I think the problem of F-104A/C is quite complicated; it can’t be just considered right or wrong.
In the downtier match, even though the F-104A/C are nerfed in FM, OP’s claim is right.
The only thing that a subsonic fighter can do is evade as hard as they can.
-until they die.
-or F-104A/C players lose their interest
-or F-104A/C players made a blunder enough to get killed.
Yes. If we only think about F-104A/C itself, it isn’t 9.3BR material. Should go up.
It is insanely faster than other 9.3BR supersonic counterparts, or even some counterparts in higher BR.
F-104A/C is a sinful plane because it created further compression by buffing F-86 and MiG-15/17 a year ago. (F-86 and MiG-15 can’t fight against F-104 so need to- kind of theory)
But the point at which things get complicated is, as always, the compression.
F-104A/C is forced to stay stuck at 9.3BR thanks to an insane level of compression.
If we look uptier match, which majority of jets are filled with supersonics, or [Later, exported variant of F-104], F-104A/C loses its pros rapidly, but cons also grow rapidly.
Also, if we directly compare them with other Supersonic jets like T-2 in 9.7BR, AIM-9B is not good enough to fight against planes in the uptier, which is why we can’t send them up directly to 9.7BR.
F-104A/C needs to go up eventually, and I really hope that today is that day.
But we all know that today can’t be that day.
All we can do is daydream about decompression, which Gaijin will never do. :/
TLDR
1- Yes, F-104A/C is OP and ruining the enjoyment of 8.3-9.3. (Even after nerf. efficiency goes low, but toxicity is high enough.)
2- and it also has the responsibility of ruining 7.0-9.0 thanks to Sabre/MiG buff.
3- But we can’t nerf it directly unless decompression comes up, because she is stuck at somewhat kind of sweetspot.