An unfair Ground Simulator Battle featuring vehicles such as the Tiger II (H), Panther F, Panther G, Jagdpanther, and Ferdinand

No, they did not “manage” it in the sense that said turret was never built. Both DB and Krupp kept suggesting designs, sometimes collaboratively and sometimes competitively, a familiar story to anyone who knows about the politics of weapons procurement during the Third Reich. But neither ever managed to deliver even a soft-steel prototype.

Yep. That one qualifies for addition. However, as you can see from my list above, it would have the standard 75mm L/70, the standard engine and transmission. It would be a Panther with worse mobility and slightly better armour, but identical firepower, compared to the A and G already present in the game.

As you can see from my list, it occurred to several people. There is the minor hurdle, however, that they had no such turret to mount, because they never built it in time.

This is referring to the Panther II hull and is basically the manufacturer saying they can’t rule it out. Even if it did happen, it would have been with the original Panther engine, transmission, and gun.

That is correct. Installation of the Sla engine into a Tiger II was proposed by the people developing the Sla engine, however. The crucial difference, which you keep missing, is that the people who were designing the modified Schmalturm to house the long 88, never proposed to resurrect the Panther II project in order to install it.

That’s what makes the Panther II in-game a kitbash.

This is not inevitable at all. Many ideas were pursued and later dropped, the Panther II being one of them.

Do you not realise the irony of quoting logistics, supply, production, and maintenance, when we’re talking about a medium tank that was supposed to be in the 30-ton class, and ended up weighing 45 tons while in service, which caused endless reliability problems? Just adopting the Panther II hull would have pushed the weight to at least 47 tons, and installing the KWK43 would increase that weight even further.

The Germans cancelled the Panther II project for very sensible reasons.

They also stopped pursuing the idea to mount a 105mm into a Tiger II because the lower rate of fire was not worth the trade off.

There is nothing “inevitable” about different developments coalescing.

Cool, so the in-game Panther II can’t be added because the hull was never planned to have the long 88; and the Panther F with 88mm can’t be added either because it was never “laid down” (i.e. its new turret was never even partially built in soft steel). How does that help your cause?

So, what’s your take on the ships?

You know, the ones where even the lower deck hasn’t been modeled yet.

I suppose it’s not an issue for you when ships are added to the game before they’re even finished.

The same goes for the Tiger, too.

Yet, when it comes to the Panther, it seems like every technical term suddenly springs to mind for you.

*Furthermore, these guys also had a “standardized Panzer” project—namely the E-25, E-50, E-75, and E-100.

The common goal across all of them was to simplify production and focus on a single vehicle platform, thereby achieving cost savings in areas like manufacturing and other related aspects.

It shouldn’t - Germany doesn’t need another panther.

Nor does it need the tiger 2 105.

There definitely is.

You write like Irz (in the literal sense of writing style) and seem to share literally all of his talking points. I do dearly hope you are not an alt account :)

You say you have read through the thread. If you really have, you know the answer has already been given. Building a ship is a much more labour intensive effort than building a tank or a plane, and you don’t build prototypes either. Once you commit to laying down a ship, you are allocating a monumental amount of raw materials and labour to the project.

In any case, since you “share” Irz’s tendency for ignoring points that were already explained to you, I have to unfortunately reiterate that if you follow naval rules, you still can’t add a Panther F with the long 88, since it never went through the ground equivalent of being “laid down”. Not only was no final component manufactured, but even the soft steel version was never built.

Must I repeat this again and again?

Ground vehicles also get added that were never finished, but usually what they have in common is that there is a physical component unique to them that was manufactured.

For example. the Panther F we have in the game was an unfinished vehicle, since we have the turret (the Schmalturm) but it’s mounted on the G chassis, as it was in testing. Why is this okay? Because the Schmalturm was fully built.

Unlike the Schmalturm, the long 88 version of the Schmalturm was never built.

Unlike both, the Panther II was never even meant to have a long 88 or a new engine.

Ergo, the Panther F stays, but the in-game Panther II is fiction.

As I have already explained, the Tiger II Sla is in the exact same situation as the Coelian, and it is my opinion that both vehicles should be in the game. However, it is not in the same situation as the Panther II or the Tiger II 105, which are kitbashes.

Lol, and perhaps even lmao. Who do you think you’re kidding, brother?

Do you have any more history channel pop material you want to throw at us?

Sad thing about goals: you don’t reap the rewards if you don’t actually achieve them.

So, just to bring this to everyone’s attention…

Gurme31, who is here discussing about the three removed German vehicles and the medium tank gap in Germany’s roster for Simulator Battles lobby 6_1, is a player with the following total game experience:

https://statshark.net/player/245290958#Vehicles

4 battles in Arcade, with the Pz III E, and nothing else.

Now, you might think its entirely coincidental that Gurme is talking like Irz, repeating his same talking points and repeated questions, agreeing with everything he says, commenting while Irz is silent, and caring so deeply about 6_1 simulator when he’s just started playing arcade.

But let me point out that this user was created today:

https://warthunder.com/en/community/userinfo/?nick=Gurme31

Now, if I remember correctly, having more than one account is against the TOS of the game.

Just saying…

EDIT: in another thread, bro’s openly discussing being a sim player:

Cannot make this up.

2 Likes

This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.

Maybe the Account is banned already 🤣

218 tons of steel were laid down for the Lion. Sorry Irz, you lose this one too.

Show us photographic evidence of this supposed Panther II turret being manufactured, Irz. Where is it? Because it’s not the Schmalturm, the Panther II project had a different turret design and it was meant to house the 75mm L/70, so come on Irz, where is the turret?

What about that tank encyclopedia article, Irz, the one you posted which claimed the turret was a fantasy? Remember that, Irz?

1 Like

Could you show me the ship’s engine, its deck, and its turrets?

This discussion isn’t going anywhere.

You accept everything—treating even the smallest, isolated components of these ships as if they were fully integrated and complete—and yet, these ships are currently playable in the game.

The Americans are supposedly capable enough to mount a “G” turret onto a Panther II chassis.

We can only hope that the Germans would have been just as capable of mounting a Schmalturm turret onto a Panther II.

They could even have mounted a turret designed by Daimler.

The way you describe it, one would think that mounting a Panther turret onto a Sherman tank was an absolute necessity.

Look, the French managed to mount their own unique turrets onto Sherman tanks.

Why are you making such a big deal out of this?

You see no problem with British, Russian, or German ships being added to the game in a fully functional state, even when only their basic frameworks were ever completed.

Yet, mounting a turret onto a Panther—or the more heavily armored Panther II—chassis is suddenly a massive problem. Or rather, there simply “wasn’t enough time” for it, right?

Moreover, these turrets exist at least as physical scale models; they aren’t just “paper” designs.

To be honest, there wasn’t enough time to complete the production of either the two ships or the tank; yet, the ship can be included in the game, while the Panther II model cannot.

You yourselves state that instructions were given to have the vehicle ready by a specific birthday.

Similarly, instructions were given to complete the ship by a certain year—and in both cases, neither the ship nor the tank could be finished.

Nevertheless, the ship can be added to the game, but the tank cannot.

This is unfair.

Cry more, doesn’t change anything about reality…

1 Like

Statshark says that he is.

Bro is more stubborn than a cockroach

1 Like

Do you know the definition of the English word “laid down”?

I am not claiming the Lion’s turrets were built. You are claiming the Panther II’s turret was built. Well then, support your claim, where is it?

218 tons.

They had no reason to do it. The Panther II was cancelled before the Schmalturm was ready.

No, because such a turret was never built.

Okay, Irz.

I’m not the one who violated TOS and created an alt account, Irz (and I hope you didn’t do it just to circumvent a moderator’s actions.)

It actually is a massive problem if the turret is nonexistent, genius.

Show me a WW2 era scale model of the Panther II turret.

The problem with the H.39 or the Lion was never time.

And this was not achieved. They couldn’t even build a soft steel turret in time.

Similarly my ass. The H.39 was actively cancelled after starting construction, the 8.8cm version of the Schmalturm was never constructed at all, the turret designed specifically for the Panther II was also never built, and on top of all that the Panther II was never meant to mount either the Schmalturm or the long 88! No German engineer or leader ever made a decision around it, it’s pure fiction!

Correct.

Get good at the game.

Also, while we’re at it.

What about that Tank Encyclopedia article, Irz? Anything you want to share with the class? :) :) :)

Shocking.

1 Like

The Ordinance 16 inch BL Mk I gun was the basis of HMS Lion’s guns, although Lion would have used a newer variant - the Mk II.

Four guns were seemingly produced but the turrets to house these guns seemed to have never been constructed.

There’s a keen difference between an inaccurate, fictional kitbash (Panther II with the 8.8cm KwK) and an incomplete ship with hundreds of pages of documentation, schematics and steel in the yard.

1 Like

Irz will simply refuse to acknowledge this being a thing. He’ll say something about how it was inevitable that eventually blah blah blah. He’ll ask you why you believe such lies and that a single bolt in Liverpool blah blah blah.

The guy’s so far gone he literally posted an article that contradicted his own point and was all smug about it, oh oh, read here, see what it says.

The “suffering endured by German players” is that we have to share a TT with the likes of him. I shudder to think what it must be like, having him take up a spot on your team.

1 Like

The suffering we’re having to endure is constantly proving these ‘wunderwaffe’ were fictional, either by mistake (Gaijin’s case) or maliciousness and/or willful ignorance (Irz’s case).

1 Like

How many prototype capital ships were ever build? I will help you, its 0.
Even the only cruiser that I would call prototype was fully put into service.
But this creates a problem, There are already less warships, even counting every singel one in a class as different, to be added into the game. In the case of some nations, like russia/ussr, they would not have ships above a pretty low br. You also cant add lend lease vehicles, becouse there was non.
The soulution, you need to loosen the restrictions on what ship can be added into the game. For tank, you dont, there is enough to be added.
Also, the extent to which the tanks you mentioned were complete was less than the ships you complained about.

You’re talking to someone who talks about himself in third person to pretend that someone agrees with him:

So we’re just wasting our breath.

HMS Royal Sovereign, aka Arkangelsk.

Gaijin often rates vehicles not only by production time but also (and a bit more) by the weaponry and strength