except we already have zero space anyways for example the most OP 4.3 heavy tank KV1E in a uptier to 5.0 gets curbed stomped by M6A1s in full downtier it curb stomps everything and theres a lot of vehicles that are like this
it doesnt make them money so they wont do it as they profit from compression
And this is why I have said the game needs to double the entire BR range. Alongside probably using all of the missing digits between current numbers (0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.8, and 0.9).
But I agree with you that situations like the KV-1E should not exist of “club or be clubbed.” If it were up to me I’d eliminate the entire concept of uptiers and downtiers.
genuinely how did you get me thinking they’re bad from me saying this. The t58 is obscenely overpowered and needs to be moved up and I just actually despise the maus.
7.0 is the lowest I’d go, but I do see the point. I love playing huge guns (you could probably judge this by the fact that I changed my kill message to “DONK” in honor of getting the hummel), and the maus is arguably one of the best big guns in game. Huge, tanky, absurd HE filler, and gets a secondary 75 firing heat that can obliterate a hellcat in one indirect hit. Facing IS6s. I don’t think it should be immortal, quite the opposite, but at around 7.0 high pen heat rounds like can be found on some pershings and the M51 mean that the maus is realistically balanced, it can nuke absolutely everything but is also very vulnerable when played wrong. I would say it’s one of germanys most skill based vehicles, it’s hard to play it with your brain off and get more than one kill. Seeing some counter arguments that the hull armor is too tanky I would say that, just flank. it has a top speed of 20 k/h, and practically it’s less than 18. it has no hope of stopping anything other than a literal slug from flanking it. It’s also a literal bomb magnet. 7.7 matches it against vehicles like the T95E1 that get early apfsds, and while this isn’t a huge disadvantage on the part of the maus, it certainly ups the challenge.
Undo all the old nerfing of HEAT, HESH, APCR, APDS, APFSDS, Bombs, Rockets, and large-caliber plane guns.
Completely rework big HE to give it the kinetic portion of its penetration its missing so it doesn’t just go “poof” upon impact.
Give all HE rounds the ability to use delayed fuses to make them behave more like SAP as needed - most HE fuses (and even some APHE fuses) could be adjusted on the fly by the crews with a wrench unless they were in an autoloader. Also all 75mm-203mm American HE rounds are missing M78 CP fuses that would literally turn those HE rounds into SAP rounds (these would be additional module unlocks in the game, for example “75mm M48 (M78 fuse)” could be how they’re named).
THEN lower the BRs of all the “rolling brick” heavy tanks that have no mobility to adapt to when their armor doesn’t work. Suddenly, the Maus’s historical opponents would be able to kill it quite reliably. Artillery in direct fire, certain big AP, 90mm APCR, long 90mm APCR, 76mm APCR and APDS - everything else would be functionally overkill.
The Maus faces opponents its armor actually can do something about, but in exchange it and all other heavies lose their artificial survivability of being able to easily “tank” multiple penetrating shots without dying. The tank’s BR is on stilts because the rounds that should be able to kill it currently don’t. And the rounds which can pen it almost universally do fuck all for postpen damage, enabling it to calmly turn the turret, delete the offender, and then repair. Thus I focus on removing that crap, and lowering its BR in compensation.
Don’t forget HESH, i want my old HESH back from it’s glory days!
In all seriousness to all of the points above. As lovely as all that sounds, i don’t realistically see it happening. Not in the near future anyways.
It would require looking at all vehicles affected by the changes, and rebalancing of those vehicles. Which from the ammo types listed, would be nearly all tanks.
I used to have a Maus. Honestly, at 6.7 it would absolutely be unkillable and be the definition of German bias. At 7.7 it is okay, although you do face things like MILAN atgms and 100mm de rupture’s. But hey, the Maus shouldn’t be unkillable, so I think that Maus is pretty decent at that BR.
Correct. And I have thus far come up with a vastly improved single penetration formula that works for all non-APFSDS munition types, which fixes all of this.
Meanwhile Zenturion7 on YouTube showed how easy it is to fix APCR (and therefore also APDS) - just give it the spall pattern assigned to large solid AP. The game automatically downscales exact spall cone sizes with smaller projectile masses and velocities, so it just simply works. I would grant the same to HEATFS too.
I bet a similar “copy-paste” solution would work for restoring HESH postpen.
That would work very well, with the slight caveat that you would have to readjust the brs of a couple of planes. I’m sure all of you know which russian plane I refer to here. HEAT is probably the most annoying round I’ve ever played, not only does it not necessarily detonate on small stuff like bushes irl, but the spall cone and chemical jet are WAY to focused in game. It is fully capable of overpressure and yet never works that way except on open tops. With a little round rebalancing, stuff like the maus and T95/T28 become something that when played a little slower, more at range where you take fewer hits but can dish out more, they become fair. Still a huge CAS target and they have horrible mobility, but the guns can actually do damage and you have to play them correctly, not as some shell sponge that doesn’t care if a shot pens or not. While they wouldn’t get penned much, they would be extremely vulnerable to flankers and even one penning shot could do more than enough damage to end a run. Also yes HE and HEAT rounds both have a significant amount of kinetic pen, which would deal with almost all volumetric issues that tanks like the M44, M55, Hummel, and PzH 2000 experience.
Actually no, I really don’t. Because I look at CAS the same way I do at Tankbusting SPAAG - instead of repeatedly uptiering the “offending vehicle” into oblivion, I would repeatedly buff its counters, lower the offending vehicle’s BR, and EXPECT the people whining about said vehicle to use the empowered tool(s) to solve their “problem” with it themselves, under a “Make. Their. Whining. Their. Fault.” game design philosophy.
HEAT used to in early 1.67 and before spall at roughly 45-60 degrees and reliably would one-tap or two-tap any and all Sloped Russian Bullshit, nevermind German Big Cats. Then the IS-6 arrived and sold better than practically any vehicle in the game’s history at that point in time. Then halfway through 1.67, the M46’s 90mm M348 HEATFS shell got corrected to its proper 305mm penetration. For a week people spammed M46s day in, day out to counter equal spam of IS-6s. IS-3s, T-54s, IS-4Ms, King Tigers, Mice, and others all were collateral damage. Then Snail utterly butchered the round’s postpen and it’s never been good since. THAT nerf is what I would revert.
Precisely. Their BRs would lower until they can reliably stop all but a select handful of derp guns with awkward mobility in exchange for the ability to penetrate anything they meet, such as for instance the 2S1 which has 400mm pen HEATFS. Or the Ikv 103 which is the size of a goddamn cockroach and penetrates 400mm but has KV-2 shell velocity and an open top you can 7.7 to death.
I have a whole separate thread’s worth of stuff on reforming CAS. But long story short, it boils down to 1) removing needlessly aggravating mechanics which buying stuff ingame doesn’t do anything to even fix (therefore it just blatantly harms Gaijin’s business model so why keep it) 2) Empowering all the counters, making them always present in every user’s deck whether they like it or not, and making aircraft no longer beholden to SP walls as if they’re “powerups” and 3) Giving both CAS and Tanks a bunch of new objectives to get the diehards in either camp of the CAS debate off of each other’s throats before they strangle the entire game like Londo and G’Kar from Bablyon 5 did to each other.
Furthermore, wherever applicable, I would also call for adding any and all experimental shells to every applicable vehicle. As long as the vehicle has proper counters, there is no reason why capability cannot be expanded.
For instance, I would give even small-caliber solid AP the same spall cone that larger solid AP has, which the game already down-scales proportionally with penetrator mass. There is no sane reason why one round spalls at up to 60 degrees wide while the latter is basically a needle when both are solid steel projectiles. Would this make stuff like the Yak-9T, P-63, Tempest Vickers P, and other solid shot cannon CAS much more threatening, almost to Yak-9K levels? Yes, and that’s the fucking point. If SPAAG and Fighters are made easily-accessible without dumb SP walls then it falls on players to do something about such planes if they claim to hate them so much.
From what I gather HEAT really doesn’t have significant kinetic pen, and due to standoff distances with the extended nose spike of HEATFS, I really don’t know whether those would have a huge overpressure wave. Maybe spin-stabilized HEAT rounds could given they directly hit the tanks, but honestly I would not know what to even do with stuff like 75mm H.I Gr.B on long 75s, 76mm BP-353A, or 88mm HEAT for that matter. HE with kinetic pen just does the job better in every situation unless you happen to have HEAT in the barrel for some reason and see an armored target to pen which it can even pen that is higher priority than the open top you loaded it for initially.
I actually developed a revised penetration calculator that fixes all of Gaijin’s problems while maintaining simplicity of calculation. It works for all AP, APC, APBC, APHE, APCBC (filled and not), HE, HE-Base Fuse, APCR, APDS, HESH, and I have been trying to get it to work with APFSDS too but thus far am not having a ton of luck. It was originally inspired by how to calculate what the correct kinetic penetration big HE should have to remove the artificial inconsistency SPHs have when running into various common heavy tanks. Yes, Mr. IS-2 or King Tiger, if a 155mm exploding sledgehammer whacks your turret side, that turret would be torn clean off or caved in to the point of unuseability, not “no-damage” for you to retaliate from.
Yeah there is a lot of work to be done, especially when it comes to balancing CAS, namely because the vehicle I was referring to was the Yak 9K. Still performs just fine at 9.3, and I learned that when a guy got a literal nuke with it by killing me 4 times. I don’t disagree that there are other solutions to that sort of balance, but considering both average player skill at that tier and the AAs having no radar or lead indicator there isn’t a lot you could do to “empower” the counter vehicles. And yeah, most HEAT has abysmal post pen not because it’s realistic, but because gaijins tried to balanced it. Admittedly this is true for most rounds, but if you place the shot well it’s still a pain to deal with because it has the pen to go through nearly anything, overpressure lighter stuff, and because it doesn’t volumetric in the same way to AP type rounds it can consistently hit ammo, commander/gunner, the annoying things that mean a skilled player in the M46 or any tank with high pen HEAT (I cannot express how much I hate fighting M51s and M56s, I know they can be balanced differently but having 400 mils of HEAT pen on one of the only examples of HEAT in-game that does decent internal damage and with the M56 being a literal frickin fly in both mobility and size they’re absolutely horrendous to fight in the large casemate TDs that are my primary vehicle style because I like sniping and having heavy armor) can absolutely wipe a lobby.
Oh indeed I was well aware which one you were referring to - but I arrived at the opposite conclusion regarding that plane when all the hubbub over that initially blew up. I thought then and still think now that plane is purely a case of the counters being too weak or unavailable, not the plane being too strong. The Yak-9K was not particularly strong at air-to-air even in its old BR of 4.3, nevermind higher than that.
And that is precisely why I suggest for CAS to massively rebuff the counters so that nobody with any sanity (read: not anyone who supports tank-only mode) can argue why they aren’t shutting the fuck up and going to use said counters if they claim they hate [insert particular CAS vehicle] so damn much. It’s a “Make. Their. Whining. Their. Own. Damn. Fault.” sort of balancing philosophy - when a problem is incapable of being solved by appeasement nerfing, you instead attack the folk doing the complaining by force-feeding them the intended counter(s) to their so-called “problem,” while simultaneously being ready to viciously and ruthlessly pin all blame on the complainer if they still try to whine after the counters have been rebuffed to where they’re always-available and easy to use. Trap the whiners in their own screams, then watch them and their “movements” on social media wither away, just like the “History Channel Tiger Driver” epidemic did in years past to the point of becoming a community meme.
For the full details of what I would propose:
Part One: Removing Unnecessarily Rage-Inducing Mechanics.
Spoiler
Remove the kill camera completely, or at most have it show the final few seconds of the current one with not even the slightest snapshot of where the killer was. Dying should not reward you with someone’s location in a game all about positional actions.
Make all planes runway spawn, engine off.
Remove all helicopter pads that are separate from runways, and instead make helicopters spawn on the plane runway complex with the engine off, perhaps at the front end of it.
Remove the text notifications of “[Insert] Team is Capturing Zone [Letter]” - these for all intents and purposes read to any CAS in the region as “Fresh meat here ripe for slaughter.” The game already has the flashing ticket bar and icons below that for each cap - this message is redundant and needlessly frustrating.
Part Two: Rebuffing The Counters and Adding New Ones.
Spoiler
(Probably the most controversial point) I firmly believe CAS is fundamentally unbalanceable as long as it remains a thing people lack access to at match start and must “earn through doing stuff on the ground.” No matter what you set it to, people will always find some way to rapidly access it before their opponents think to field counters. Raising the SP costs higher than they already are would render CAS inaccessible to anything that is not already a scout vehicle. Therefore I propose pivoting completely to Simulator Mode’s SP system - 1000SP per player at match start and no ability to earn more through any actions whatsoever. Everything would be available as a first spawn with any loadout, but so would its counters of Fighters and SPAAG, therefore NOBODY has ANY EXCUSE to complain.
SP costs of various weaponry would be properly itemized so small CAS loadouts are no longer stupidly-expensive compared to planes wielding much larger ones.
The baseline costs of Fighters without air-to-ground weaponry would be slashed to a third of their present values.
The costs of tanks of all flavors would be likely reduced somewhat.
All SP cost doubling would be eliminated, as the fixed supply of 1000SP means nobody would be able to earn more than one spawn of a given vehicle anyways.
Dying in a vehicle would not remove it from your lineup if you have SP to use it again. You can spawn it as many times as you wish until you are out of SP. This solves the issue of some nations having only one competent machine at some BRs.
All SPAAG, Tank MGs under independent control, Heavy Flak TDs (think the Flakbus, VFW, YaG-10 (29-K), QF 3.7 Ram, Breda 90/53), and all SPHs which have HE-VT rounds available would be given short-ranged lead indicators based on the Rangefinding Crew Skill. All stock crews get this from 0-1000m, with Aced Crews at maximum Rangefinding+Leadership skills extending it up to 1600m. Now even the densest idiots are told where to shoot, but only when the plane is close enough to even bother. Even Radar SPAAG would have this feature when their radars are either turned off manually or knocked out from battle damage.
The existing feature of giving all users default SPAAG and a backup MBT in higher ranks would be extended to all BRs, and it would also be expanded to include a default Fighter and a default CAS, all using preset ammunition loads or ordinance loadouts where applicable. Now even the most stubborn tank-only supporters cannot dare argue they aren’t able to access the counters to the CAS they hate.
(Another highly controversial take) SPAAG being able to more accurately hit planes is good and all, but player behavior shows plainly that if the given SPAAG does not have adequate anti-tank ability, the vast majority of players will NOT move outside their own spawn zone. Then tank players in the map center still whine endlessly about how “OP” CAS supposedly is while the SPAAG then get ganged up on in/near spawn and also whine as a result. Therefore I propose undoing the repeated nerfing of SPAAGs’ (and autocannons more broadly) anti-tank capabilities. Almost all SPAAGs are outright missing their best anti-tank ammunition types. Some have their best ammunition types but due to deliberate penalty nerfing and a legacy of global nerfing for APCR and APDS either don’t pen at all or do fuck all postpen when they do pen. I would even go so far as to give some time-traveling rounds to make them guaranteed able to melt the sides and rears of most tanks they could encounter. All their BRs would intentionally be altered to ensure they are competent “Ersatz TDs,” in many cases lower than now. SPAAGs butchering tanks would be force-normalized until the whiners give the fuck up - the actual problems of old 2D armor models full of gaps and holes are not fixed by nerfing SPAAG.
Tank cannon barrels would intentionally become immune to all damage regardless of weapon or caliber that hits it. This is mainly to prevent SPAAGs from melting the barrels of whatever they cannot frontally pen to then try flanking it while it repairs, but this would also help all the beleaguered heavy tanks and heavy casemate TDs with similar issues.
All SAMs physically able to aim their launchers down in a direct-fire manner would be made able to dumb-fire their weapons. This is to give all SAMs with the ability to aim actual anti-tank capability.
All IR SAMs would be modeled similarly to the Strela in terms of how easily it locks onto targets.
All Helicopters would actually be locked by IR SAMs from reasonable distances, even in cold weather.
All Helicopters would have a constant Doppler return from their spinning rotor blades even when stationary.
The act of firing your own missile to counter the enemy’s missile would become impossible, specifically so a helicopter cannot fire 12-16 missiles against a SAM with at most 2-4 ready to shoot between reloads. Use hard cover to evade the missile…or else.
Part Three: Adding New Objectives for Both CAS and Tanks to Distract the Die-Hards in Both Camps and Get Them Off of Each Other’s Throats for Good.
Spoiler
Copy over the Cap Zone design from Naval EC, where caps double as spawns for the team controlling them. Current spawn zones now double as caps, and on each map where there are currently two spawns automatically by default, each team now starts with just ONE under their control to spawn at initially, sorta like [Battle] Mode.
Each of these “Command Posts” (yes I got the idea from OG Star Wars Battlefront 2 only to later see Naval EC already had it) would have some AI-controlled Pillboxes and AT Guns that actually fire. These are intentionally only moderate-potency weapons for each BR and vary based on the nation capturing the zone. In higher ranks towed AT guns are replaced by ATGM launchers. Like Naval EC caps, these must be all destroyed to begin capturing the zone, but unlike Naval EC they do not respawn unless players of the same team drive up to each emplacement to physically fix them. Killing these bleeds chunks of tickets like killing players does, and killing these rewards RP and SL like killing players does, intentionally to give CAS something productive to kill that cannot go scream on the forums upon death. Tanks, particularly ones with bunker-killing derp guns, would be expected to also kill these when CAS isn’t available or is distracted.
The new “Command Post” style objectives enable map sizes to dramatically increase without adding “meaningless driving time only to be one-shot and then do it all over again.” Instead the likely new meta would be to use fast machines to grab forward cap zones and spawn superheavies up front later on upon the death of the initial scouts.
The ability to capture even rear enemy spawn points will solve much of the spawn-camping complaints, because now when a flanking party has finished a flank, they do not need to sit there staring down the spawn zone to shut off enemy reinforcement flow - instead they can capture that zone and encircle the enemy team spawning mid-map. Obviously this means removing nearly all spawn invulnerability, all map red-zoning, all minimap highlighting, all flashing chevrons from people shooting into spawns, etc.
The Artillery Support mechanic gets a total makeover, and is split into Gun Artillery and Rocket Artillery. Each team has three batteries of each with their own reload timers, so you do not have say 16 impatient players spamming 32 consecutive artillery barrages all on Cap Zone C. These also scale with the BR range and the nations in a given team. Up to the early Cold War era, gun sizes grow and number of rounds per barrage proportionately decreases. Past then, gun sizes shrink down to modern 150mm-203mm sizes but rounds per barrage substantially increase. Killing these also rewards like killing players and bleeds ticket chunks like killing players, again to lure CAS away from player tanks because bots don’t whine when they die.
Bombing targets would be brought back on tank maps, and be worth tickets when killed. Destroying all 3-4 would open runways to be destroyed, but destroying those would NOT auto-end the match - it just blocks further plane/helicopter spawns or repairs/rearms of existing ones.
Spawning at each bombing target early game is a convoy of light trucks and maybe a few bot tanks+SPAAG. Killing these does NOT bleed tickets, but each unit arriving adds tickets equal to ten player/bot deaths to its respective team.
THAT is how I would solve CAS. Anyone who wants to pick up the counters would be now empowered to do so. Anyone who wants to sit back in their tank and keep complaining would be laughed out of the room by all the rest who have picked up the counters already.
And for whomever decided to flag this as off-topic, I was merely replying to another user regarding what he asked about - in case you’re wondering how fixing CAS is relevant to properly-tiering superheavies such as the Maus, I’ll break it down simply:
CAS weaponry is in many cases overkill-nerfed, where it struggles to kill much of what it damn well should, or demands comically large ordinance to kill stuff that realistically needed far less. The nerfed weapons mean superheavies like the Maus, T95, IS-4M, and others survive more hits than they otherwise would have. This pushes up their battle statistics, and contributes to their BRs remaining so high that their armor becomes borderline-irrelevant. Thus empowering the counter to camping heavies locking down map swathes will ironically HELP, not HARM, said heavies’ overall experience.
I vehemently disagree that nerfing whole ammo classes actually balances them at all. If HEAT has proper postpen damage, then the vast majority of tanks using it become fundamentally incompatible with all WW2 or Early Cold War tanks, and are forced upwards in BR to where they no longer meet them. This would require BR decompression en masse (at least doubling the entire range) to make sufficient room, especially when you also factor in undoing nerfs of APCR, APDS, HESH, HE, and others.
Also, they need to add proper spall cones to APHE. Right now it exists, but does practically nothing. There are SO many examples in youtube videos demonstrating shooting right next to the ammo, a place where the spall cone does hit it, but it doesn’t do enough damage. And that’s another thing, “yellow” ammo DOES NOT EXIST. If the ammo is hit, it blows up. There are no documented cases that I know of of any round designed with internal damage in mind hitting ammo/fuel and not detonating it. The reason I specify designed for internal damage is simply incidents of dud, non fusing, or simple AP rounds hitting things like bomber fuel tanks or wet ammo storages and not doing that much. I understand that thing like this do involve A LOT of work, and the community is really not helpful most of the time, but if Gaijin were willing to try and work with it then maybe the community would offer up more opinions and discussions like this that have good ideas and valid points.
Then why are you suggesting it to be 7.0 and face 6.0
Not a single pershing or any other ww2 vehicle at this BR has high pen heat
Even if you own every tank in the game, high pen heat vehicles at 6.0-7.3 make up a tiny minority of the vehicles.
You cannot expect a tank to be balanced around only a hyper specific class of vehicle being able to counter it. The Maus is practically immune to all conventional ammo in the game which is the majority of what it would face at 7.0
The IS-6 cannot kill a maus practically anywhere
War thunder, the game that famously has maps that allow flanking
which can then only pen the maus in the turret cheeks and only the level horizontal section and not the top 33% or bottom 33%
For the Maus’s sake? Absolutely not
So make them unkillable murder machines until hyper specific vehicles show up to counter them?
ahem CAS versus AA. and the maus is a frontal rolling bunker. most stuff at 6.3 and above can kill it from the side or back and it’s not hard to flank, and I’m not referring to the volumetric shot with the sherman HE round that one taps it, instead that knowledge of weakspots and skill will get you along perfectly fine. I manage to fight IS3s, having similar armor levels in a downtier, and win perfectly fine.
The IS6 kills a Maus rather easily, it can sometimes pen the mantlet straight on, or once, again flank it. Don’t try to complain about the Maus being invincible frontally. Look at the Jagtiger and the win rate with that.
I wouldn’t call flanking light tanks or a decent russian player hyper specific.
Not just for the Maus. Allowing all those rounds realistic damage would make a lot of things much more balanced, for instance matching WWII vehicles against Cold War stuff significantly less, so it doesn’t have to compete with mobility, as much as 400 millimeters of pen, and even early APFSDS. I disagree slightly that bombs should be un-nerfed, but at the same time rebalancing planes and changing loadouts a little would help with that.