EWR VJ 101 and VFW Fokker VAK 191
If only…
1 Like
130mm challenger is the tank British top tier needs to fight 2A7V and Strv 123
1 Like
I meant denied as in the suggestion.
Gaijin denied a lot of things before that still fit suggestion rules (unfinished prototypes like F-111K or O-I) or things that would be added later as the game progressed like more modern vehicles, infantry, etc.
If there was plans for armed VAK191 for example I think at least a suggestion would go through.
im also quite sad Lampyrdae never left the early design phase
those Jumpers were literally ready for arming and going into production
they were at the same step in their development the Eurofighter was at in 1999
not really, more so that germany could have a leo hull 130mm, america can have a 130mm abrams, russia already has obj 292. Each tree ought to have an equal to each other in one way or the other
and Britain could have a chally
Reject CR3
Embrace CR2 Street Fighter II
One is a hugely iconic aircraft known the world over. The other is an obscure prototype / demonstrator most people that are not more dedicated fans would know about. So no, they do not compare at all.
The “much weaker tank” is Britain’s current upcoming main battle tank that will be in operational service.
There is no need to “talk this out”. Its a meaningless matter.
The British suggestion for the Challenger 2 130mm doesn’t need to be passed for its existence to be known. You are acting as though no further research or investigation is done outside of exactly what the suggestion topic contained or exactly who it was suggested for with no other context.
The F-35s are a hugely iconic are far more widely known matter in terms of suggestion and demand.
Its really nothing much to get so significantly worked up about really.
2 Likes
Reject tonk, embrace Brimstone III
Reject tonk, embrace Panzervernichtungstrupp
we have the challenger 3 + epsom ERA/NERA so theres chances of that.
the 130mms are really just a meme tank.
EAP wasn’t a government contracted prototype, it was a private test of avionics systems, using the rather horrific engines from the Tornadoes. Yes, I personally love the Tornado’s engines, but they are very thristy engines.
Whereas Su-47 started in 1983 under government contract… it didn’t stay that way for reasons we can’t discuss here, but the context is different.
Wait… EAP can only carry 4 tons of fuel? That’s 5 minutes of fuel on full afterburner. lol Horrific.
It doesn’t really matter what the nation suggested was in whatever topic passed. It would be down to the devs to decide on any vehicle on a case by case basis regardless. So its a bit of a moot point and a strange one for some people here to be getting so worked up about. Its not a popularity contest.
to us the players which have no insight in the Secret acting of Gaijin it very much looks like this, which is why I and many others expect it to be like this
6 Likes
shame the brimstone launcher isnt operative
Its not a secret at all. Just a few posts above, you would have the direct clarifaction:
“There is no need to pass two almost identical suggestions in the same month. The German suggestion being passed is not some magical barrier that blocks all knowledge of the existence of the British one.”
The nation of which something is suggested (and passed on as a suggestion) is not signficant.
- Something being suggested and passed does not mean it would come to the game anyway
- The nation from which it was suggested and passed does not mean it is limited to just that nation anyway.
1 Like
Im still quite salty about the Royal Sovereign (just like many Royal Navy fans are) I do hope gaijin doesnt have a ground vehicles RS fiasco too. ill leave it at that
Doesn’t that make it less important to be passed to the devs?
If suggestions are meant to bring player ideas forward to the devs, then the devs would already know about something as popular as the F-35 and have in their plans.
Wouldn’t more obscure options have a higher importance here?
4 Likes
@someweirdname was referring to how the passed to dev post and the new years deal is generally the only insights we get other than the leaklists.
Gaijin is a brick wall to players
3 Likes
Not at all. Otherwise it invalidates basically 80-90% of all suggestions.
1 Like
vehicle suggestions are just cermonial. they even passed J35J which had literally been in the game files for a long time so the devs know damn well about it.
1 Like