‘test drive’ not event fully upgrade. Sure.
he’s just a liar trying to put some argument, just like the Turkish only thing popuplar at : FUE
‘test drive’ not event fully upgrade. Sure.
he’s just a liar trying to put some argument, just like the Turkish only thing popuplar at : FUE
Whether I play or not doesn’t change anything.
Someone shared a poll above. The tier where the Tiger II (H) sits is constantly losing. It’s all right there—there’s essentially no such thing as a medium tank at that level.
Can you answer this question: Are the Panther F and G, AMX 50 100, Char 25t, T-44-100, and the British Centurion Mk 3 on par with vehicles that have 381mm of penetration? Are they of equal strength?
Why are you dodging the question and trying to muddy the waters?
Besides, it actually works in my favor—it keeps the thread near the top, so please, by all means, keep it up.
It is much easier to build a to scale wooden mock up (a few days or weeks) of an armored vehicle or aircraft than the countless man hours, space, resources and manpower to build a battleship which takes years. Countless committee reviews and revisions both before and during construction alongside the requirements of mathematical equations to make sure the hull is even properly buoyant to begin with before construction is even started.
That’s not including the metallurgy for the massive steel plates, 700 to 3.3k men (depending on the era/size of the battleship) needed to be trained and crewed, guns that need to be tested (if new and untested), etc.
I think this is off topic for the thread, however.
Test drives don’t count. You can’t see the armor protection since nothing shoots at you on them. Like get those vehicles before you start your bitching about them
You forgot one thing, you’ve never play those British line and 17pdr - 84pdr -105mm - 120 mm with EARLY APDS: ‘‘shell shattered’’.
→ Conqueror mk2 is not good - #10 by Whiskey_077
(we can’t putt image in your topic because of you)
Plus : Early apds are weak, you’ve APHE with high penetration on your german vehicules. Do you want to complaint about the issue ? Play your M48A2C with APCR.
Again : High penetration with APDS not meaning doing damage inside of the vehicule. We need to aim specific point on the vehicule to make damage. (change with late APDS at 8.3-8.7 totaly different) and APCBCs (Shot mk.1)are better with the 84mm, but to compare with aphe of the 88mm, even the 75mm, you’ve explosive filler.
The only thing about The Centurion is the Stab, this why it’s 7.7, In the beginning of thew introduction of the British tech tree, the centurion was 6.7 in 2016, same BR of your Tiger II, even the Fv4202 was 6.0 (no apds). Centurion mk10 was 7.0 for a long time before to move at 7.7 then 8.0.
→ There was a poll on the APHE mechanics that passed with 51% voting yes, but Gaijin canceled it because of the remaining 49%.
→ There have been two APDS nerfs in recent years.
→ There have also been three HESH nerfs/changes, two of which happened before you even started playing in 2022.
You never experienced the good era.
Counter question : can you stop being german_fanboy_plaintive and change your name before a Game Master do with a renamed automatic bot number’name ?
In simulation battles, armor protection doesn’t matter. If armor protection were significant, the win rate for Tiger II (H) tanks would always be high. Mobility, ammunition penetration, turret traverse speed, and having a small footprint are far more important.
I’ve explained this so many times—and what’s more, you don’t even play simulation mode, yet you still insist on talking about it.
I think the tiger 2 sla16 is far superior to the base version due to the mobility, even with the gears being bugged
honestly the conquer and m103 are so much worse than something like the is4m, even in a downtier they’re not really hard to kill, just shoot turret ring or lfp if it’s available, and YouTubers like that furry (degenerate) spookston brigaded that with non fourm users (ie people who play the game the most) aphe really should be made historical
You said the name who must not be named.
Heresy.
lol what. armor definitely matters bruh
I am awaiting your response.
Let me ask again: are the Panther F and G on the same tier and do they offer similar performance to vehicles such as the 1950s-era AMX series, the T-44-100, and the British 1948-model Centurion Mk 3 (which uses 381-penetration ammunition)?
Folks, there is a problem with German medium tanks in the game.
This is patently obvious.
The Panther II, Tiger 10.5 cm, and Coelian should be brought back.
This also applies to the Japanese anti-tank vehicle that was removed from the tech tree.
T-44-100 was also made a month before the end of WW2.
Hell even first prototype of T-54 was produced in start of 1945. Even second proto came before the end of WW2 iirc.
If anything German WW2 is pampered by lack of additions to other TT’s.
I’m not, lol. They did indeed enter service later, though its design was a direct post-war project and it was completed before the 1950s. TOA90, as present in game, was first tested in a fully-functional capacity in 1949.
Why would we? I’m staunchly opposed to basing vehicle balancing purely off of dates. You’re the first person to mention dates and I’m basing my refutation of your statements directly on that.
What “administration”?
I’m not your therapist bub. Seek help.
Holy lmfao
I won’t provide the production dates, as doing so would only reinforce the superiority of these vehicles.
So, in your view, the Panther G and F are on par with the AMX tanks—am I mistaken?
You already have… Your one and only argument is based on its entry to service, not its rooted design date and philosophy. The TOA90 is a conceptual continuance of the Panther’s design. Its attributes bank almost entirely on what the French learned from operating Panthers and studying late Tigers after the war. It facing Panthers at the VERY TIP of a full uptier isn’t at all astonishing.
Not quite. In my view the light AMX-50 lineage are a direct successor to the Panther’s design and, given their later conception, are better in a handful of ways but operate very similarly.
There’s a reason why the TOA90/930 is 8.0 while the Panther F is 6.0. It isn’t because they’re “on par”.
Yes, they are not equal. That is precisely what we are talking about.
It’s not just a high tier; it’s an extremely high tier. Pitting a Cold War-era vehicle against the Panther F and G models is simply unfair.
I am saying that you cannot have it both ways. Your options are, A, historical matchmaking, this will lead to Panther F vs T-54, or B, performance-based matchmaking that ignores historical date, this will lead to Panther F vs AMX M4. If you want an internally consistent system, tertium non datur.
This is the fifth time you have insulted my personal character instead of discussing the topic at hand (remember in your previous thread you called me a scheming liar and a vile human being etc etc). Do it again and I’ll start tagging mods so we figure out how they feel about it.
I assume you meant to say that Gaijin has placed them beyond the 6.0 - 7.0 bracket, and that is correct. This is why I do have a problem with the way sim vehicle lists currently are in the game, and I have stated as much. They are a half-measure that mixes historical considerations with balance considerations. Personally, I think this should be replaced with a BR system akin to the one used in Realistic.
However, the point is that you are against such a system, you made this abundantly clear when you claimed that the EBR should not be fighting Tigers and Panthers in the other thread.
If simulator had Battle Ratings, the Panther G would not be able to fight the Conqueror unless you upped its BR to the equivalent of 6.7 to play it with the Tiger II. But it would definitely fight the EBRs just like it does in realistic, a situation that you have deemed an intolerable injustice.
War Thunder follows the 80-20 rule. This is an empirically observed phenomenon in many aspects of nature and human society, it is not exclusive to any one War Thunder game mode. In most matches, 20% of players are responsible for 80% of the outcome, and 80% of players are responsible for 20% of the outcome. This is a completely expected statistical distribution and simulator is not immune from this.
I’ll even give you the Turkish language link so it’s easier for you to read.
Sounds unlikely, since you’re the one complaining that the Tiger IIs are unmatched while I think they are fantastic.
Date of introduction does not directly determine performance in this videogame.
It’s not. The production Tiger II and the Tiger II Sla are both meta vehicles.
Do I have to show you the screenshot again? I play Tiger IIs a ton. I am one of said German players.
My playerbase? Do you have the erroneous impression that I work for Gaijin?
You are factually incorrect, I’m afraid.
The real-world Panther II was proposed in 1943 as an up-armoured Panther hull to deal with Soviet anti-tank rifles. This upgrade was deemed unnecessary when the introduction of Schuertzen showed that it was possible to defeat Soviet anti-tank rifles without significantly increasing weight.
The “Panther II” we have in War Thunder is an amalgamation of five different unrelated projects that were never meant to coalesce in a single vehicle, those five being:
The historical Panther II, an up-armoured hull, cancelled long before any other project in this list was actively being considered.
The development of the Schmalturm/Schmale Blende turret designs, which were eventually built for the Panther F.
The installation of an 88mm L/71 gun. This was not going to fit either the Schmalturm or the Schmale Blende, a new turret would have been required. By the time this idea was being looked at, the Panther II chassis project had already been cancelled.
The installation of a new engine. This was not related to any of the specific projects above. The history of German engine development in the late war is quite complicated and really hard to recap in just a few lines, but suffice to say that the quest for a better engine was not specifically tied to the development of a brand-new medium tank.
The installation of night vision devices. This was carried out on Panther G and Jagdpanther units and had nothing to do with the development of a brand-new medium tank.
During interrogation by the Allies, von Heydekampf wrote down the production plans Germany had for the second half of 1945, and you can find the list below. Conspicuously no mention of any E-series tank or any Panther II.

For the record, I also think these vehicles should return purely because of player parity considerations, but it must be emphasised that the first two of those three are essentially inventions. They are an amalgamation, conducted by Gaijin, of different programmes that were never developed cohesively as one package (three projects in the case of the Tiger II 105, and five in the case of the Panther II, as I have just explained).
Completely correct.
And as previously mentioned, the T-54 was undergoing trials in January 1945, and would be ready for production by the same time that the Germans were planning to start mass-producing the Panther F. So if one was doing historical matchmaking, the Panther F should be facing the T-54.
The side that lost the war, of course, did not have the spare industrial capacity and resources to actually produce advanced tank designs in 1945. All their plans and upgrades were inferior to what the Allies were about to bring to the table. People who want historical MM conveniently forget this fact when they focus on their Wunderwaffen.
If we follow your logic, the Me 262 was being tested as early as 1942—which would mean P-51 Mk I fighters should be facing off against Me 262s.
I evaluate vehicle superiority by factoring in the year of production; after all, human progress is cumulative—we don’t move backward from rifles to bows and arrows, or from bows and arrows to throwing stones.
The comparison between the T-54 and the Panther F just doesn’t make sense.
Furthermore, the Americans actually brought over a Panther II hull.
To me, the solution is simple: all this chaos could be resolved by adding these vehicles to a “Cold War” tech tree.
In simulation battles, even the smallest differences translate into major advantages. I can’t seem to get this point across—or perhaps you simply don’t want to understand it.
We are not evaluating testing dates, brother. The important part of the sentence, which you missed, is this one, which I have emboldened for your attention:
The only reason the T-54 took years to go into full production is that the war ended. Despite the end of the war, the trials were still concluded in 1945, and considering they had started in January and significantly slowed down after May, in an environment of continued warfare with no slowdown happening you are looking at T-54 mass production beginning in late summer or early autumn of 1945.
When were the Germans going to mass produce the Panther F? Ah, yes.
Which is irrelevant for a videogame, but if you did factor it in, you would end up with the Panther F and the T-54 (both 1945 vehicles) at the same BR. Well done!
Yes, because it was built before the project was cancelled and it was a project that had nothing to do with the long 88, the Schmale Blende, or a new engine, or NVD.
Horrible idea. As mentioned several times in the past. Go play a SAV m/1946 against the aforementioned T-54 and tell me how well you perform. There is also no reason to dilute the players and therefore the queue, or split research and economy.
Because it’s a nonsensical point. Vehicle performance (mobility, targeting speed, reload speed etc) is the same in ground realistic as in ground simulator. Therefore the primary differentiating factors are not technical in nature, they are about situational awareness (which is reduced and poses a less arcadey challenge), map size (often but not always larger), different respawn mechanics, and crucially matchamking since team composition is determined by a closed vehicle list.
Like I already said this list should be reviewed imho. But none of this has anything to do with historical MM.
You are just yet another German main who thinks the grass is always greener on the other side. Trust me, this game has seen plenty like you and will see plenty more, there is a reason why things aren’t the way you want them to be.