.”