The subtree of Polish helicopters

[Would you like to see this in-game?]
  • Yes
  • No
0 voters


The subtree of Polish helicopters
In today’s suggestion, I present a subtree of Polish helicopters for War Thunder. Since 1957, the Polish army has been equipped with helicopters of various designs and origins. In this suggestion, I will present the most interesting Polish helicopters (without the Soviet Copy-Paste)
History
At the beginning of the 1950s, the Polish People’s Army (Poland was a communist country from 1944 to 1989) noticed the phenomenon of helicopters in the armies of other countries (the USSR and the USA) and began to look for opportunities to acquire its own helicopters. When the Russians developed the new Mi-1 helicopter in Poland, a decision was made to purchase a license to produce this helicopter. The manufacturer was to be a small plant of WSK Świdnik, which had previously produced aircraft components for WSK Mielec. In 1955, the documentation of the Mi-1T helicopter was purchased and delivered to Świdnik, and a year later, with the help of the Mila factory, the production of a new helicopter was started, which received the designation SM-1. SM-1 helicopters served as transport, liaison or medical helicopters. At the end of the 1950s, Poland supplemented its helicopter fleet with Mi-4 helicopters and an improved SM-1 helicopter designated SM-2. At the beginning, Polish helicopters were either not armed at all or had only defensive armament. In 1965, Polish received licensed production of Mi-2 helicopters (Poland was their main manufacturer), these helicopters entered service in the Polish People’s Army in 1968 together with the Mi-8 heavy transport helicopters. In the following years, armed versions of the Mi-2 helicopter were developed in Świdnik, and these were the versions Mi-2 US, Mi-2 URN, Mi-2 URP, Mi-2 URS, Mi-2 URP-G .In 1978, the Poles received Mi-24 heavy attack helicopters version D and V (in Poland called W). In 1981, Poland purchased Mi-14 helicopters for the Navy, in the Mi-14PŁ, Mi-14PS, Mi-14PX versions, which were used for anti-submarine and rescue purposes. In 1986, the army took over Mi-6A helicopters, which had previously served as flying cranes. In 1988, Mi-17 helicopters were delivered to Polish, and in 1989 Świdnica W-3 Sokół helicopters were introduced into service. In 2002, the Polish Navy received four SH-2G Super Seasprite helicopters. In 2006, the SW-4 light helicopter was introduced into service. In 2007, Sikorsky Aircraft Corporation acquired the PZL Mielec plant and since 2009 S-70i helicopters have been produced there. In 2010, the PZL Świdnik plant became part of the AgustaWestland company and the production of AW101 and AW149 helicopters began. In 2023, three AW101 helicopters went to the Polish Navy, and in the same year, three AW149s went to the Polish army. On August 13, 2023, a contract was signed at the Latkowo airport in Inowrocław for the purchase of 96 AH-64E helicopters worth USD 10 billion. This is where the long history of helicopters in the Polish Army ends.
OIP

S-70i

The concept of Polish Helicopters for Japan in War Thunder

Someone will say that this is a strange concept, but Polish-Japanese relations have been very good for over a hundred years. Poles learned about the existence of Japan thanks to the Marko Polo expedition in the 15th century, and the first direct Polish-Japanese contacts took place in 1585, when three Japanese emissaries from the Tenshō Mission in Rome met with the Pope and the Polish bishop Bernard Maciejowski. Until the 19th century, Poles and Japanese did not maintain permanent diplomatic relations. In the years 1892-93, during his trip to Berlin-Vladivostok, Colonel Yasumasa Fukushima became acquainted with the Polish independence movements in Russia and the convicts in Siberia, which moved him very much, and he presented it in Japan, which moved the Japanese. In 1904, two of the most important Polish independence activists, Józef Piłsudski and Roman Dymowski, came to Tokyo. Piłsudski wanted to encourage the Japanese to support the Polish uprising in Russia in exchange for help in conquering Manchuria. However, Roman Dymowski believed that it would end badly for the Poles, which is why he discouraged the Japanese from Piłsudski’s plan. Dymowski reached Tokyo first and nothing came of Piłsudski’s plans, but both politicians tried to improve the situation of Poles who served in the Russian Army and ended up in Polish captivity. On March 6, 1919, Japan recognized Polish independence as the fifth country in the world and established diplomatic relations. In the years 1920-22, the Japanese helped Polish orphans from Siberia. The Japanese saved 765 children, who were first taken to the Fukudenkai center in Tokyo (visited by the emperor) and then brought to Polish. In 1928, on the initiative of Józef Piłsudski, fifty-one Japanese officers were awarded the Order of Virtuti Militari (the highest Polish designation). In 1939, after the Polish capitulation, the Japanese embassy operated in Warsaw, which operated for two more years. In 1940 in Kaunas, the Japanese diplomat Chiune Sugihara began to issue transit visas to Jewish families of Polish origin without restrictions. He issued 2139 family visas, which saved several thousand lives from the Germans. In December 1941, Poland declared war on Japan (the only war declared by Poland in the 20th century), but the Japanese consul stated that the Poles were declaring this war under British coercion and did not accept it because of good relations. Despite the declaration of war between Poland and Japan, the cooperation of intelligence services against the USSR and Germany continued, which continued until the end of the war. In 1957, Japan recognized the Polish People’s Republic and on February 8, 1957, the Polish-Japanese War ended and diplomatic relations were reestablished. In 1980, the Independent Self-Governing Trade Union “Solidarity” was established, which was joined by Yoshiho Umeda, for which he was expelled from Polish in 1982 (he returned in 1989), for his merits he was awarded by Poland. Since 1989, Polish-Japanese relations have become more and more cordial. Poles sent aid to the Japanese after the Cataclysms of 1995 and 2011. In 2002, the historic Imperial Majesties Emperor Akihito and Empress Michiko (Emperor of Japan for the first time in Poland) took place. In 2015, during his visit to Japan, the President of the Republic of Poland, Bronisław Komorowski, established a strategic partnership between Poland and Japan. In 2019, 100 years of Polish-Japanese relations were celebrated, and then Poland was visited by the Japanese heir to the throne, Prince Akishino, together with Princess Kiko. Poland and Japan cooperate economically, culturally and scientifically.
These long diplomatic relations allow (if I will) for the Japanese in War Thunder to host Poles in their tech tree.

Presentation of the Polish subtree


Era V

Regular Vehicles

Mi-2 URP “Salamander” (Salamandra)
OIP
At the beginning of the 1970s, it was decided in Poland to arm the Mi-2 helicopters. The first version was the Mi-2 US armed with 1 NS-23 cannon and 4 PTK rifles. The army decided that this armament was too weak, so it developed other versions of the armed Mi-2 helicopters. The first was the Mi-2 URN (armed with unguided missiles) and the Mi-2 URP, which was armed with 9M14M Malyutka missiles. This variant was created in 1974 and was produced from 1975 to 1984. 46 copies were built.
General characteristics
Crew: 4
Length: 11,94 m
Width: 3,25 m
Height: 3,75 m
Empty weight: 2400 kg
Gross weight: 3700 kg
Powerplant: 2 x GTD-350 engines with 400 hp
Main rotor diameter: 14,5 m
Main rotor area: 165,15 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 210 km/h
Range: 580 km
Service ceiling: 4 000 m
Rate of climb: 4.5 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x Fixed NS-23 cannon (100 rounds) and 2 x PK machine guns in the windows
Rocket: 4 x 9M14M “Malutka” (4 Rockets Reserve) or 2 x 16 S-5 missiles

Photos of the Mi-2 URP

40-1.jpg.5f4d457ed964eda592e711391a6bcad2
OIP



Source

Mi-2 – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Mil Mi-2URP Salamandra [Kód NATO: Hoplite] : Mil (valka.cz)
WSK Mi-2URP - Opisy Broni
Mil Mi-2US: The Polish Utility Gunship - Suggestions / Heli - War Thunder — official forum

Era VI

Regular Vehicles

Mi-2 URP-G “Gniewosz”
OIP (1)
The Mi-2 URP-G is a modernization of the Mi-2 URP helicopter from 1988. Added the ability to mount four 9M32M Arrow-2M anti-aircraft missiles at the ends of the 9M14M Malyutka rocket holders. 6 of these helicopters were built.
General characteristics
Crew: 4
Length: 11,94 m
Width: 3,25 m
Height: 3,75 m
Empty weight: 2400 kg
Gross weight: 3700 kg
Powerplant: 2 x GTD-350 engines with 400 hp
Main rotor diameter: 14,5 m
Main rotor area: 165,15 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 210 km/h
Range: 580 km
Service ceiling: 4 000 m
Rate of climb: 4.5 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x Fixed NS-23 cannon (100 rounds) and 2 x PK machine guns in the windows
Rocket: 4 x 9M14M “Malutka” (4 Rockets Reserve) and 4 x 9M32M Arrow-2M or 2 x 16 S-5 missiles or 4 x 9M32M Arrow-2M

Photos of the Mi-2 URP-G

5





OIP (1)

Source

Mi-2 – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Mil Mi-2URP Salamandra [Kód NATO: Hoplite] : Mil (valka.cz)
WSK Mi-2URP - Opisy Broni
Mil Mi-2US: The Polish Utility Gunship - Suggestions / Heli - War Thunder — official forum

W-3WA Sokół


The W-3WA is a modernized multi-role W-3W helicopter. The modernization consisted in receiving the FAR-29 certificate. This version was created around the 2000s, all W-3W helicopters were modified to the W-3WA version. 36 helicopters of this version were built.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x Fixed GSz-23Ł cannon
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 16 S-5 missiles , 4 x 10 S-8 missiles , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system

Photos W-3WA





Source

PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Уголок неба ¦ PZL W-3W/U Sokół/Anakonda (airwar.ru)
samolotypolskie.pl - PZL W-3 “Sokół”
PZL W-3WA Sokół : Polsko (POL) (valka.cz)

W-3PL Głuszec


The W-3PL Głuszec is an upgrade of the W-3WA to the role of a combat support helicopter. The modernization of the W-3WA helicopters was undertaken in 2007, and the first three helicopters were delivered in 2010. The modernization consisted in mounting a 12.7 mm HMGWKM-Bm mobile machine gun in a movable turret under the nose of the machine. The helicopters are equipped with the FADEC system, autopilot, digital cabin, INS, GPS, ILS, HUD systems, the “friend-foe” system and the m.in RWR countermeasures and flare systems. 7 copies were made.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 12.7mm HMGWKM-Bm movable machine gun (350 rounds)
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 57 mm or 70 mm unguided missile launchers , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system, ZR-8 bomb pods

Photos W-3PL Głuszec




w-3_sokol_poland


1234341

Source

PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Уголок неба ¦ PZL W-3PL Głuszec (airwar.ru)
samolotypolskie.pl - PZL W-3 “Sokół”
PZL W-3PL Głuszec : Polsko (POL) (valka.cz)

Premium Vehicles

W-3K Huzar
101332-385ba080e44ff99ef9cc995c5bba9a27
The W-3K Huzar is a trial export version of the W-3 helicopter to South Africa. In 1992, cooperation with companies from South Africa took place. This is how the W-3K (Kentron) was created, which was equipped with a day/night HSOS optronic head, ZT-3/ZT-35 anti-tank missiles and a 20 mm GA-1 cannon with a helmet sight. Only one prototype was built.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 20 mm GA-1 cannon
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 16 S-5 missiles, 4 x 10 S-8 missiles , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system, ZR-8 bomb pods, 8 x ZT3 Ingwe ATGM

Photos W-3K Huzar

101331-0de4572c0311ee67284399132c099486
101332-385ba080e44ff99ef9cc995c5bba9a27
101333-eb22955cb924261780a33300555f5b73
101308-b846624b4b3fee2ef3383cfe42117f01
101309-c4a521cbdf40a774c28399cf432a0fba

Source

PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Przeciwpancerny Głuszec - Wydawnictwo militarne ZBIAM

Era VII

Regular Vehicles

W-3U Salamandra
w3w-9.thumb.jpg.03ce7dec67c1d0bec582a1ccd6797ae6
The W-3U Salamandra is a prototype W-3 helicopter that was armed in the same way as the Mi-24W. Only one copy was built in 1990, but the army rejected it, so it was sold to Burma as the W-3UT.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 23 mm GSh-23L gun (250 rounds)
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 16 S-5 missiles, 4 x 10 S-8 missiles , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system, ZR-8 bomb pods, 4 x 9M114 Shturm, 6 x 9M14M Malutka, 4 x 9M17P Falanga-P

Photos W-3U Salamandra

w3w-8.thumb.jpg.41b5d099fa7768665a9bdc69719901e5
w3w-9.thumb.jpg.03ce7dec67c1d0bec582a1ccd6797ae6
1234
1042268494_Beztyteeuu.thumb.jpg.8e04d0fe7eda51883e0125b03f4a0d50
W3_SP_0317_1.thumb.jpg.0e537c52d5b746633d4e8d9d606e5639

Source

PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Уголок неба ¦ PZL W-3W/U Sokół/Anakonda (airwar.ru)
Przeciwpancerny Głuszec - Wydawnictwo militarne ZBIAM

W-3WB Huzar
OIP
The W-3WB Huzar is a modified W-3K Huzar helicopter with European armament. The helicopter was equipped with a Sagem Viviane observation and targeting head and a HOT-3 ATGM. The 20mm GA-1 cannon was left. The helicopter was part of the Huzar program, which ended in 1999. Only one prototype was built, tested in 1999.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 20 mm GA-1 cannon
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 16 S-5 missiles, 4 x 10 S-8 missiles , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system, ZR-8 bomb pods, 16 x Hot-3

Art about the W-3WB

101335-d2e76ad56084873bc387bece324294e2
OIP

Source

PZL W-3 Sokół – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Przeciwpancerny Głuszec - Wydawnictwo militarne ZBIAM
samolotypolskie.pl - PZL W-3 “Sokół”

AW149


AgustaWestland AW149 is one of the newest helicopters in the Polish Armed Forces. The Polish Armed Forces purchased 32 AW149 helicopters and 800 AGM-114R2 Hellfire II missiles as part of the perkoz program. The first two AW149 helicopters were delivered on October 30, 2023.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 17,57 m
Width: 3,06 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight:
Gross weight: 8 300 kg
Powerplant: 2 x General Electric CT7-2E1
Turboshaft engines with FADEC (2,000 hp each) and 1 x Safran e-APU (60 kW)
Main rotor diameter: 14,60 m
Main rotor area: 167,42 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 287 km/h
Range: 958 km
Service ceiling: 3 948 m

Armament
Guns: 2 x 7.62 mm movable machine guns mounted in windows
Rocket: 28x FZ231, 28x FZ275, 8x AGM114K Hellfire II, 20mm gun pods, 12,7 gun pods,80mm rocket pods

AW149 Photos





image

uDSgr04S2ikfx9OpRur1wfRjVdt6YPSUnSpppeM0.qhmq

Source

Beznazwy-2 (pzlswidnik.pl)
Leonardo AW149 - Suggestions / Heli - War Thunder — official forum
AgustaWestland AW149 – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia

W-3PL 2016


The W-3PL 2016 is a prototype model of the W-3PL helicopter modernization presented for MSPO 2016. This helicopter was equipped with Spike-ER and Spike-NLOS ATGMs. The helicopter is equipped with a Toplite 3 optical head.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14,21 m
Width: 1,75 m
Height: 5,14 m
Empty weight: 3900 kg
Gross weight: 6100 kg
Powerplant: 2 × Pratt & Whitney Rzeszów PZL-10B turboshaft engines with a power of 671 kW (900 hp) each
Main rotor diameter: 15,70 m
Main rotor area: 193,6 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 255 km/h
Range: 734 km
Service ceiling: 6000 m
Rate of climb: 9,3 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 12.7mm HMGWKM-Bm movable machine gun (350 rounds)
Rocket: 2 x UPK-23-250 pod with GSh-23 cannon, 4 x 57 mm or 70 mm unguided missile launchers , 2 x 2 9M32M Arrow-2M, 4 x Platan minelaying system, ZR-8 bomb pods, 8 x Spike-ER , 12 x Spike-ER, 8 x Spike-NLOS , 12 x Spike-NLOS

Photos W-3PL 2016




Przetwarzanie: maxresdefault.jpg…

Source

Uzbrojone śmigłowce: nie tylko Black Hawk i Głuszec | Konflikty.pl
Przeciwpancerny Głuszec. Świdnik proponuje rakiety Spike | Defence24
Przeciwpancerny Głuszec - Wydawnictwo militarne ZBIAM

AH-64E


In 2023, the AH-64E helicopters were the winner of the kruk program, which aims to replace the old Mi-24D and W helicopters. Poland has ordered 96 AH-64E helicopters along with a logistics package for USD 10 billion. The first helicopters are to be delivered in 2028.
General characteristics
Crew: 2
Length: 14.68 m
Height: 4.72 m
Empty weight: 5165 kg
Gross weight: 6,838 kg
Powerplant: 2 x General Electric T700-701D with a power of 1487 kW (1994 hp)
Main rotor diameter: 14.63 m
Main rotor area: 177,31 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 279 km/h
Range: 476 km
Service ceiling: 6,096 m
Rate of climb: 14.2 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x 30 mm M230 Chain Gun (1200 rounds)
Rocket: 4 x 19 Hydra-70 M247, 4 x 2 AGM-114 Hellfire II, 4 x 4 AGM-114 Hellfire II, 4 x 7 APKWS II, 2 x 2 AIM 92

AH-64E Photos


AH-64-Poland-800x534

poland-selects-apache

Source

Boeing AH-64 Apache - Wikipedia
Rekordowa umowa na 96 śmigłowców AH-64E Apache Guardian dla Polski – MILMAG
Polska potęgą w śmigłowcach bojowych. Umowa na Apache podpisana | Defence24

Premium Vehicles

S-70i
S-70i
The Sikorsky S-70i is a military export version of the UH-60 helicopter produced by PZL Mielec. It is an export variant of the UH-60M, but it is lighter by 500 kg and has only equipment without export restrictions. It has been produced since 2010. It has been in service with the Polish army since 2019.
General characteristics
Crew: 4
Length: 15,26 m
Width: 2,36 m
Height: 5,33 m
Empty weight: 5347 kg
Gross weight: 9979 kg
Powerplant: 2 x General Electric T700-GE701D with take-off power of 2974 kW (3988 hp)
Main rotor diameter: 16,36 m
Main rotor area: 210.15 m2

Performance
Maximum speed: 302 km/h
Range: 496 km
Service ceiling: 6096 m
Rate of climb: 11,43 m/s

Armament
Guns: 1 x M134 Minigun machine guns caliber 7.62 mm in windows , 12.7mm FN M3M machine guns in the door
Rocket: 4 x 19 Hydra-70 M247,4 x 7 Hydra-70 M247, 4 x 2 AGM-114 Hellfire II, 4 x 4 AGM-114 Hellfire II, 7,62 mm gun pods, 12,7mm gun pods

Images for S-70i

Black Hawk 019
pilot-controls.png.pc-adaptive.480.high


Anakonda
Black Hawk 017
Zdj. Andy Poulastides
S-70i
WIT_7_2016_BH_ok-768x512

Source

Uzbrojony śmigłowiec Black Hawk: elastyczność i siła ognia (zbiam.pl)
MSPO 2019: Polski wariant uzbrojonego Black Hawka | Defence24
Oferta \ S-70 Black Hawk \ Dane techniczne \ Uzbrojony \ PZL Mielec

Summary
The Polish helicopter base is very large and provides a variety of armament without the boring Copy-Paste. For the Japanese, there was a huge support in War Thunder.

Additional sources

Uzbrojone śmigłowce: nie tylko Black Hawk i Głuszec | Konflikty.pl
Polish Helicopter Tech Tree - Other Nations - War Thunder - Official Forum
Polskie Śmigłowce PZL W-3 Sokół latają na całym świecie. Wojsko odebrało kolejne zmodernizowane egzemplarze (wp.pl)
Lista śmigłowców Wojska Polskiego – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Konsultacje polsko-japońskie w Tokio - Ministerstwo Spraw Zagranicznych - Portal Gov.pl (www.gov.pl)
Stosunki polsko-japońskie – Wikipedia, wolna encyklopedia
Japan–Poland relations - Wikipedia
Japonia - Polska w Japonii - Portal Gov.pl (www.gov.pl)
日本とポーランドの関係 - Wikipedia

4 Likes

Am I missing something? Why is this for Japan?

19 Likes

I guess it’s because of similar flag colors.

2 Likes

Huh what do you me-

Oh

2 Likes

Definitely NOT for Japan, a sub-tree as a whole in-case an independent tree can’t come to the game? Sure. Japan doesn’t need Poland anyways, it’s already getting ASEAN nations.

14 Likes

Here is the explanation

No. Having good diplomatic ties is not enough to justify this, otherwise pretty much every European country could be lumped together as one tree. Ideally you would need to show that Japan or Poland used military technology from each other, cooperated on designs, have a history of joint military training exercises, etc.

1 Like

Independent Polish Tech Tree would be better. The reason for Polish helis being in Japanese doesn’t make sense. You wanna add them simply because Poland and Japan have good relations.

6 Likes

I read it, but if you’re going to make a suggestion for Polish helicopters, then Poland as a whole would have to go under Japan which doesn’t make sense since there is no correlation between the two ground forces beyond good relations.

2 Likes

Don’t worry, this suggestion does not contradict the suggestion of an independent technology tree for Poland. In addition, ASEAN will add two Polish W-3UT and S-70i helicopters

4 Likes

Honestly, why not. If not for the looming ASEAN subtree, I feel like this would be a more viable option. The two nations have had pretty excellent relations throughout the century with little in the way of controversy, so it’s not nearly as bad as some other suggestions might be for a Japanese subtree. Not to mention, it would be a good way to give Poland a platform with the space Japan had and reduce the amount of clutter a collection of 4+ nations might invite. Unlike ASEAN, Poland also has a wide variety of options including an actual SAM with a built in radar. It’s certainly a bit odd, but not unwelcome.

Bait used to be believable.

3 Likes

I just want a SAM with a radar man.

1 Like

you surely will get one someday

ASEAN and Japan both have no such option, despite the abundance of other types. They also lack unique helis with atgms, aside from Apaches (likely due to the fact AA & Helis are some of the most expensive vehicles to field). Poland has more options for both. It may not be the most conventional, but considering how much people fight over what goes where in Asia, a more complete a constant friend doesn’t seem like such a bad pick.

Yeah but the connections with Japan and Poland are too weak to add it to Japan. Thailand must have something good to offer.

There may be a tree from Japan, Poland and Thailand

1 Like

Honestly, the connection is about the same as Japan and say, Indonesia, which is another popular option. Poland & Japan did share intelligence against the soviets, which is more cooperation than can be said of some other nations. I agree that Thailand has a better connection but if we are including other options too I wouldn’t rule out Poland just because of geography.

By adding Poland you will also have to add Soviet stuff it used as well. You can’t just cherrypick the vehicles.

As one of my best friends is Polish, I heavily support the implementation of any Polish vehicle into the game. But IMO this is not the way. Polish heli in the Japanese tree? Perhaps a little sub-branch or goodie bag vehicle as part of the German tree, seeing as most Poles do not have a favourable opinion of Russia.

1 Like