You have a relatively historical match maker in WT it’s called SIM, and how many ppl and vehicles are playing that
1 Like
So what it’s 20 years younger?
You put it very nicely: it’s an artillery piece, not a tank, so it will naturally get balanced differently than tanks, cause guess what? Arty vehicles make concessions that benefit them in real life but not in a game like War Thunder, thus they are a lower BR: they are less effective. Simple!
And no, the variants we have in game are not in service with Ukraine, you do your homework 😘.
And why would you be the fool to pick IS-2 over M109? Because you’ll get better armor, mobility and a shell that doesn’t fuze weirdly at times when you hit certain plates? You’d be a fool not to pick IS-2 over M109. IS-2 is a competitive tank, M109 is a gimmick.
Then bring 7.0 tank with your 8.0 lineup and enjoy your historicity
2 out of 9 examples are outside of WW2, the game never “lost its plot” because it never had the one you think it had.
I am not sure what tanks you are talking about but if they are experimental then they would have to be limited in numbers also if they are not mass produced there numbers would have to be historically correct like 1 in 100
Ok, then I want to play with Me 262 and Kikka against end war props with no uptiers. Or do you have rule for this too?
No, no and hell no. There are so many reasons this is a bad idea. Only people who don’t critically think about this suggest it. On the most basic level there are literally still ww2 tanks in service today eg. T-34. Think t-34 should be facing challengers, leopard 2 and abrams? Imagine the fun playing g for a. Couple days unlocking your t-34 and then first battle your facing modern main battle tanks.
Other tanks still in service for eg. M3Stuart tank, m48 pattons tank, centurion and more. Syria last used the pz 4 in 1967 so have fun facing cold war mbt in that tank.
1 Like
Spitfire mk24 all ready does
The idea is when they was first deployed. Obviously many got sold on and zre still in use or been converted
K but I want to face all end war props
1963
Limits are a hard ‘NO’. They also tried this when they dolid the historical events.
People will rush to get to use the limited tank. If they dont get to it in time, a fair number will just leave the match to try again.
Usually these aren’t debates, there typically people who would love to make a suggestion post except any time they do they get denied since its often very dumb ideas.
Exactly, nothing modern about that.
We’re in 2024, 61 years later.
This is a debate and if you dont want to be part of it move along, nothing for you here unless you want to troll
It would be interesting to try a historical MM as a base, it is clear that some separations would have to be made since there are tanks of similar dates that could not compete with others, but in any case it would be almost impossible to do, the first thing is that the damage model of the The game is a real piece of garbage, so the game should be given a realistic damage model, making Full AP ammunition and all non-APHE ammunition greater damage. Apart from this, much larger maps would be needed, so that They could make flanks correctly and thus defeat tanks that are superior to yours. The penetration calculator would also have to be improved, for example one of the clearest cases of their disaster is the fact that the American cannon cannot pierce the hull front of a panther, when in reality with the M77 and M82 it could be lost at around 400 meters and the T33 could reach almost 1000 meters, making the pershing and the M36 an extreme danger for the panther. And finally, and even more impossible, the teamwork, if your team plays properly and supporting the other players you can compete with a much superior tank, but in this game that is impossible unless you play with a friend.
1 Like
It would not be unhistorically correct to be modern
How about NO
1 Like
If your iteam is not historically mass produced then you cant have it sorry
Sure, I’d love to demolish Pz.III’s with my IS-3