It would be really cool and I feel like it could work fine as a high cost event vehicle. I would prefer it to be hard to get just so it isn’t overused.
Plus Japan hasn’t had a ground event vehicle since the Ka-Chi many years ago.
But as I said, Gaijin hard denied it quite a few times during DCT anticipation this year, so it is exclusive to WoT for the forseeable future
So, why aren’t you bothered by the AMX series tanks, the T-44-100s, those British tanks that use the infamous Shot Mk.3, or the Swedish models?
German players are constantly having to deal with these.
Perhaps you happen to be among the “lucky” group that uses these very tanks—that’s how I interpret it, at least.
It’s like a bad joke; some people are openly complaining about the Maus or the Panther II, and on top of that, they’re mocking those who come here to voice their concerns.
At this point, nothing you say carries any weight.
Reporting the profiles in game to Gaijin’s attention is also probably a good idea, since in the event of a TOS violation, it’s not just a TOS violation on the forum, but in game as well.
However, those just joining the discussion can read through to understand why these individuals oppose this tank.
They complain because people play the Maus all the time, and they don’t want a repeat of that situation with the Panther II.
Let’s reiterate: if a vehicle can be added to the game based on nothing more than a bare hull, some scrap in a shipyard, or a diesel engine that was never even installed,
then there is absolutely no reason why a vehicle—complete with its hull and a narrow turret designed to house an 88mm gun—shouldn’t be included.
As for those who call it “fictitious,” they should focus on what is truly fictitious—or perhaps be grateful to Gaijin for bringing “scrap” (like ships that existed only as wreckage) to life in the game.
Here is the most compatible turret, as required by the documentation.
Strawman. The [fake] Panther II you want back in is not remotely similar to the maus. The uparmored hull would ultimately do little aside from being a slower Panther with the same firepower as a tiger 2 - which ultimately makes it redundant.
Similarly, the Tiger II 10.5cm would offer zero advantage over the 8.8cm tigers. Sure, marginally more penetration while also being considerably slower to reload.
The actual Panther II would offer next to no difference to the Panther G except being slower for slightly more armor.
A tank is not a ship. A tank is maybe 3 to 5 meters long at absolute most.
A ship is upwards of 223 meters. There is a DISTINCT difference in required resources and building techniques you cannot seem to get through your head. The rules are different to reflect this but you keep ignoring it to try and use it as some weird ‘gotcha’, Irz.
No ship ever started their existence as wreckage. They all started as steel.
Every single ship was in varying stages of completion but you pull the fictitious card without doing a modicum of research because you can’t get your way. Unironically, one of these tanks literally never left the drawing board.
The other two were little more than hulls with one being removed never having been planned to begin with (the removed Panther II - a kitbash of five different projects).
Never added to the Panther II hull that exists. As such; does not meet GAIJIN’S criteria.
we got already a great breakdown (with timeline) about the different ideas for modifications of a panther tank.
all i could see would be a ‘panter II’ with the addon front armor but else the same turret, engin and transmission as the panther G, putting it at 5,7 with worse mobility.
We ‘could’ argue about a Panther G with the unified engine and transmission at 6,3 but thats already very douptable.