An unfair Ground Simulator Battle featuring vehicles such as the Tiger II (H), Panther F, Panther G, Jagdpanther, and Ferdinand

We don’t claim him

1 Like

A very good chart.

At the 6.7–7.0 BR (Battle Rating) range, these vehicles almost always lose, primarily because they frequently face compact, high-tier vehicles produced after 1950.

This is the core issue we’re talking about.

The German tech tree has no equivalent to these vehicles—and if you jump into a match, you’ll see that most people are playing the German tree. In a typical 15- or 16-player match, you’ll find at most 3 or 4 players using French or Italian medium vehicles.

Honestly, that’s their own choice; there are other alternatives available.

The folks here can also play against bots. They actually play quite well, too.

centurion mk3?

shot mk3 ammunition?

Skill issue

Oh no! Forced to rely on some of the most meta defining heavy tanks in the game

Situational awareness/skill issue

That’s entirely up to you, since the problem described in this thread (the third you’ve created on the subject) is entirely located within your skill. Good luck!

1 Like

… For real?

Let’s compare the Panther F and G models against the AMX 50 (100/90), Char 25t, AMX 13, Centurion Mk 3, and T-44-100, looking at which ones are superior and which are inferior.

I’ll break down the comparison: The AMX series—which entered service in the 1950s—features ammunition with at least 200–270 mm of penetration, turret traverse speeds twice as fast as the Panther models, and a 4-second reload time; they are, in effect, more advanced, compact vehicles.

Although the Centurion models are slower, the Shot Mk 3 (produced in 1948) utilizes formidable ammunition capable of penetrating 381 mm of armor. The Caernarvon heavy tank—which costs roughly as much as a Tiger II—boasts a 6-second reload time.

As for the T-44-100, while it serves as a contemporary to the Panther F and G, it represents a more forward-looking design that helped shape like is3 the future of tank development.

In fact, all of these tanks can destroy the Panther models by firing directly into the hull without needing to aim for specific weak points; the Panther, by contrast, can only achieve a penetration against these vehicles by targeting very precise, specific spots.

These “space-age” machines, however, can penetrate the Panther’s hull with direct, center-mass shots.

You also mentioned heavy tanks: the IS-2 (1944 and M variants), the Super Pershing, and the Caernarvon are all quite capable of standing up to the Tiger II. Depending on the situation, they may perform worse in some aspects but better in others—as is the case with the Caernarvon.

The vehicles in question—especially the French models—are so highly mobile that by the time a Tiger II (H) has covered a certain distance, the opposing side has already traveled four times as far, securing positions along the map’s edges and setting up devastating ambushes that frequently net them 4–5 kills per match. Furthermore, vehicles that come with two respawns tend to play more cautiously, anchoring themselves firmly along the map’s periphery; this allows the enemy to expand their perimeter, gain firing angles from various new positions, and ultimately dominate the game.

As mentioned in other comments, one might assume the low win rate is due to the presence of many “unskilled” players like myself—but that is not the root of the problem. The real issue is:

The medium tank crisis.

My detailed analyses in response to your brief, provocative posts.

I’m sure you’ve never even played the tank simulation battles, either.

For those like you, who have grown through short-form content—much like YouTube Shorts—these texts must surely feel like a form of torment.

However, I would ask the rest of you to at least take a look, gather some ideas, and then share your own deductions in the comments.

As I have told you before, you cannot have your cake and eat it. You have two options:

  1. Historical MM
  2. BRs set by performance

If you go with BRs set by performance, it is justifiable to have an environment where these medium tanks rarely meet. For example, in GRB the Panthers are 6.0 and the T-44-100 is 7.0, meaning that you will meet them only in a full uptier.

Having said that, your credibility problem is that you are ostensibly against performance-based MM. What you want instead is historical MM.

Now, under historical MM considerations, the T-44-100 is exactly what your beloved Panther F would be fighting, alongside the regular T-44 and the T-54. Because if the war had continued such that the Panther F entered into mass production, this is the mass-produced Soviet opposition it would have to fight.

The French vehicle selection is simply a product of the lack of relevant alternatives. This is a weakness of simulator in ground as far as I am concerned, since it looks like the mode can’t decide between fully historical rooms and pseudo-BRs, so for me the solution is simple - GSB should have BRs, just like ASB does.

Either way, you are simply not credible because you want historical MM only when it suits you.

As a final point, I will note that you can frontally kill every single one of these medium tanks in a Panther, all you need to win an engagement against them is skill.

Of course. It would be very imbalanced otherwise. But the Tiger IIs are amazing.

Skill issue. Tiger IIs are excellent counter-flankers.

Wrong.

You have levelled this accusation at me before, and I responded to you with a colossal wall of text, which you pretended to read and then decided to ignore by calling me a manipulative filthy liar, the worst kind of human being, and then added some kind of Turkish insult for good measure.

If I respond to you with brevity, it is because you have already demonstrated you cannot handle an adult conversation without resorting to name-calling, and because your arguments are trash.

1 Like

They feel like torment because you constantly harp on the year a vehicle began production and act like a vehicle being made in like 1947 is an unkillable demi-god in the face of a 1945 vehicle.

2 Likes

Meanwhile, the humble state of Soviet tank production in 1944 and 1945:

"Order of the People’s Commissar of Tank Production of the USSR #637s
Moscow
November 1st, 1944

Factory #183 (comrade Morozov) developed a new T-54 medium tank with improved armour.

The review of the project showed that the new T-54 medium tank retains high maneuverability and mobility characteristics but has significantly better armour and more powerful armament than existing medium tanks.

The presented T-54 medium tank project should be approved and a prototype developed.

In order to develop the new T-54 medium tank, I order that:

Director of factory #183 comrade Maksarev and Chief Designer of factory #183 comrade Morozov must develop blueprints of the new medium tank with a 100 mm D-10T gun with the following armour thicknesses by December 1st of this year:
    Upper front plate: 120 mm
    Lower front plate: 120 mm
    Sides: 90 mm
    Turret front: 150 mm
    Front section of turret sides: 150 mm
The turret design should be similar to that of the IS-6 with a commander's observation device installed in a rotating hatch without a commander's cupola. Use high hardness armour for the turret, with a ring to be welded into the upper turret ring.
The full weight of the tank must not be greater than 34 tons.
Director of factory #183, comrade Maksarev, must produce a prototype of the T-54 by January 1st, 1945, and complete trials by January 15th."

Photo from February 1945.

Historical matchmaker for thee and not for me.

1 Like

As for the T-44-100, while it serves as a contemporary to the Panther F and G, it represents a more forward-looking design that helped shape like is3 the future of tank development.

You’ve misread my post again—look, I’ve included a quote from my previous comment above where I already pointed this out.

If we were going by historical accuracy, IS-3s would be facing Tiger II (H)s. Strangely, the game doesn’t include this matchup; I honestly don’t understand how they could overlook something like that.

Are you suggesting that Tiger II (H)s are excellent “counter-flankers”?

For heaven’s sake, the tank barely manages 20 km/h on uneven terrain, while other vehicles hit at least 40 km/h—sometimes even 50 km/h. Why are you spouting such blatant lies?

Could it be that you’re talking about “realistic battles” or something similar?

In those modes, if you mark a location, it shows up on the map for everyone to see. That’s not the case here.

Look, you keep stubbornly steering the conversation toward specific points, and you aren’t even reading what I’m saying. My point is that certain vehicles have been added to the game despite the existence of more appropriate, equivalent counterparts.

I’m not insisting that everything must be historically identical—if that were my position, I’d be asking for T-34-76s to face the Tiger I (H). Don’t twist my words.

There is no balance here; French and British tanks—along with the specific Russian tank I mentioned—possess superior performance and are completely dominating the game.

1948 - so not long after ww2 officially ended.

I dont remember the exact date, but it was in 2022. February maybe. You`re mistaken there: SIM was always on the lineups since it was added, it was its feature. People waited several weeks before new techs was added to lineups of sim battles :3

They tried basic matchmaking at 2022 time and it didnt work: first day everyone tried sim, but then online died to usual numbers but it was impossible to find a game as everyone wanted to play different BR, the only one alive was 6.7 and only if you wanted to play AGAINST germany (everyone wanted to dominate with Tiger2)

I wholeheartedly agree, but thats what Germans ask for

That realy is funny to see how they call it sim yet add all postwar techs to ww2 lineups. THats hilarious.

1 Like

It is you who keeps misreading. You have to decide what you want. If you want historical matchmaking, you can’t complain about meeting superior opposition (and in fact you should advocate for the Panther F to see the T-54). If you don’t want historical MM, then you should be fine with vehicles fighting each other even if they are from different time periods.

Instead, you keep trying for a nonexistent middle ground because the truth is that the vehicles you want to exclude are simply those you don’t like to fight.

Correct.

In realistic battles, tanks have the same mobility, targeting speed and rate of fire as they do in simulator battles. The primary differences are of course parallax shooting (but you can negate this with binoculars), the inability to peek behind corners or over-cover, and sometimes but not always, larger maps.

While this sometimes can reduce your situational awareness, it does not fundamentally change how you play. Whether I’m using them in sim or realistic, I play Tiger IIs the exact same way. And yes, that often means deliberately seeking out the flanking enemies so you can remove them before they annihilate your team.

After doing some digging, I think i was remembering the short time in 2014-2015 when they had regular mm.

probs was back then, i only play since 2017 if i remember correctly

I mean, depends what “sim” means. For example, “sim” could just mean “simulator controls” and that means you get a more grounded experience without barrel cameras or third person corner camping etc. Or it could mean simulating real battles or whatever.

Personally, I would stick to the former. Give SB a full BR-like system and open up the matchmaker so all nations can be on either team. The current compromise is just an unhappy one imho.

For example what’s the point of doing Axis vs Allies for historical reasons if you then have to add neutral Sweden to one side so that Swedish players can also play? By all means let them play, just remove the team restrictions so team composition works like GRB!

Or, if ahistorical vehicles are placed ahistorically in otherwise-historical lobbies for balance reasons… Just to all the way with balance-first and use the BR system that already works so well in realistic!

Imho the best features of sim are all immersive in nature. You’re alone in your tank’s commander position in a massive map with only faint knowledge of where friendlies are, and only your instincts and experience about where enemies might be.

The closed nation MM and the lobby rotation on the other hand are just annoying to me.

nah bro i get it so we want sim players to suffer as we do but christ let at least them have a proper War Thunder experience

I keep off sim as it makes me feel lonely on the map, plus they use huge landscapes there often which i hate.

But the Axis VS Allies is what i miss in current GRB. Which is stupid they removed it as it works in small sim lobbies but somehow doesnt on bid RB lobbies? idk it sounds stupid

Spoiler: it doesn’t, it’s just that with sim’s low player base it’s not a priority to fix it and it helps give the mode more of an identity.

I think nation vs nation would still be fine. But the fixed line-ups are what is annoying.

Have it Axis vs Allies but we can make our own line-ups.