That just means they weren’t paying attention. They’re impossible to kill if the F-5 is aware of their surroundings.
I own the ROC F-5A which is the same but with 9Ps, and I can confirm that it is incredibly good. Most of my kills in it aren’t even from missiles. It should go up, but it can’t because it is worse than the F-5E.
And back to the main topic, which is about the J-7D being undertiered which is factual. Pl-5Bs are fast, with good range, and the J-7 is a solid platform as well. It should be 11.0 in its current state.
The Kfir Gderot has comparable performance, inferior missile count and comparable missile performance but sits at 11.0 while the J-7D is below it.
I argue the PL-5B is literally the best rear aspect IR missile in the game, period. Magic 1, sidewinders from USAF and USN, K-13, R-60 and others are just outright worse in the majority of scenarios.
Ok? As if there aren’t a dozen+ other jets in similar situations and with worse missiles/platforms? J-7D is too good for 10.7 it’s literally that simple
If u change direction after you flare 1 flare is enough to dodge Aim-9M in nearly every jet in the game do you even know how a 9M seeker works and why they hardest to dodge side aspect??? Can an F-5C 1 flare a Matra 2??? No it cant because THAT missile dont shut off its seeker when it see’s a flare like 9M’s do … I kill lots of F-5C in my Mirage 5F it slays them and they cant ever catch me + im .7 BR lower with waaaay better missiles
The main issue is what it faces in downtiers. At 10.7 and above? yeah its solid but not busted. But in a downtier? Lots of jets can do literally nothing to it, some like the Harriers can flare off missiles but are screwed in an actual dogfight. The F-105 (along with many other non-nimble attackers, that may or may not have countermeasures) are just free food.
and the same can be said imo of pretty much every 10.7 in a full downtier.
Supersonics, with good missiles and CMs vs subsonics with weak missiles and no CMs is never going to be a fair fight.
What is more needed is a decompression of 8.0-10.0. Maybe even pushing up to 11.0/12.0 a bit too. I think what the J-7D faces at and immediately around 10.7 is fine, its just the extreme downtiers which might be an issue.