Hello,
I’d like to understand why exactly the Z-19E is currently placed at BR 12.3.
From what I remember, one of the main reasons for its higher BR is its air-to-air missile capability. However, I honestly don’t think this justifies such a significant BR difference compared to the regular Z-19 in the tech tree, which has access to the same air-to-air missiles sitting at BR 12.3.
I mainly play helicopters in Ground RB for their anti-ground capabilities, not specifically for their air-to-air missiles. The Z-19E’s laser-guided rockets are its main ground-attack weapon, but its overall effectiveness doesn’t justify placing it at such a high BR in my opinion.
Another major disadvantage is the lack of adequate infrared countermeasures.
Unlike many other helicopters at comparable BRs, the Z-19E lacks an infrared jammer or comparable IR-based defensive countermeasure system. This makes it particularly vulnerable to incoming infrared-guided missiles, especially when operating at the low altitudes required for laser-guided rocket attacks.
Combined with the lack of a machine gun or minigun, this leaves the Z-19E with very limited defensive options. Its air-to-air missiles are essentially its only means of engaging enemy aircraft, while it has very limited ways of protecting itself against incoming threats.
I find it difficult to justify such a high BR when the helicopter has these significant defensive limitations.
Another issue is its limited ability to defend itself against enemy aircraft. Unlike some other helicopters, the Z-19E doesn’t have a machine gun or minigun for self-defence. Its only real option against incoming aircraft is its air-to-air missiles.
And while those missiles can certainly be effective in some situations, they are far from being as reliable or powerful as their BR might suggest. As shown in the video I’m going to attach, I’ve had multiple situations where missiles failed to hit targets despite what appeared to be very favourable firing conditions.
The biggest problem, however, is its actual performance against high-tier ground vehicles and SPAA.
At BR 12.3, you’re already facing extremely capable anti-air systems. Even in a full downtier, these vehicles can often detect and engage you long before your laser-guided rockets have reached their targets.
Since the rockets require continuous laser guidance, you cannot simply fire and immediately disengage. You have to maintain the laser lock and remain exposed long enough for the rockets to reach their targets. Against high-tier SPAA, this often means getting shot down before your attack can even be completed.
And it gets even worse in an uptier.
At BR 12.3, the probability of facing BR 13.3 matches is quite high. At that point, the situation becomes even more difficult, as you’re facing even more capable air defence systems.
Honestly, playing the Z-19E at 12.3 already feels extremely situational and heavily dependent on luck. In an uptier, it becomes practically unplayable in my experience.
I also don’t think the current BR makes much sense from a lineup perspective. China doesn’t have a proper 12.3 ground lineup. Its next relevant ground vehicles are at 12.7, and there are only 3 tanks available at that BR.
This means that taking the Z-19E into a 12.7 lineup essentially forces you to use it alongside a very limited selection of ground vehicles, despite the helicopter itself not being particularly effective at that BR.
So why would anyone choose to purchase the premium Z-19E when the regular tech tree Z-19 offers the same air-to-air missile capability at BR 12.3?
The premium version is supposed to offer an attractive alternative, but its current BR makes it extremely difficult to justify purchasing it. (I know it got removed)
My questions to Gaijin are:
- What exactly justifies the Z-19E’s BR of 12.3?
- Has the effectiveness of its laser-guided rockets against modern high-tier SPAA been taken into account when determining its BR?
- Could its BR be reconsidered, taking its actual ground-attack performance, limited self-defence capabilities and the lack of a suitable Chinese ground lineup into account?
I’m not asking for the helicopter to be overpowered or artificially placed at a lower BR. I simply think its current BR is difficult to justify, especially when compared to its tech tree counterpart.
At the moment, I honestly struggle to see why anyone would spend money on a premium helicopter that performs so poorly at the BR it’s placed at.
I’d appreciate an explanation from the developers or the community.
Video showing the missile performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zietoM1EOQY