I am pretty close to just dropping the effort to be kind and just switch to being honest.
This stubborn hero will not accept that Panther II and Panther 88mm projects are two different tank designs…
He just doesnt have the IQ to do it.
Sorry, I must reiterate. We are not discussing ships until you address the Tank Encyclopedia article.
The conversion to allow a Tiger II to house the Sla engine is far less problematic than the fact that neither Daimler-Benz nor Krupp ever produced Panther turrets that could house the KWK43.
I am also still waiting for an acknowledgement from you about that Tank Encyclopedia article.
It is not my site.
Really, the site says that? The site says, had the new turret for the 88mm gun been completed, it would not have gone to the Panther F it was contracted for, instead the Panther II hull project would be un-cancelled in order to fit the new turret on it, and on top of that, NVD equipment and a new engine would be provided?
Can you please, oh so kindly, point out where exactly the Tank Encyclopedia article makes this rather remarkable claim?
Just play the Tiger II and get good, for god’s sake.
Also, what was that about Tank Encyclopedia?

Or what his username means in Turkish.
I have read through the entire discussion.
Although there are some gaps—particularly toward the end—it appears that both of the vehicles mentioned were intended for production, but the plans were ultimately abandoned due to the circumstances of that era.
As I understand it, there is an issue concerning medium tanks.
Given that vehicles that were never completed or put into production are already present in the game, it stands to reason that the three vehicles frequently mentioned by Irz—the Panther II, the Tiger 10.5 cm, and the Coelian—could also be added (or re-added) to the game.
After all, the Tiger II SLA and certain warships remain in the game, despite never having been fully completed—some never even reaching the prototype stage.
It seems that adding the Coelian, the Panther II, and the Tiger 10.5 cm would resolve this issue.
The Panther II we have in game was never intended for production, because no German engineer ever designed that vehicle, it’s a kitbash. If that is your takeaway, then you did not read very closely at all.
I would rather not repeat myself in full again, you can easily find details if you scroll up, but the long and short of it is that the in game Panther II is a kitbash of five separate projects, one of which was not Panther specific, and another (the hull that gives the vehicle its name in the game) had already been cancelled by the Germans.
So even with greatly relaxed rules (naval rules wouldn’t work as no component of the new turret was made) the best you could hope for is a Panther F with the KWK43, the existing hull and engine, and a turret with a bigger turret ring diametre. That’s it.
As for the Tiger II with a 105mm gun, that is not a project that ran out of time. The Germans considered the idea and then decided it was not worth pursuing.
If one sticks to medium tanks, the only thing that can be realistically added to Germany in this range is either a Swiss medium tank (like a Centurion) or the Argentinian Sherman Repotençiado.
The Coelian is the only one of these three that was a real project that never reached completion. The other two are kitbashes of different ideas, some of which weren’t even under simultaneous consideration.
Mod came in and swept the thread.
From what I gather on that particular site, the Panther 88 and the Panther II appear to have been separate projects.
It is said that Daimler’s engineers managed to fit an 88mm gun into a turret and intended to conduct tests, but the war ended before that could happen.
Furthermore, a Panther G turret was mounted on a Panther II hull, and this configuration is currently on display in a museum.
Some sources even suggest that a prototype hull might have been sent to the front.
Given all these points, wouldn’t it have occurred to anyone to mount the turret equipped with the 88mm gun onto a Panther II hull—especially considering the logistical challenges faced throughout the war?
I also looked through the comments; it seems that some unfinished vessels—and perhaps that “premium” Tiger II—were being constructed from the ground up at a shipyard, while in another instance, the component in question hadn’t even been mounted onto a Tiger II tank.
Considering all this, I truly fail to see what kind of problem the inclusion of the Panther II would cause—especially when there are already vehicles in the game that entered service around 1950—or what the point of all this uproar is.
Even though they were separate projects, it was inevitable that they would eventually merge into a single program, given the requirements for logistics, supply, production, and maintenance.
Furthermore, this transition is well-represented in both of the games in question.
The same flexibility granted to ships should also be extended to the Panther series—which effectively consists of two separate projects—as a way to help resolve the medium tank issue within the game.
Questionable when the single hull was captured without a turret to begin with.
First, the panther II program ended years before the panther 88 even started and second there wasnt any logistical issues because the turret was never made at the end and only 1 hull for the panther 2 were ever made. And this new turret would worsen the logistical issues if anything as you would need to modify the hulls as the turret ring is bigger.
We dont have ships that mixes two different and unrelated proyects like with the panther, technically more since they added a different engine as well
However, Daimler officials state that they are preparing to begin full-scale production of the turret in question.
Furthermore, although the ships remained unfinished in the shipyards, they have already been added to the game.
I do not understand why this same level of leniency—applied to the ships—becomes a problem when it comes to this particular vehicle.
In other words, it is highly probable that, had the necessary adjustments been made, this vehicle could have appeared before the war ended.
Due to material shortages, the Germans often repurposed components originally intended for other uses; for instance, the Jumo 213 engine was initially designed for bombers but was later adapted for fighter aircraft.
Given all of this—and considering that we are not talking about the development of an atomic bomb—wasn’t such a combination practically inevitable?
Pr23 in game is alleged to be a kitbash of multiple projects.

Even if they start full production of the turre which they did not the panther 2 ended well before that.
Because the panther 2 was never meant to use the 88…
What?
So, they made designs out of wood just because they were bored?
I think that settles the discussion.
Iirc the issue with that was that the guns were never made, not sure about it being a mix of different proyects
The guns served in defense of Leningrad.
The turrets weren’t made though.
I feel like putting together a timeline might help people understand why we call the in-game Panther II a kitbash.
So, in War Thunder, there are five components that make the Panther II different from its predecessor in the tree. These five are: the Schmalturm, the installation of an 88mm gun, the installation of a new engine/transmission combo, the inclusion of NVD, and the Panther II hull.
If we look at each of these separately in real history, we get the following:
Late 1942: The Maybach HL234 begins development as part of work on the Tiger-Maus design, and following the latter’s cancellation, stays on as the intended engine to equip the E-100.
22nd January 1943: a Wa Pruef 6 report lists the specifications intended for the Panther II. The logic here is that the Panther’s all-front armour layout leaves it vulnerable from the sides to fire from Soviet 14.5mm anti-tank rifles. Experience on the Eastern Front had proved how deadly these could be. The Panther II is meant to address this potential issue, plus satisfy Hitler’s preference for 100mm frontal hull thickness.
The specifications are as follows:

I will ask you to note that no changes are planned for either the armament or the engine and transmission combo. In fact, I couldn’t find what transmission the game Panther II’s is based on, and I can’t check since I don’t have the vehicle, does anybody know?
Early 1943: The Nashorn, the first vehicle to mount the PAK 43 (anti tank version of the later KWK43) enters mass production. Discussion is happening at this time about installing this weapon in Tiger 1 tanks. This will never come to fruition. If any discussion is being held about potentially installing the weapon in the under-development Panther II, there is no record left of it and it is not reflected in official intentions and requirements for the intended vehicle.
May 1943: German testing reveals that the installation of armoured side-skirts is enough to defeat Soviet anti-tank rifles.
To quote directly from Jentz and Doyle,
the invention of Schürzen saved the Panther I. If the Panther I hadn’t been able to cope with anti-tank rifles, production would have been converted to the Panther II.
After this point, the Panther II project is cancelled. Two hulls were ordered and one built, but the vehicle was unnecessary and redundant now that a much simpler solution had been found. Therefore, everything after this date no longer applies to the Panther II, and only applies to the regular Panther instead.
20th August 1944: First Schmalturm prototype completed and installed on a Panther G for testing.
18th October 1944: Krupp drew up a blueprint for a modified version of the Schmalturm that could house the KWK43.
4th December 1944: Krupp is awarded a contract to develop this turret design.
January 1945: Second Schmalturm prototype completed and installed on a Panther G for testing.
23rd January 1945: Development of the KWK43 version of the Schmalturm is moved from Krupp to DB. Later, Krupp and DB would be asked to cooperate on the design.
23rd January 1945: The HL 234 is proposed as an alternative engine for the Tiger II. The engine had been in development for more than two years at this point and would never mature, but more importantly for our purposes we are now almost two years past the cancellation of the historical Panther II.
8th March 1945: Colonel Crohn from Wa Pruef 6 brings Krupp back in a major way by giving them four days to submit their turret design.
14th March 1945: the General Inspector of the armoured forces asks Wa Pruef to build a soft-steel prototype of the new turret for testing purposes, and to install it on a Panther chassis.
March through April 1945: the NVD system FG 1250 is issued to Panther Gs belonging to a handful of regiments.
23rd March 1945: Albert Speer asks for a Panther with the KWK43 to be ready for display in mid-April such that Hitler can review it around the time of his birthday.
The end.
The vast majority of the relevant history of these components took place after the Panther II had already been cancelled.
Still, it wasnt a turret with an 88 mock up like we have in game, like i said a panther 2 with the 75 could be added without an issue.
They also gave it in game a different transmission, not sure on which did they based it on IRL tho
