Why does no one talk in this game? Feels sterile

no warning about what the enemy is doing or if a particularly dangerous tank is somewhere

Waste of time trying to do this. Nobody ever listens. Lost count of the number of times I’ve been spamming ping on a location for a solid minute, said in chat there’s a guy there and watched in disbelief as about 4-5 single celled organisms on my team drive straight out into the open and get instantly killed by said enemy within a span of seconds of each other.

The chat is useful for two things.

  1. Flaming the enemy team.
  2. Being flamed by the enemy team.

We all know this is the only reason all chat exists in PvP games.

3 Likes

Everyone is busy suffering and most WT players are toxic sociopaths, so… consider it a blessing.

2 Likes

It’s not “fake” if it is indeed, sincere . . . which it is for me. If my team does well, I in turn do well . . . just common sense . . and common courtesy . . and we are not riding a bus or any other public transit. I’m a pretty nice guy irl, but I also realize that if they held an Ahole Competition, I would place pretty well in my weight division . . that being said . . no reason to be a condescending jackwagon, just because someone else does not do or see things the same as you. And if you actually see something offensive in just telling someone, even a STRANGER!!, hello . . . than you Sir are part of the problem . . . not the other way around. It’s a game . . nothing more, the idea is to have fun. That is an Subjective word, so means different things to different people . . but encouraging my team mates to do well, in a polite & civil manner will never be a bad thing. And that is just my opinion . . . . nothing to argue about, so I am done . . . thanks for your time.

I’m really struggling to see how you find it ‘really annoying’ when people say good luck in the chat at the start of a match. It’s called sportsmanship, maybe you should give a go.

2 Likes

I scored my 10th violation in August this year - unfortunately calling out a “trash” player as “trash” is not allowed if you use it multiple times. I was found guilty of using “hate speech”… I mean he ran away from me, farmed 2 clueless guys and dove out / below his team whilst using all chat to make fun on them…

But Orson_ES as community manager (and head of GMs, which have set the punishment) told me that you can appeal to reinstall in-game chat after 3 months, so we will see. Maybe worth a try for you guys too…

Have a good one!

PS 1: The pilot i called out this way (i really, really regret this…) in a prop Air RB match responded (ofc) in the same manor in this game; it even increased especially after i managed to kill him with a perfectly timed 800 kg bomb drop on him whilst he tried to repair on his forward airfield, so imho i proved my pov was not entirely wrong…
PS 2: I share the pov that chat is mostly useless, but i guess you can influence 2-4% of your matches especially if you fight with a rookie and you are totally outnumbered - so therefore in very tight matches it is a benefit to give some guidance / support…

1 Like

They banned you for that? Tf. Atleast I was completely unhinged 95% of the time.

1 Like

Don’t want people to hear my mom yelling at me…

1 Like

10th violation is 10th violation. At least they offered me to change the charge “hate speech” if i would insist in order to feel better as i could not match “trash” with hate speech, but they insisted that “trash” used multiple times is seen as offensive, so using it multiple times is a rule violation.
Unfortunately other rules deny me to share the message exchanges…

1 Like

Actually this is a severe issue in some countries.

If reported by neighbours or strangers you might get visits from various child care organizations. So i recommend that your Mom try to use code words.
I started to use “Special Agent” and “Superbrain” after some incidents with my 2 kids - same effect on them (=zero), but way less critical if you are in public…

1 Like

You got lucky … I got one player who said the magic words “free Palestine” … the battle was lost due to so much hate going on. I just asked if we could let this out of the game … no one cared.

Man I’ve abused a fair few players in my time, mainly the Bomber pilots for ruining a tank games when they carpet bomb half the team. I’ve used lots of R rated curses but never ever been chat banned or warned.

1 Like

Just add here and there (depending on lobbies) randomly a “China #1” or a “Taiwan #1” if you have boring matches - and look what happens. Things get really complicated if you use both with a 30 seconds delay…

You simply not got reported.

I mean it is war game designed to kill virtual enemies - but gaijin earns a hell of money with kids. So without their PG 12 rating they would lose a hell of money, so it is logical that they try everything to keep it at PG 12…presenting overwhelming evidence in case some authorities might question the chat culture with providing thousands of temp or perma chat mutes looks comprehensible…

2 Likes

I’ve found with extremely grindy games where you more or less play solo, as in not with a group of friends, it is considered a “safe space” for people. I asked a simple question today in chat at the start, why a rocket tank is just spamming his rockets because I thought it was a waste of ammo. It was coming from behind, like he was still in the spawn location. I was immediately lambasted for “being bothered by what people do in a video game,” which is essentially what that player is feeling about me talking in his game. I tried to explain why I thought it was a valid issue to ask the question, and I was met by repetitive responses of the same nature by the same player. Some tried to chime in and answer, saying he’s artillery, to which I replied rockets aren’t artillery. I get that the player was trying to say he’s lobbing rockets from range, but I gave a technical answer saying it’s not artillery because the sound is clearly from a rocket tank. I can understand a tank functioning as artillery, but not from spawn at the start of the match with limited ammo. I was met by other responses that suggest he has infinite ammo which I don’t believe. All the while, the guy having the meltdown is constantly accusing me of what I’m accusing the rocket tank and him of doing. He then accuses me of projection which is impossible for me since he’s stating the same identical accusations back at me after I send them his way. Some people just aren’t suited for conversation and take offense where none was directed.

I often join matches where the rocket tank instantly spams all his rockets, and I’ve wondered if he was shooting hail marries or just loves the sound effect. The one tank I have with rockets only has 2 volleys of ammunition, so it doesn’t seem prudent to waste it at spawn. This could just be my noobness, but I don’t see how that warranted such offense by parties not even involved. Maybe he too spams rockets like a kid with a toy. Who knows…

In my experience, people that hate communication in game are the most toxic. I don’t consider players that lash out in anger to be toxic. They are just frustrated with their grind. In war, people are cussing up storms and livid at their own men sometimes. This is generally meant to get the men to form up and fly right, but most grindy games are for a certain crowd to “unwind,” and they see this anger as demoralizing. They attach a label to it: “Toxic.” It’s laughable. If you were in a foxhole too afraid to get out of your hole to advance as ordered, you’re probably going to catch an ear full. I don’t mean to suggest all anger is successful at achieving results, but it does work. If people that hate chat want to argue on the % of success, it’s irrelevant. You don’t get penalized in game for trying something in your tank, so why should you get penalized for trying something in chat? I have often turned a match around by tossing a bit of trash talk out to get people to wake up. In a combat game of any genre, it should be expected that people are going to get angry. Snowflakes getting voting power to install chat restrictions just diminish the game. I have seen it happen to good games. They die the tighter chat restrictions become. The chat haters go on enjoying it, but the queue times get longer, and it becomes “their” game. Then they complain about queue times like it’s the dev’s fault. lol That to me is toxic and non-inclusive. If I yell at you for doing something I think is a bonehead move, and I’m right in doing so, even if I’m wrong, I don’t want you to quit. I want you to do better. If I’m wrong, you should be more than capable of defending yourself and explaining to me what I didn’t understand. If your go-to response is to report me, that is toxic to the health of the game. Competition is what attracts people to these games. You start limiting how people can participate, and you start killing the game for people that make it competitive.

If by chance you’re a monk that has mastered the art of silence, good for you. It’s just a strategy. I don’t fault people for being silent. I fault people that actively perceive enemies on their own team for simply trying to develop some banter, ask questions, offer intel, or trash talk. Often times people enjoy seeing people get angry despite reporting them because they think it’s the right thing to do. I find that incredibly toxic. Why would you ban someone you enjoy? Chat was dead. An angry person livened it up, and that’s… terrifying to you? Hurts you in some way? It’s absurd.

I think it’d be a great addition for a post-game lobby that can be switched off for players that definitely would never want to enter it. Hopefully moderation would be extremely laxed as people would be going in with the intent to let off steam or just discuss the match which may involve a disagreement. The reason why people don’t say GG sometimes is because you can’t enter to type once the victory or defeat screen pops up, so you’d have to be quick about it. Even then people are gunning for a kill after the buzzer.

I have since found the Calliope and test drove it to discover that apparently it is “infinite” rocket ammo with a large carriage count. Still seems silly to spam it in spawn especially on a map like Japan. Not sure why I’d get so much flack for asking what’s up on a 10k GE tank I’m likely never to own.

@Exocetta

Everyone is busy suffering and most WT players are toxic sociopaths, so… consider it a blessing.

This to me is exceptionally toxic to blanket label an entire playerbase of which you’re apart of as a condemnable collective. You do touch on the fact that I mentioned as well though, that most people are trying to grind on top of enjoy some competition and reflex training. However, I still find you to be the toxic one in this whole thread, and I’ve seen similar antics from you in other threads. People shouldn’t be condemned for trying to elbow their teammates in the rib. People shouldn’t be condemned for trying to jab the other team. And if you think lashing out in anger at someone is toxic, go get some hockey players fired from their team. When you have a competitive game that boosts adrenaline, you’re going to get some outbursts of masculinity. It’s healthy. Putting restrictions on this release is only going to make it bottle up and cause problems. Every time a game adds restrictions, the toxicity count goes up higher than it was before the restrictions. It becomes a game of abiding by the Terms of Service where the player weapons are automated report systems. Nobody is here to play that game. We’re all here to play warthunder. If you want to play the Terms of Service, you’re a toxic warthunder player. That’s just a fact. You don’t care about the health of the game. You care about your own health which is actually your problem, not the guy trying to do cool shit in a video game that gets angry when he sees some stagnant, lazy, afk, sleepy players focused on their xp grind or even just people with wildly different strategies. Quick paced, short matches, loose matchmaking… it’s going to create some oil and water type scenarios. You just have to accept it rather than control it. Communication is entirely natural and healthy for exploring and understanding what the differences are.

I did propose some more useful strategic fixed messages but nobody was interested.There has to be a way of motivating the team or directing play especially nearer the end of the game.

I find the game to be a very lonely place in GRB sometimes and really no idea where the enemy is in some cases when others must know.I can see the minimap and I see players sitting doing nothing when we could work together.Think about the actually amount of pre set messages we have ,think about erasing everyone and what they could be replaced with to direct play and be helpful instead of just spam.

2 Likes

Exhibit A. lol

1 Like

I have nothing to contribute except toxic condemnation.

Seems I was right.

I did that with Taiwan number one. Used Deepl to translate it. Found out there are A LOT more Chinese than I thought playing this game.

Also accidentally wrote racist shit after that and got muted for month(or a week) i cant remember

2 Likes

do u have some aoing teammate ? who is shoting u ? do u have some anoing mig 29 in ur team ? who is uses speed force to mace fredly helis to crash XD ? its me XD. or mby ur frendly pantsir is kiling u when u are on jet or helli D its me 2. so im rly fredly and kind teammate. after every game 1-2 teammates adding me on frend lists. and they share theyr lovly gaming experiences whit me .so bro there is lot of oportuniti to mace people use chat . just use them.

As usual we have a common understanding :-)

But Air RB has its loneliness too, especially if your team of fighters optimized for high altitudes try to play hide and seek in heavy clouds at low alt whilst facing opponents optimized for low alt - so a classic P51s vs Yak-3 scenario, with the usual outcome.

Or your climb in your 5.0 Italian P-47 whilst being sucked into the usual full uptier with 4 Ju 288s and a German fighter and you play 1 vs 6 before you are at 5.000 meters.

I reduced my chat to the minimum (so just calling out map design flaws) but as proven by my ban i am just a human too. Map pinging or warning of approaching enemies were mostly useless, but very late game the chat can be a very powerful tool…

That is the main reason why there is a lot of truth in the saying you need a fast horse sometimes - especially in Air RB with friendly fire active :-)

1 Like

Although i share most of your views i am not sure if you find the right guys here for a deep analysis of this rather complex issue. No offense, but the game chat looks usually not like a meeting of ANPW (Anonymus Nobel Prize Winners) and this is acceptable for a war game played by kids and 70+ players.

As said earlier, the PG12 rating has a high monetary value for gaijin.

Have a good one!

PS: Plz consider to use more paragraphs in long and complex texts, it makes it much more convenient to read. Thx!

3 Likes