Directly translates to “one who violates” or “severe predator”
Potato tomato
Directly translates to “one who violates” or “severe predator”
Potato tomato
If you consider the Tiger II (H) a good “counter-flanker,” then there’s no point in continuing this conversation.
To clarify my position: you seem to think I want to see the T-34-76 facing the Tiger I (H).
That is not what I want at all; yet, you act as if it is.
What I want is for vehicles that are, to some extent, historically balanced against one another to be grouped together.
For instance, the T-44 is a well-suited opponent for the Panther Ausf. A, F, and G models. The T-34 series had begun to fall behind, which is precisely why they started developing the T-44. Even on the German side, Heinz Guderian shared this view, suggesting that the introduction of the Panther series had shifted the advantage back in their favor.
However, these 1948–50 models—including the T-44-100, which was completed in February 1945—completely shatter this balance.
This is evident in the chart your friend provided, and I see it in-game as well: the sluggish Tigers are quickly flanked and destroyed by crossfire.
Furthermore, I have no issue with the ARL-44 appearing against the Panther D or the Tiger I (H)—while it is a problematic model, it remains within a tolerable range. The same goes for the M18 tank destroyer; in my view, it is the best American vehicle.
The real problem, however, lies in the biased claims made by people like you—individuals who deliberately spread falsehoods and clearly have no understanding of what a “simulation battle” is actually supposed to be.
In realistic battles, when someone is at a certain location, you can mark it so that other players in the game can see the marked spot—for instance, by indicating “over by the side of that house.”
This feature does not exist in simulation mode.
You are deliberately manipulating the subject and being untruthful.
Much like when you claimed, “The T-34-85 is the equivalent of the Panther F series.”
… No words.
It’s not like I’m speaking from experience or anything, right?
Your position is that you hate facing vehicles that have a significant mobility advantage over late-war German heavies and/or are more performing than late-war German medium tanks. That much is abundantly clear.
Like I already told you, there are two approaches to the issue which are internally consistent. One is to go by performance, which leads us back to the Battle Rating system. However, you are not happy with a system like that either, because in that system, the EBR that you hate so much would still be lower than the Panthers, even if you would no longer see the Char25T. So, this first system is not to your liking.
The second system is to go full historical matchmaking. Besides the obvious problem this creates for people who don’t play one of the major nations, it would also not solve your balance problem, because the Panther F would belong in the same lobby as the T-54 if we went that hypothetical route.
So your proposed “solution” is just to remove tanks you don’t like fighting from the sim lobbies.
If your concern is balance, then forget about year of introduction and ask for an equivalent of the BR system, fully in the knowledge that this will create anachronistic fights.
I can’t put it any simpler than this.
How can it be a 48-50 model if it was completed in February 1945?
Also, since we are comparing it to the Panther F, we are talking about a design for which the Germans had this plan:
Development would end in April of 1945 and mass production was meant to begin in July of 1945.
So what are we even talking about here?
I think you keep confusing arcade and realistic. The “attention to the map” and “squad ping” mechanics work exactly the same in both game modes. It is also irrelevant to this discussion anyway, because a lot of the time, when you choose to do counter-flanking, you are going to be on your own. As a general rule in War Thunder 80% of the team will just press W out of spawn. If you set yourself the task to protect the flanks, you’ll rarely be playing with team mates anyway.
I am instead talking about skills that are used in exactly the same fashion in both RB and SB. You listen for engine noises, look at known spots and power positions likely to be targeted first by an aggressive enemy, and you dig em out of there.
So, what you’re saying is: “Actually, the Panther F should be facing the T-54; you should be grateful it’s facing lower-tier models instead.”
You also claimed that I’m “bothered” because there are better medium tanks on the opposing side. You’re quite the manipulator.
“Better” is a massive understatement—they are far, far, far better.
I mean, even Gaijin has placed these medium tanks at the 6.0 BR level. There’s the AMX-50, the Char 25t (at 7.7–8.0 BR), and the Centurion Mk.3—the Caernarvon is in the same boat. Should I keep listing more?
“Despite the existence of equivalent tanks, they’ve stubbornly chosen to include vehicles that are simply superior.”
Do you not grasp this?
And you also claimed that in Simulation Battles, people just press ‘W’ and drive straight ahead. Right—because, clearly, Sim players are just playing like it’s Arcade mode, driving straight forward without ever looking left or right. Sure, of course.
You say they’re supposed to “hold the corners”—huh! By the time a Tiger II (H) manages to climb a single hill, the enemy’s fast-moving vehicles have already crossed three or four other hills.
I think you’re part of that 80% too.
In other words, the task assigned to players of the German tech tree is to face off against models produced between 1950 and 1960 using heavy tanks. It’s the classic fate of a German-tree player: having to struggle against far superior enemies.
Why are you condemning German-tree players to this? Why is the Panther II being removed from the tech tree? If “paper vehicles” (blueprint-only designs) are supposedly a problem, why are the H39, Stalingrad, Sevastopol, Soyuz, and Tiger II (Sla) being added to the game?
#By acting this way—allowing people who engage in blatant lies, manipulation, and biased rhetoric to speak—you are going to lose your player base.
Also, the translation tool is misinterpreting some sentences, leading to misunderstandings.
My point is that models from the 1950s and 60s are already at the top tier; the T-44-100, for instance—even though it was built in February 1945—is a top-tier vehicle, much like the IS-3, and the Panther series simply falls short against it.
In fact, the Panther II project was proposed precisely because of such shortcomings.
If the T-44 had actually appeared on the front lines, this project might have been accelerated even further.
The T-44-100 is at Tier 7.
The T-44, M26, and Centurion mk1 are more than capable of holding their own against the Panther models—both in terms of historical context and game balance.
Actually, my proposed solution is to bring back the Panther II, the Tiger 10.5, and the Coelian.
The AMX-50 TOA90 was contracted in 1945 and completed in 1949.
The T-44-100 (or 44B, whichever you choose to prefer) was contracted in late '44 and had its first vehicles made in Feb of 1945.
The T-44-122 was contracted in late '43 and had its first vehicles made in Jan of 1944 alongside the 44A.
The Panther G and F, both of which you’ve named, were made alongside both T-44 variants and alongside it, with the AMX-50 TOA90 completing trials at the same time that France operated the Panther lineage.
What about this matchup is anachronistic?
Once again, Cent Mk.3 came in 1947 with the Mk2 in 1946.
Caernarvon’s chassis was complete in 1949 and had its turrets mated in 1952.
IS-2M is nothing more than a depo-level overhaul of an already existing design from 1944… Gonna whine about its engine from 1956 and the sheet metal welded to the hull?
IS-2 '44 is from '44 brother, it predates the Panther F lmao
Super Pershing is also a wartime design, if you’re talking about the T26E5.
All of these are very realistic matchups for the Panther line, as the 503rd would have fought alongside and against every single tank listed here by its date of decomm, 1952. (Except the IS-2M, but an uprated variant that changes very little isn’t much to preach about)
Yeah, newer tanks are superior to older tanks. Big whoop?
The hell is this even asking for?
You are lying.
The AMX series all entered service in 1950 or later.
By that same logic, jet aircraft began flying as early as July 1942 with the Messerschmitt Me 262 V3—so perhaps we should use that year as our starting point for everything.
Me when I spam on forums (they will eventually bam me from posting)
Please do that
I will not fall for their provocations.
Frankly, the solution to this problem is to bring back vehicles that were removed from the game—much like the Maus tank.
This is the only solution to the issue.
Gurl, it was available to research like, a week ago
Yes, the Maus—a tank that’s enough to trigger a nervous breakdown. It’s just so incredibly slow.
T-54s can easily catch it in an ambush.
Its presence in the tech tree doesn’t really change much in terms of gameplay.
The solution for this line is simple: bring back the Panther II, the Tiger II (10.5 cm), and the Coelian.
itd be swell if a moderator looked at what this guy’s name means in turkish lmao.
@Schindibee please
Apparently people flagged a post I mentioned needs moderator opinion???
@Stona_WT can you please lock this thread and/or give the OP a suspension? In case you need a list of what’s wrong:
thank you!
Also apparently this is worth flagging but the post isn’t lockable. Bruh
Schindibee is a Game Master, GMs handle chat bans. If you are looking for a person capable of locking threads then you should be looking for an actual moderator.
If this topic is unimportant to you, why are you putting so much effort into getting it shut down?
I am asking this of those who continue to engage in provocation.
Do the AMX 50 100, Bat.-Châtillon 25t, T-44-100, Centurion Mk. 3, and the Panther F and G perform at a similar level?
There is a major issue regarding medium tanks.
It is much like the situation where an IS-7 might encounter tanks from the Leopard series.
No, but that is incorrect comparison, as Panthers appear first in 5-1 an them Chat 25 and T-44 in 6-1
Tho it seems ridiculous to have that 6.1 fight with lineup of axis that dont have any 7.3 like M48s or M47s at least
Because your reactions are entertaining while migrating via train.
No, not for you, you don’t need them.
You’ve never tried any nation other than Germany. U can’t complain about vehicles without ever test them and only faced them. The game is based on a certain balance with BR and needs to be balanced against what you’re facing, even in simulator mode.
Fed up? Switch nations, you’ll see it won’t change the way you are.
Don’t worry, I’ve done plenty of test drives.
They are incredibly fast, their ammunition is excellent, and their turret traverse speeds are high, too.
Are you suggesting that the Panther F and G series are superior to the AMX-50 (90/100), the Char 25t and its variants, the T-44-100 in the Soviet tree, and various vehicles in the British tree? Well, it certainly seems that way.
Even Gaijin has set the Battle Ratings (BR) for these vehicles quite high.
You’re mistaken; the Panther II, Tiger 10.5 cm, and Coelian actually seem necessary for this game. This is even reflected in the statistics.
Btw, to test drive a vehicle, you have to either have it unlocked, or have it as the next vehicle in a line. So if you are so progressed in the British, Soviet, and French trees, why don’t you play actual games with them?
The only possible way to test drive Char 25, you have to have Lorraine 40 unlocked?
That really brings me down.
It might even be enough to make me quit the game.
The P-51 D-10’s incredibly smooth flight characteristics were a real downer for me.