When was this the case? Production time is never used for balancing.
If we consider the effort invested in development, the tank and the ship are currently in the same category.
The ship’s keel has been laid down at the shipyard.
The hull for the Panther II has been produced.
The ship’s armament has been manufactured.
The Schmalturm turret for the tank has been produced and has begun undergoing testing (a sample of this turret still exists, albeit in a damaged state—you can look this up).
Work was carried out on a turret suitable for the tank’s 88mm gun; according to claims by Daimler employees, production of the final, definitive turret was set to begin shortly. It is highly likely that another firm would have also contributed or collaborated on the project.
Note that a Panther G turret can, in fact, be mounted on a Panther II hull.
The directive from a German minister—stating that he wished to see an 88mm-armed Panther tank by his birthday—serves as the strongest evidence for the direction this project was taking.
The Germans would certainly have mounted the new, 88mm-compatible turret onto the Panther II hull.
If you possess even a modicum of logic, the idea of combining a Panther II hull with a new 88mm turret is something that would occur to anyone—even a janitor working at the tank design bureau.
Given the shortages of raw materials and the various production challenges, such a combination would hardly be a surprise.
Much like how the French adapted a turret—originally designed for their AMX models—to fit onto a Sherman tank.
These vehicles will return. Just as the Gnesenau or the diesel-powered Tiger II were added to the game—under the justification that “such a project actually existed”—
the Panther II, the Tiger II (10.5 cm), and the Coelian will also be added. It is necessary, given the requirements of the game. These vehicles ought to be brought back.
Unlike the E-25, E-50, E-75, or E-100, which remained merely on paper, these vehicles had physical development work done on them—much like the ships currently in the game, and in fact, even further along in their development.
I hope the developers will consider these ideas.
Thank you.
For the Panther II, which was to be armed with a 75
For a different Panther after the Panther II was canceled (completely unrelated)
No construction was started, it was obviously never finished, and therefore, the vehicle which it was to be mounted was never chosen (probably not the Panther II, as it was canceled)
Nevertheless, it never started, so no 88 armed Panther will ever come
Why would they first mount a new turret on a tank hull that was canceled already?
Purely speculation and what-ifs
By this logic, I could ask for the Surbussy turret on a Lorraine 40 chassis because it is technically possible. Why wouldn’t the French mount their new 120mm super turret on the fastest medium chassis? Surely there wouldn’t be other complications, right?
Blockquote
If we consider the effort invested in development, the tank and the ship are currently in the same category.
This is where you are wrong, the cost of building a ship is magnitudes higher than building a single tank.
Hello, Irz. Please invest some effort into telling me about that matter with the Tank Encyclopedia article.
Which is why both qualify for addition under the game’s rules. However, the Panther II that qualifies for addition would have the 75mm gun and its original engine and turret.
No, genius, the Schmalturm was not the Panther II’s turret. You are confusing it with the Schmale Blendausfuehrung.
No. Work was carried out to equip the Panther F with a Schmalturm that could house an 88mm gun. The Panther II had long been cancelled by then and was not being brought back. There is no version of the (again, different) Panther II turret that could house the KWK43.
No, production of the mild steel version would “begin shortly” (a highly dubious claim given Germany’s situation in March 1945).
That is irrelevant to the development of an 88mm Schmalturm.
The minister in question was Speer and the birthday in question was not his, but Hitler’s. And they didn’t want an actual, combat ready Panther, but a mild steel version meant to be showcased to Hitler for review.
Yes, it’s the strongest evidence that Germany planned to produce just one medium tank in 1945, the Panther F, which is not the Panther II. The Germans expected to have Panther Fs armed with the 88mm KWK43 by Q4 of 1945.
And yet, nobody in Germany at the time was thinking about it, because the Panther II as a project was dead, since the extra weight added by the additional armour was considered not worth it given the modest protection increase it gave the tank. You are literally making this up. You cannot find one scrap of document to support that anybody proposed mounting the KWK43 in the Panther II instead of the Panther F, because it doesn’t exist.
What is this even supposed to mean? Given the shortages of raw materials which made producing the regular Panther almost impossible by March 1945, the logical move would be to… produce a heavier, unreliable Panther that had been cancelled two years before???
I hope you’ll tell me all about that Tank Encyclopedia article you were so happy to send me! :)
While we’re at it, “Gurme”, I have a few more questions for you. Since you have technically only started playing the game yesterday and have only played arcade,
Why do you have strong opinions on simulator battles, including with the Leo2A6, and on vehicles which were removed years ago? I’m very curious. You should urgently tell us and maybe even tag a mod in your reply!
Yeah, but Moderator Hide my Screenshot to expose him :(
I feel Gurme31 is mostly the Second account of IrzDüşmanı.
You can message a moderator directly
He isn’t even denying it. In any case that feels like a game mod problem, not a forum mod problem, which is why I’ve reported both profiles in game.
Already reported the name, than now the second account
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
Lion alone had 218 tons of steel used, H39 had it’s guns made and later reused while these vehicles either only reached mockup or are fictional combinations of projects.
H39 has already been said to have been laid down and guns made, here’s Stalingrad and Sevastopol respectively partially made


The engine was made and wasn’t reused anywhere else, hence it fits as an unfinished prototype.
Why bring up a Czechoslovakian tank, it was made by Czechoslovakia.
Do you have anything that isn’t a unsupported assumption that Germany was planning to build the Panther II in the in game specifications?
Are you reading what I’ve written?
Please, do not cherry-pick specific parts of my posts to use as evidence against me.
Focus on the text as a whole.
Due to a shortage of resources, the Jumo 213 engine—originally intended for bombers—was adapted for the Fw 190 D-9.
It’s truly fascinating; you speak as if everything remained merely on paper.
Didn’t these people work on the Panther II hull and the Schmalturm turret—even going so far as to build a wooden mock-up with plans to later construct it out of mild steel? Were these engineers just doing this as a hobby?
The development status of these vehicles is comparable to that of ships under construction. In fact, given its relatively low cost, the Panther II would almost certainly have been brought to fruition. Most likely, the Daimler-designed turret would have been completed with the support of other firms and mounted onto the existing hulls. Just as there were variants like the Fw 190 D-13, there would have been a variant for the Panther II—fitted onto the hulls already in existence. This was inevitable. A German minister even issued an order demanding 88 Panthers by April 1945.
What more could you possibly want?
Vehicles that were merely in the “this is how it should be” planning stage—even those already laid out on the assembly line—are included in the game, yet the Panther II somehow becomes a problem.
Take the Gneisenau, for instance; it was included in the game based on a “project” that involved adding 388mm guns.
And let’s add one more point: these Panther projects are not distinct, unrelated endeavors—don’t try to imply that they are. Ultimately, they are all Panthers; they all involve improvements built upon the same basic hull.
Moreover, the focus is on the standardization of production.
The E50 and E75 are the clearest evidence of this—even if they are merely projects.
this vehicle is not something like the E-series (25, 50, 75, 100) as it appears on paper.
There is no obstacle to the return of these vehicles.
Let this be our final comment.
Wrong person here. This is a forum related matter, outside of GM scope and authority.
Just a reminder for all: keep it civil, don’t attack personally and of course don’t be toxic.
Shouldn’t actually be necessary to be said, but people tend to forget - on all sides usually.
An officially approved plan for a ship that was eventually built is not the same as they could’ve thought about combining multiple plans when there’s no evidence they did.
Several people here keep saying the Panther II is eligible according to the rules. The issue is the fact the in game Panther II is a hybrid of different projects.
I know a way to end this. Ask a forum moderator like smin about the return of the Panther II and see what answer is given
played statue626.You are clearly not reading what I have written.
Perhaps our brains simply work differently.
Or perhaps you are deliberately distorting the subject.
There is no “Leopard 2A4” project or “Indian Panzer” project—do you not understand this? These are all just the Panther and its derivatives; they are identical in every respect.
Judging by what has been written, it seems the “medium tank” gets three chances at inception, and the “heavy tank” gets two. It stands to reason that people would prefer a “heavy Panther II”—a tank that is heavier and better armored, yet faster than the Tiger II—over the Tiger II Ausf. H (which, in this scenario, is granted two chances at inception).
Those participating in the other discussion can refer to my previous post, which I have quoted here.
Not in my last message. I also wasn’t the one introducing them into the conversation.
I wouldn’t call them different if the Panthers had different hulls, armour, speed etc.
Again the issue is there isn’t any evidence proving the Panther II in game aligns with the real project the Germans attempted nor the American version post war.
You’re quite an interesting person.
So, this is what it boils down to:
If ships like the H39, Sevastopol, Stalingrad, and Gneisenau—for which orders were issued or the laying of the keel had begun, and for which certain components were manufactured before the projects were left incomplete—are considered eligible…
…then, given that the Panther II and Panther 88 were also worked on and had certain components manufactured, there should be no issue with adding these two vehicles to the game either.
That brings the total number of vehicles to be added to five:
Panther II, Panther II (75mm), Panther 88, Tiger II (10.5cm), and Coelian.
Okay then. Let us say you are not an alt.
Welcome to War Thunder, new player!
This is the date your account was created, and your service record:
As a new player who has just started the game and never tried sim, it makes no sense for you to worry about the Panther II. Instead, go and enjoy all the game has to offer! Oh, and maybe stop saying in other threads that you recently played the Leopard 2A6 in sim. Someone might draw weird conclusions from that statement. :)
Correct.
Specifically requesting that it be the Panther F.
It’s not “one team”, but yes, the Panther F is the only medium tank slated for mass production in 1945 as per German plans.
False. The Panther II had been proposed and cancelled in 1943. No work was being carried out on a Panther with more armour in 1945.
One Panther II hull was manufactured in 1943, and no more work was carried out after the project was cancelled.
The Schmalturm was being manufactured but it could not fit the KWK 43.
No component of a modified, KWK 43-capable Schmalturm was ever manufactured.
Not inevitable. Daimler Benz, Krupp, MAN, the Waffenamt, Speer, and Hitler all wanted the 88mm for the Panther F. No one argued to resurrect the old Panther II project.
On the basis that the Panther II was cancelled in May 1943, while the first proposal to modify a Schmalturm to house the long 88 is from 18th October 1944.
I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but time has a linear progression, and events have causal relationships. May 1943 comes before October 1944. Hope this helps!
The Germans intended to build those ships. The Germans never intended to combine the cancelled Panther II with an unmodified Schmalturm that could magically house the long 88, a new engine, a new transmission, and NVD.
Ohh, sounds ominous.
I don’t want to see your comments deleted, I really don’t care.
I have reported IrzDusmani and Gurme31 in-game as potential alt accounts belonging to the same person, as that is a TOS violation. A report just means that maybe someone at Gaijin will look into it. If you two are different players, nothing will happen and you don’t need to worry. If Gaijin determines you are in fact Irz and have violated the game’s TOS, then they will take whatever action they deem necessary, which no simple user like me can predict or directly comment on. In either case, reporting you was clearly the correct course of action, as reporting merely brings a matter to the attention of the company. What they determine and decide after that, is up to them.
They were following a direct order to mount a modified Schmalturm onto a Panther F hull. No order was given concerning the single Panther II hull. Nobody cared about it.
There was only ever one hull, and since it was from a cancelled project, mounting a turret on it would be literally wasting a turret. Instead, the turrets would go to the tank the Germans were actually producing. The regular Panther.
No… he demanded a mockup of a single Panther F armed with an 88mm gun. Not “88 Panthers”.
Because the Panther II as it appears in game was never planned by any engineer.
You literally cannot stop yourself from throwing insults at other players. Funnily, “just like Irz.”
The… Leopard 2A4… is a Panther derivative?
I’m gonna go lie down for a bit.
The original Panther II can definitely be added, since the hull was manufactured. Sadly for you, it will have the long 75mm and the original Panther engine and transmission.
The Panther F with KWK 43 cannot be added, as no component for it was ever built.
Nope. The Panther II was cancelled over a year before consideration was given to upgunning Panthers.
