We are finally starting to get closer to seeing eye to eye. Me and multiple people were saying since that the real life Panther II plan had work done, it can be added. The one in game however is a fictional hybrid so if that tank were to return, it would need to be corrected to the irl project specifications. The 88 hadn’t made to partial production so it won’t be eligible under Gajin rules.
As you can see, it’s not what he actually wants. He wants a more competitive medium tank for the relevant sim bracket. He has no use for a fatter and slower Panther A. That’s why he’s specifically listed that he wants both versions of the “Panther II” in the game, the real one and the one made up by Gaijin.
As I understand it, the system works like this:
Someone issues an order, and vehicles are designed accordingly—but then, it’s decided that “this is too costly, let’s forget it.”
In some cases, the foundation is laid at the shipyard, but the project remains unfinished.
These vehicles are suitable for inclusion in Gaijin’s game.
In other instances, someone might ask, “What if we put this diesel engine into a Tiger II (H)?”—and so, they do it.
So, why does this process become a problem when it comes to the Panther series?
Especially considering that, for all of them, at least some components were produced or the designs were at least conceptualized?
Honestly, my opinion is that there is some manipulation going on—by individuals here, and even by some bloggers outside of this site.
Gaijin made a very reasonable interpretation and added the vehicle to the game. In fact, it would have been even better if they had designed the rear of the turret to be flat.
Actually, the current “Panther II” is essentially the E-50 project.
It is the E-50 project—the armor thicknesses are even similar, and it was also planned to be equipped with an 88mm gun turret.
How many times does it need to be stated that naval has its own rules for additions which differ from tanks/planes?
Sure, it is essentially the E-50 in the fact that it was never built.
Nobody can manipulate a brick wall with words.
So, it seems the rules can be bent whenever it suits them.
The rules for naval have been in place ever since naval was added. It has not changed.
Tiger 2H SLA?
Not a ship. Either stay on the topic or do not reply to my comment.
The topic is tanks, after all.
Why was the Tiger II (H) Sla added?
If you want to go down that route. The actual topic is ground sim at 6.7 which you “never” played.
It doesn’t. The vehicles you’re describing simply never had any component built for them, or in the case of the in-game Panther II, were never even ordered by anybody.
This is literally contradicted by the relevant meeting where it was decided to keep it sloped.
False. The E-50 never reached a stage of maturity sufficient enough to draw the comparison.
False. No information on the intendet turrets and armaments survives, that we know of.
Do i dare jinx it?
Hey congrats on joining the game new player. Before you try discussing the panther II, why dont you try reaching that tier?
He’s already back with next account…
The cycle continues…
At what point does the og account just get a permanent ban to remove any incentive of even doing this
Honestly, I expect these vehicles to return in the new patch.
I believe the Maus tank has made a comeback; I read about it in the news.
Why couldn’t the same apply to the vehicles in question?
By the way, I won’t be engaging with you. You won’t get what you’re looking for.
This is because the Maus is built and iirc the main reason for being event was it was hard to balance
Not to crush your hopes and dreams, but the O-I is more likely than the forbidden German trio, and it has been hard denied
Sadly, it’s unlikely the O-I will ever see the light of day in Warthunder.
