I call that bullshit but everyone will have a different opinion.
Yak9s definitly dosnt have it all. They are heavy and therefore not the most manouvable, they have little ammo and not hard hitting ones, against planes, aswell. (only the 23mm but both dont have that when using the 45mm)
Any Bf109, Typon, Spit, Jap and so on… will have a freekill on a Yak9 unless theyre stooopid.
Also dont forget the BR is based on statistics and most players are also to stooopid to get a kill with a Yak9K especially an Plane…
I know it sucks that they balance stuff like that, but it is what it is. BI should also not be 6.3… but it is… and why? because the few that got it back then sucked ass. Same with the Tu2s, why the f is that 5.3? Cause the people suck ass. For me that thing is stoooopidly broken OP and could easily be 6.3 in GRB.
And if u want to get a balanced game… u need to bann all HVARs to 6.7 minimum aswell… but no one seem to care about that to hard… cause 99.5% of the people havent understood yet that u can kill basically all AAs from 3-4 km, staying out of their range and being unattackable for them. Just get used to it and shoot 3-4 rockets in their way and they will die. Most planes have 8+ HVARs… so happy hunting
Statisticly (sadly u cant different between ground and air rb), the
Do 335 B2 has a Tank KD of 4.3 and Air KD of 1.35, and the
Yak 9k has a Tank KD of 3.42 and Air KD of 0.59, and the USA
AD-4 has a Tank KD of 4.6 and Air KD of 0.77
Well, being 1.7 BR higher than the same plane with just worse engine and 12,7mm instead of 20 seems like an overkill to me.
I’ve been using Yak-9UT in my 5.7 at first and then 6.0 ground lineup for a long time, years before it got APHE and i’ve never found it particularly game breaking.
At 5.7 with APHE it was definitely at it’s strongest, but those tankier heavies above 6.0 like Tiger 2 or T34/29 really put the 45s to the test. I think it’s fine in the current spot.
If they leave me completely alone? Yeah, i probably won’t do as much in any other plane. If they don’t i will be able to do more in many other planes, like TU-2 or F4U-4B
With Yak-9UT I’m able to fight planes and all ground units that spawn. With Tu-2 I’m mostly just a bomber and Your capabilities are restricted to bombs and few 20mm ammo.
With F4U-4B You are able to perform fighter duties after You drop the bombs and get rid of rockets, not like Yak-9UT that will still have ammo. Not to mention that after dropping bombs and rockets You won’t be able to destroy as many ground units as You can still destroy with Yak-9UT
With TU-2 i operate at altitudes most GRB planes won’t chase me after at. And with 5/7 bombs i will have more than enough for the entire enemy team.
With F4U-4B you just need to get rid of 2 bombs, you are still a very decent fighter with those few HVARs underneath.
I also forgot about Do 335-B2 which is also amazing CAS around this BR.
And again, the biggest downside of Yak is vulnerability to AA. No other plane listed above has this downside to such extent. To make best use of your guns you often need to get at least pretty close to the target and to fire at it you need to fly in a straight line
It is really not harder to hit. Size of the aircraft doesn’t matter as much when firing an SPAA. It’s way more about predictability of it’s path. And gun CAS by design is forced to fly very predictable when attacking. It balances out by far the greatest kill potential this type of CAS has
It matters alright. Be it vs SPAA or in a plane on plane scenario. Hence f.e. BI is almost impossible to hit as it’s like 50% of what normal plane is. It’s like trying to shoot a mosquito with a pistol
Of course it matters. If you are shooting something huge, there is a much higher margin of error allowed vs when shooting a tiny plane. The Yak-9 is tiny.
As long as you properly predict plane’s path given enough shots you will hit it. And most AAs only need 1 or 2 hits to entirely cripple enemy aircraft.
And it just so happens that planes flying low, in straight paths and spend a long time over the battlefield are by far the most vulnerable. If i have to choose between a TU-2 at over 1km altitude doing circles over the battlefield and a Yak-9 doing nose dive on the enemy and then going straight up, often getting pretty slow at the end of regaining altitude i will always choose the Yak, since it’s much easier to hit. It’s not any rocket science. It doesn’t matter that TU-2 is huge and Yak is half it’s size. It is still easier to hit.
And if TU-2 wants to kill me, he just needs to more or less approximate my location, fly over at 1,5km altitute, go into bomb sight, press space once and immediately turn away. If yak wants to kill me, he needs to commit and fly directly at me becoming the easiest target in existance.
It is not A2A combat where regardless of type of plane, all are at more or less same distance from you when you fire. Larger planes more often than not will stay away from you if you are an AA, so their size doesn’t matter as much. In same circumstances they will obviously be easier to hit, but that’s not what happens.
If your aim is perfect and enemy will not change his course, you’ll hit every time.
How simple and briliant.
I guess when playing 37-40mm SPAA you just single-click people out of existence, creating a no-fly zone.
ABSOLUTE LEGEND.
Meanwhile in real world - you make a tiniest mistake, you miss. Vs bigger plane - you hit and kill allright.
Except it’s simply easier to aim at a closer and predictable target than one that is 3 times further away and can do all sorts of maneuvers while still performing it’s CAS role.
This is not ARB and you aren’t a fighter. You can’t just get closer to the enemy you want to kill. You are stationary and larger planes with bombsight will stay away from you. It’s as simple as that.
At same distance larger planes are obviously easier to hit, but this is not what very often happens.
A yak at 500m is much easier to hit than TU-2 at 1,5km
Again, this is about margin of error. If there’s a Pe8 coming straight at me, even if he’s keeping his altitude, in a Duster or Ostwind I can easily slap him out of the sky.