Some of that was discussed in a previous topic I made.
2 Likes
I wouldnt even really mind it being 11.7 because it is really good against actual close air support and not f16s dropping bombs from 15km if italy had some kind of top tier SAM to go along side it
Germany gets the Gepard 1A2 at 9.7 which has missiles and radar along with its main 35mm, Sweden gets the LvKv 9040C at 10.0 with flack shells and radar. The Russians get the 2S6 with radar and missiles able to pull 32Gs along with its 30mm that shoots 1250 rounds per minute at 10.7. I dont see why Italy shouldn’t be able to have a SPAA that can do somewhat of a good job at what it does.
And if aircraft have issues with getting close, the Mi-35, AH-6M and helis just like it can launch ATGMs out of its range just fine.
Plus Italy will probably never get a long range SAM due to the only ones in service are trailer based SAMs.
I dont play italy that much, but br of otomatic was always bizzare to me. Ralisticly speaking, since its top tier tech spaa in minor nation, it would literally change nothing if this thing was like 10.3 and if they are so afraid it would break the game, they could nerf apfsds pen, or make reload longer while using apfsds. (Im not realism purist, id rather play a game that is fun and balanced, rather than full sim that this game will never be).
Honestly, i thing that gaijin have tendency to turbo nerf vehicles into the ground just do they dont need revisit the same problem twice.
Well they have already nerfed the OTO heavily by making the ammo transfer 10x slower so after about 15 shots you have to wait for each round to get restocked which takes around 8 seconds each but for a SPAA its crucial to have rounds ready in a short amount of time, so when you run out of ammo in your main ammo storage, you become a sitting duck for CAS.
And for the APSDS, I don’t see why its so crucial for a SPAA to have a round to kill MBTs when it already comes with a round for defense against light armor. and its main job isn’t even to kill tanks.
Italy has sidam mistral… at 2 br steps higher than anything comparable to it… and worse than any of them…
Yeah italian spaa sucks
1 Like
Which is exactly why I am proposing the APSDS round gets removed and the OTO put down to 10.3.
Implement the 3 round APFSDS drum that is the actual configuration. Allow people to load as much APFSDS they want into the bulk ammo storage.
Drop it to 10.7/10.3, see how it performs and go from there.
This would limit it to 3 APFSDS before needing to restock the secondary drums. I dont see how this will put it at much of an edge over the Lvkv9040C and the 2S38 other than penetration as you would need to wait the long restock time to refill the 3 round APFSDS drum.
3 Likes
Infinite APFSDS+reduction to 10.7 is the bare minimum. It is not because it has been nerfed but everyone around it gets better. As of an missile AA, either SL-ASPIDE, Centauro ADATS, or RO/HU Osa-AKM.
2 Likes
Well what they could do is make the reload around 6-8 seconds and limit the amount of drums you can take in so it can be 10.3 cause Italy needs a good SPAA and not so much a vehicle with a higher penetrating auto cannon cause Italy already has the VCC-80/30 and the KF41 to fill in those jobs.
1 Like
The reload will be whatever the replanisment will be.
And the APFSDS drum kinda limits itself. You get 3 rounds, and then a long replanisment. With that limitation i see no reason to emplace the arbitrary limitation on how many rounds you can carry.
The only arbitrary limitation is that you can only load APFSDS into the dedicated 3 round drum.
The drum seen in this image.
1 Like
So the drum is separate from the auto by being placed on the right side of the gun?
Yup, its there for the very rare chance that the OTO actually had to deal with ground vehicles
Interesting. I don’t understand why gajin didn’t just add that. Plus right now with the ammo transfer speed it would be pretty balanced in 10.0-10.7 area.
It would mean adding a new mechanic. Easier to just bump a vehicle to irrelevancy and apply the mechanic they used for the gepard. Which have a similar system for alternate belts in place
It doesn’t belong to top tier. 10.0 or around it, not 12.0
1 Like
Indeed. 2S6 now is way too much better than the OTO and still has lower BR, and the only reason of keeping OTO such rediculous BR is it can carry up to 11 apfsds rounds, which is basically non-sense because we already have 2S38 in 10.0 now.
2 Likes
This is just a nonsense proposition, the OTOMATIC was designed, built and tested with APFSDS shells. It could be lowered to BR 10.7 as it is, but for GJ to assign BR considering the statistics, it will never happen.
1 Like
Well the OTO is supposed to have 3 round drums for the APSDS rounds but Gajin just gave the OTO the same mechanics as the Gepard which makes it overpowered. The reason I say this is its going to be ages before Gajin fixes this and Italy should be able to get a decent SPAA in 10.3 range. Having APSDS rounds shouldn’t be the main priority of the OTO cause killing tanks isn’t its main job.
1 Like
It doesn’t make sense, because if you nerf it and give it BR 10.3 nothing changes because even at that BR there are planes and helicopters with AGM and GBU that can easily stay out of reach of the OTOMATIC.