No, they are sturdier in arcade and have a much more forgiving fm.
Nice swiss cheese. It just shows how tanks are unrealistically strong in this game, since I have never seen any tank get killed by anything less than a direct hit from artillery.
This is plane wrong. Such a hit always destroys an aircraft in RB.
Nice link that shows an aircraft being shot down. :D
He dropped the bomb just as dollar fired at him and after that he had no further control over his elevator and died.
This was just an example i could find quickly. Is there any similarly armored tank that would have survived that?
Yes, about everything that is not a light tank.
And the Arado didn’t survive it. The damage caused by the hit destroyed it. As you can see, his elevator was shot off on both sides and he immediately pitched up after the hit. At that point the only way to control his pitch is by adjustig his throttle and using flaps, which is rather tricky and the reason why this hit killed the Arado.
I said similarly armored ones. And even armored targets have so many weakly armored parts, that many random hits from similar HE will kill them.
Yes, and if it had more bombs, it could have easily dropped them :)
And when a tank gets killed, can it still shoot? Can it still drive?
So, this means that it could possible get back to an airfield?
I have seen and experienced just that.
Similarly armored ones. Only the top tier SAM trucks fall into that category and I have seen those survive all sorts of HE hits.
Not random hits. They have to be in a place where the pressure gets directed through weak areas, such as the hull roof.
It could not have aligned itself for a proper approach. Any successful drop would be the result of luck.
Can a tank die from.critical damage? Apart from.fires no. An aircraft can though and this is what happened in that clip.
With a lot of skill input and a whole bunch of luck he could. In the case of this video, his fate was sealed about 2 seconds after he was hit.
Evidence?
With a HE like this, any hit in the turret fron, cupola, at the tracks (like on german tanks), under tha tank, near MG ports…
With a damage like that. Not every time will be the damage like that.
Also, bombs have a large area of effect.
Why are CASvocates always dishonest?
Anyway, you know, i meant, when you get the “aircraft destroyed” message, yet it proceeds to release it’s remaining payload…
I am not running around recording every shred of gameplay I encounter, but if it helps open your eyes, I will gladly start doing so.
All of which are weakspots. So a ‘random hit anywhere’ won’t do good.
Yes, he will not always be damaged like that. This is about the minimum amount of damage he could receive from such a shot.
A. I am not dishonest. You are just making up stuff.
B. I am overly neutral towards this entire TO thing. I just like to point out fantasy or unqualified posts such as yours.
C. The ‘Aircraft Destroyed’ message is a gameplay issue that carried over from Air RB and is scheduled to be fixed.
The message pops up before the vehicle is actually destroyed and should therefore be ignored until you see the enemy hit the ground or if it was accompanied by the ‘pilot is unconscious’ message. Not knowing that just shows inexperience.
So let’s see what i have asked!
I asked, if it gets killed.
What did you answer?
You answered that dishonestly, becuase the honest answer would point out, that planes can still harm others even after they have died.
“Anyone actually good with usa top tier ground cause im not apparently…I am being serious if anyone here can show me how to play USA toptier Im asking to get better so if you just feel like calling me a scrub go ahead all I ask is for some replay and stats then feel free to call me bad its all good!” -XItsBalanceX Nov 8th
If the 251 doesn’t work for you it doesn’t mean it is shit. Other players are able to work with it. Get the right position with SPAA is key. It is nothing that comes granted and has to be figured out by trial and error. And yes it is hard to learn SPAA but worth the effort.
6 planes and 2 tanks … doesn’t look like shit.
They can’t. If a plane is dead, it can’t do anything anymore. The problem is that at the moment, and this is about to be fixed, the game tells you that you have destroyed the plane, before it is actually dead.
There is nothing dishonest here, just a lack of reading comprehension on your behalf.
I didnt say it doesnt work but that it is shit because vertical angle, you will aways get strafed. It is my go to AA for germany.
So we have a different definition of shit. Shit for me = useless
So it means that the PT-76 is not utterly shit?
EDIT:
Just becaue i had a good game in it, does not mean that it is any good, or even usable.
I have a match with a stock M48 in a full uptier with 14 kills.
Does that mean that a stock M48 is not utterly unplayable?
You are.
I have asked you a question, and you gave an answer to a different one.
So it currently is not fixed.
Is AIDS not an issue now, because in the future it will be cured?
No I think the PT is fine. Most tanks are fine. The player makes the difference. But it seems I got a different understanding of shit.
Shit = useless … I mean complete useless. A dead tank is useless. But this is my understanding of this. The tank can only be as good as I know how to use it. Some tanks are better and some are not so good in my hands. I even dare to say that the Isreal M51 is not shit. It is hard to play sure.
Just becaue i had a good game in it, does not mean that it is any good, or even usable.
So just luck? Should I play now 100 battles to show that the Sd.Kfz. 251 is useable? It wouldn’t matter because other players got other skills and are better with other tanks where I’m not good at. But this doesn’t mean the tank is shit. But I take the challenge. Just for fun.
That is my current stat for that tank. Let’s see what happens …
This is the chinese one, without the stab.
I would not say a tank is only shit when it is completly unusable. And the PT is pretty damn shit.
Now, somehow i managed to get 4.47 K/D in it, but that is just thanks to very passive playstyle.
The overall gameplay experience was awful with it.
The M-51 is fine. Wehraboos cry because it has high pen, but that’s pretty much it.
The Drilling is one of the better ones. 3 pieces of 15mm MG with high rate of fire and at sufficiently low BR that you will see a lot of noobs in planes.
Still good luck against someone who knows what he is doing.
On the other hand, try something, like the US 40mm ones with that very low rate of fire. You can get kills with them too, but they are not as effective.
