Ships have separate rules, as long as a ship was laid down it’s fair game. Planned conversions are also allowed for completed ships. From what I thought, Tiger II (Sla.16) counts as an unfinished prototype iirc as it has a unique part that wasn’t reused elsewhere.
Flakpanzer 341 had no unique parts made. It got to a full scale mock-up with a standard panther chassis and a mockup turret. Panther II in game is a hybrid of different plans that don’t match either the final German plans or the post war USA conversion. 10.5cm Tiger II from what I heard is also a amalgamation of projects.
Forgive me if I’m missing something but I’m not sure why these tanks are being brought up? Ones a MBT from the 1980s, another only went to blueprints during the cold war and the last tank is Czechoslovakian.
It’s gajins rules that realistically will only allow the Panther II to return in a different configuration. If the mock-up was treated as a partial prototype, the 341 could’ve also returned.
The argument is that the two projects wouldn’t be combined because one of them was canceled, well before the other one even made it to the mock-up stage. It doesn’t make much sense to allocated resources into a dead-end, one-off prototype that doesn’t have any established production for spare parts. They would prioritize the vehicle with established production that can quickly accept the new turret and gun to make an actual impact.
You’re asking us to entertain a made-up kit bash of real projects just because it’s hypothetically, technically, theoretically possible, rather than something they expressly wanted to do. It’s basically World of Tanks logic.
I’d be down for a Panther II with the intended turret, and I could even get behind a faithfully recreated Panther F with the new turret and 88 mm L/71, but the latter simply wasn’t conceived for the former.
Don’t bother with this guy. We have explained it multiple times clearly and he just willfully ignores anything people say and repeats the same talking points. He should get banned because this is an alt account after the original was banned
From what I have gathered, it was an idea that was thrown around at some point, and a turret layout may have been written, but it never got any construction going, not even full scale mockups or prototypes
Daimler Benz’s proposed turret got as far as a wood mock-up supposedly. There were several iterations of the concept in play, and idk if we have plans of the finalized one.
How do these fantasies differ from the Gneisenau, the H39, the Sevastopol, or the Stalingrad?
Honestly, I would also like to see the Panther II and Panther 88 series added.
In a game that already features models like the Gneisenau, the Tiger II Sla 16, and even vehicles like the E-100, these machines should be included as well.
Sir, if you have any further arguments, you should share them.
As you mentioned, a wooden version of this model was actually produced; the engineers even drew up plans to build it using a softer grade of steel. Or rather, they are going to do it.
This vehicle appears more realistic than other, more contrived designs, precisely because actual physical research and development went into it.
I don’t see much point in discussing it further. This vehicle should be brought back.
Some people here—who must be game developers themselves, I suppose—insist that it will never be added.
Technically it is not the Schmalturm, but it is also not the traditional Panther turret. It was the Schmale Blendausführung. There is a suggestion on the forums for the historical Panther II that has more information on this turret design (and of course Panzer Tracts is the most relevant source here).
The development of the Schmalturm started when the Panther II had already been cancelled.
They were never credible to begin with. For a long time now the source in question has only correctly guessed pre-orders and nothing else. I didn’t believe that guess when I first saw it, and since other guesses in that list have already turned out to be incorrect, I believe it even less now.
First of all, don’t give too much credit to Gurme. He’s an alt account that was created two days ago, played enough arcade battles to qualify for forum posting, and immediately yoinked themselves to the forum to start debating simulator and maybe more cogently, to agree with everything said by another (now conspicuously silent) forum user, that being IrzDusmani.
I will answer you on this point however. Simplifying the rather complex development history of the engine in question, in its final iteration it was meant for the Jagdtiger. This is also the only vehicle that ever had the engine installed and trialled.
Installation in a Tiger II was suggested by the engineers as it would make the project more appealing. Doing so would require a modification to the engine deck of the Tiger II, and there is currently no record that this took place.
Therefore, the Tiger II Sla is technically seen, in the same situation as the Flakpanzer 341.
Base platform exists and was mass produced. Unique part (Geraet 341, or Sla engine) was built in metal for another purpose (Kriegsmarine AA battery, and the Jagdtiger). Installation was suggested, but the required marrying component (new turret, new engine deck) was never built. So neither had unique parts made.
That is correct. The in-game Panther II is a kitbash of five separate projects. The Tiger II 105 of “only” three.
No, Irz.
Just to name one example: as we all know, the Panther had chronic issues with the reliability of a particular component, its final drive. The Germans repeatedly tried to fix this issue, but never found a solution before the war ended.
The Panther II hull is heavier than the Panther F hull.
A turret mounting the long 88 would be heavier than the turret mounting the long 75mm.
Increasing the weight of the overall vehicle by a further 2-3 tons would add extra stress to the final drive that would increase the demand for spare parts which by March 1945 barely any factory in Germany could even mass-manufacture anymore.
There is a good reason why the Panther II stayed cancelled and was never brought back out of mothballing.
Or, as Fourche eloquently told you,
I don’t think his original account was banned. If it really is Irz, and since they talk the same it seems overwhelmingly likely, I have no idea why he felt the need to violate TOS just to parrot all his talking points on a second account.
Tank Encyclopedia has two great articles on this, one on the whole concept of a KWK43-armed Panther, and one about the specific development of a turret to house such a gun.
The story of weapons procurement in the Third Reich is never straightforward. Krupp and DB were in competition and occasionally in collaboration on developing a turret that could do the job. At repeated stages, both fell out of favour or came back into favour depending on who rose or fell within the Waffenamt and what their personal preferences were for either company or either design.
It was all empty air in the end, because the disastrous situation meant that work was glacially slow. Nothing was ever built past wood that we know of. Speer (remember, minister of armaments) requested a mild steel showroom vehicle to at least show to Hitler for his birthday, the request was made on 23rd March and was never carried out. The war was over six weeks later.
We are talking about different things.
WT is not a game about realistic combat or realistic historical fighting, it can’t be from its very set up. Just consider the following idea: even if we were to introduce full historical MM, you would still be spawning your Tiger on Sun City or Arctic Pier (??). You would have Japan and Italy on your team, so the implication is that Japan apparently has enough spare capacity in 1944 to send tanks to the Arabian Peninsula or the Arctic Circle. You go into battle against Britain, the USA and the Soviets simultaneously on the same front (??). There is zero infantry and zero real artillery. You have third person view, a barrel camera, zero reliability concerns, and you keep fighting even after your fighting compartment is penetrated and the machine gunner is plastered all over the poor driver (who just wipes off the gore and keeps driving).
Come on.
The vehicles are realistic in terms of fidelity and technical specifications, to a point. And therefore it matters that they are real or not.
Built, laid down, laid down, laid down. The Panther 88 never had a component made for it.
Wow, they’re a series now? Multiple vehicles? Amazing!
I am starting to get the feeling that you don’t understand what a mild steel prototype is.
And yet you keep doing it.
No, Irz. I’m just a better player than you, so I see no reason to complain that Germany suffers.
Also, what was that about that Tank Encyclopedia article you were so happy to send me?
Bro, you are an account created 48 hours ago. Maybe consider whether that’s strange or not, lmao.
Auren, I have already provided explanations based on logic in the section I quoted.
Feel free to offer further explanations if you wish.
The Panther II is far more realistic than many other unfinished ship projects; you even listed its step-by-step development yourself.
Just as the French were able to mount an AMX turret onto a Sherman tank, the Germans—constrained by their already scarce resources—would have fitted available components onto the Panther II hull. We have already provided numerous examples of this.
By the way, I’ve learned something else—which seems relevant to our discussion: the BR-412D ammunition for the T-44-100 didn’t enter service until 1951.
I think the reason for all this conflict has become clear.
It seems there is a serious issue regarding fairness within the game.
You can consider it early installment weirdness, I think. But the important thing to remember is that at the end of the day this is a company selling a product and they can do whatever they want.
The specific rules for additions etc are stuff for us players with autism/hyperfixation. They do have some of that special interest obviously, but they’re also balancing different priorities. USP, commercial, balance, etc etc.
You have not.
Your “logic” is that, when selecting a platform to mount a modified turret with a new gun, Germany would skip over the medium tank they were actually mass producing and put it instead on a single prototype from a cancelled project that had been considered unnecessary two years before.
The real world doesn’t work like Hearts Of Iron, Irz. A factory that’s mass producing the regular Panther would need conversion before mass producing an entirely new hull, and the Panther II was a hull Germany no longer wanted, because the later Panther modifications were lighter and achieved virtually the same level of protection against AT rifles.
Reliability concerns also meant that, if you had to install a turret with a heavier gun, it was obviously preferable to put it on the lighter chassis, not the heavier one.
You should start doing some explaining of your own.
For example, why you sent that article which proved you wrong. Why you are discussing removed vehicles and sim battles on an account that’s 48 hours old. Why you felt the need to violate TOS by creating a second account.
If you mean the real Panther II, with the 75mm gun and the same engine and transmission as a regular Panther, sure, I actually agree: the hull was built and there would be nothing special about it, as it would just be a heavier, slower and worse Panther than the A, G and F.
If you mean the in game Panther II then you are making stuff up as usual. The Schmalturm was never meant for the Panther II, the long 88 was never going to fit in an unmodified Schmalturm, and the modified Schmalturm with the long 88 was only meant for the Panther F, not the II.
How many times must I repeat this?
It is not relevant in the slightest. Ammunition access is a balancing factor in the game.
I think you’re the one with serious issues (mostly located in the skill). The Maus has access to an APHEDS round whose actual performance characteristics are dubious at best. Every nation has vehicles in the game that are balanced using every tool at Gaijin’s disposal. Since you have real life constraints your choices are battle rating, rate of fire, and access to earlier or later ammo.
TBH imo, the way they should add these back is though the yearly 4 vehicle xmas events as like the high value reward for the events, as then at least new players can also get to enjoy these vehicles, and its not like they have been giving these vehicles BUFF’s this year so it would be nice for it honistly…
Irz/Gurme has been using that logic in every thread he’s created. You should check those threads out, they’re quite entertaining.
“Even the janitor would think of putting the new turret on the Panther II hull” is poetry for how much absurdity it condenses into so few words.
See, if you live in this embattled mental universe, everyone thinks like you bar the other players (who are secret developers) and therefore obviously even the janitor would think to take out the overweight, cancelled medium tank hull out of storage, in order to mount a turret that did not even exist because no one had built it, even though we have a clear paper record showing that DB, Krupp, the Waffenamt, Speer and Hitler himself wanted to do no such thing and intended the regular Panther F to get the new turret instead.
It is mind bogglingly beautiful. A fractal of contrivance and wishful thinking. It takes far longer to explain why it is dumb than it does to just utter it with supreme self confidence.
If that wasn’t enough, remember that all of this started because IrzDusmani struggles to use King Tigers in simulator because “the Allies get better equipment” and wants a fictional medium tank to redress the “terrible injustice done to German players”.
I’m happy I haven’t played sim in a while. I can imagine no better gift than the gift of never having this guy on my team lol
Just look at the medium tanks currently in the open simulation battle—and then look at the opposing German medium tank and its specifications.
This is just too much.
You are distorting the facts right in front of everyone.
Those who don’t believe me can go and check for themselves.
The Maus tank?
I tried taking it for a test drive; I could run faster than it moves.
You mentioned its ammunition.
Well, that’s exactly what I’m talking about.
There’s no difference at all.
The Panther II is far more realistic—and far more feasible—than those made-up ships of yours. There were 100 armored hulls just sitting there; I’m 100% certain the tank developers would have thought, “Hey, these are just lying around—let’s slap this turret onto one of them.” And you know it, too. The conditions of the era certainly allowed for it.
You’re distorting the facts right in front of everyone. We aren’t talking about the E-75 or other projects that remained purely on paper; we’re talking about components—actual modules—that were physically manufactured.
The mere existence of these parts is justification enough to include the vehicle—just as you’ve included those other fictional, made-up ships like the Gneisenau 388.