Vehicle Performance at Top Tier

Over the weekend, I set up a bot to watch top tier replays and collect data from the kill feed. Data gathered is from 694 replays.

Notes

CAS = Planes + Helicopters
Data volume is the relative amount of data to the vehicle with the most in the category.

Tanks

K/D
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Strv 122B+ 1.6 12.11%
Strv 122A 1.6 12.02%
Leopard 2A7V 1.54 49.09%
Type 10 1.52 12.09%
Leclerc SXXI 1.51 10.84%
Leclerc 1.49 14.81%
T-80BVM 1.45 100.0%
Type 90 (B) “Fuji” 1.38 21.05%
ZTZ99A 1.35 14.56%
T-90M 1.35 69.16%
M1A2 SEP 1.32 19.14%
Challenger 2 OES 1.27 14.76%
Leopard 2A6 1.25 25.89%
M1A2 1.25 14.81%
M1A2 SEP V2 1.18 25.89%
Leopard 2A5 1.16 27.76%
M1A1 1.12 11.81%
Leopard 2 PSO 1.1 24.77%
HSTV-L 1.06 38.73%
Т-90А 0.99 12.58%
M1A1 Click-Bait 0.98 77.6%
Т-80U-Е1 0.97 80.92%
T-72B3 0.93 23.59%
Leopard 2A4M 0.91 30.46%
T-80U 0.88 18.36%
Leopard 2 PL 0.87 28.72%
M1A1 AIM 0.85 41.53%
2S25M 0.82 11.46%
RDF/LT 0.82 10.07%
T-80UK 0.79 41.61%
M1128 Wolfpack 0.71 12.23%
2S38 0.68 30.19%
BMP-2M 0.65 23.03%
PUMA VJTF 0.59 12.09%
K/D Rank 8 Combat Only
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Type 10 1.31 10.63%
Leclerc 1.24 13.62%
Strv 122B+ 1.16 11.22%
Leclerc SXXI 1.16 9.83%
T-80BVM 1.14 100.0%
Strv 122A 1.14 11.01%
Leopard 2A7V 1.13 42.89%
ZTZ99A 1.12 12.44%
T-90M 1.08 67.06%
M1A2 SEP 1.07 21.64%
Leopard 2A6 0.89 22.52%
M1A2 SEP V2 0.87 28.47%
Leopard 2A5 0.85 23.62%
Leopard 2 PSO 0.8 20.67%
Percentage of Deaths Caused by CAS
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
FlaRakRad 59.11% 13.38%
ADATS 43.18% 20.99%
Pantsir-S1 40.88% 33.99%
LAV-AD 33.83% 17.32%
2S6 29.96% 11.42%
PUMA VJTF 18.80% 22.06%
M1A2 18.20% 18.55%
M1A2 SEP 16.10% 22.57%
M1128 Wolfpack 15.84% 19.71%
Strv 122A 15.36% 12.53%
Leopard 2A6 15.08% 31.47%
RDF/LT 15.08% 15.31%
Strv 122B+ 15.02% 12.53%
Leopard 2A5 14.79% 34.97%
Challenger 2 OES 14.29% 17.36%
M1A1 HC 13.74% 11.2%
Leclerc SXXI 13.65% 11.59%
Leopard 2 PSO 13.29% 31.21%
M1A1 13.01% 14.79%
WZ1001(E) LCT 12.80% 10.69%
M1A2 SEP V2 12.77% 31.12%
HSTV-L 12.26% 48.82%
BMP-2M 11.69% 36.21%
Leopard 2A7V 11.65% 50.28%
2S38 11.44% 46.34%
2S25M 11.29% 16.29%
M1A1 AIM 10.63% 57.12%
Leopard 2 PL 10.49% 39.93%
Leopard 2A4M 10.02% 40.96%
Т-90А 8.94% 15.78%
M1A1 Click-Bait 8.71% 97.18%
ZTZ99A 8.38% 15.31%
T-72B3 8.19% 30.27%
Type 10 8.06% 11.67%
T-90M 7.92% 73.41%
Leclerc 7.61% 15.18%
T-80U 6.73% 24.16%
Type 90 (B) “Fuji” 5.96% 21.5%
T-80BVM 5.94% 100.0%
T-80UK 5.58% 56.69%
Т-80U-Е1 3.96% 98.29%

SPAA

K/D to CAS
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Pantsir-S1 2.36 100.0%
ItO 90M 2.08 37.21%
ADATS 1.63 51.05%
FlaRakRad 1.58 43.81%
2S38 0.93 21.91%
LAV-AD 0.77 22.27%
K/D to Planes Only
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Pantsir-S1 2.16 100.0%
ItO 90M 1.94 36.48%
ADATS 1.27 47.02%
FlaRakRad 1.22 40.57%
K/D to Helicopters Only
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Pantsir-S1 3.07 100.0%
FlaRakRad 2.97 52.98%
ADATS 2.96 62.46%
ItO 90M 2.5 39.3%
2S38 1.33 35.09%
Weapons Destroyed to CAS Deaths
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Pantsir-S1 0.52 100.0%
ItO 90M 0.27 30.47%
FlaRakRad 0.25 28.98%
2S6 0.22 13.16%
ADATS 0.07 29.09%

Planes

K/D Planes Only
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Rafale C 2.98 36.44%
Eurofighters combined 1.83 70.3%
F/A-18C Late 1.34 18.78%
Su-30SM 1.3 100.0%
F-16C 1.13 29.37%
F-15E 1.02 29.53%
Su-33 1.02 27.61%
F/A-18C Early 0.75 16.53%
Su-34 0.64 41.89%
Ground Kills to Deaths
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Rafale C 2.52 26.14%
Su-30SM 2.48 100.0%
Su-34 2.02 59.41%
Su-39 1.31 21.16%
AV-8B 1.02 9.83%
F-15E 0.95 21.58%
F-16C 0.94 20.98%
Eurofighters combined 0.86 33.75%
F/A-18C Late 0.74 10.61%
F/A-18C Early 0.73 16.85%
MQ-1 0.57 26.62%
Orion 0.52 13.01%
A-10A 0.51 9.41%
Ground Kills to Deaths from Ground Sources
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Su-30SM 6.49 100.0%
Rafale C 5.78 26.7%
Su-34 4.33 59.52%
Su-39 2.2 21.23%
Eurofighters combined 2.15 27.79%
F-16C 2.05 18.45%
F-15E 2.03 19.04%
F/A-18C Early 1.32 15.24%
A-10A 0.76 8.97%
MQ-1 0.72 28.15%
Orion 0.65 13.64%

Helicopters

Ground Kills to Deaths
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Ka-52 1.33 70.44%
EC-665 Tiger UHT 1.22 31.43%
Ka-50 0.69 100.0%
YAH-64 0.57 26.4%
AH-64A 0.55 38.9%
Ground Kills to Deaths from Ground Sources
Vehicle Ratio Data Volume %
Ka-52 2.12 69.41%
EC-665 Tiger UHT 1.95 30.73%
Ka-50 0.92 100.0%
AH-64A 0.81 36.08%
YAH-64 0.81 25.1%

Raw Data

9 Likes

Do you have the raw data for further analysis?

Also, you excluded many vehicles from many nations, especially from SPAA and CAS categories. Is this your choice due to the low data, or other factors?

It would also be great if we could see some sample sizes (for confidence intervals etc)

Kinda funny the a10a is there but not the a10C. Anyhow Very nice to see this!

1 Like

Japan strong. Thank you for sharing this information, you could be a valuable member in the community with such capacity to be honest.

1 Like

Interesting how the Pantsir is the only thing with a 100% presence rate. That thing is so busted compared to all other SPAAs.

2 Likes

LOL, data volume means data compared to the vehicle with the most data in that category. not K/D

…what?

Im assuming the data volume is how many replays that vehicle was present in. Is it not that?

Yeah, but that doesn’t mean it’s busted.

There is no helicopters on the list that has spikes.

Besides, someone said that helicopters are superior to spaa. Looking at the kd list it doesn’t look that way.

Helis are one of the most difficult vehicles to play in this game I am not surprised by their KD one bit. The thing that stands out the most is how the US has 2 MBTs dying almost 3 times more than USSR MBT’s and have way less data volume than all t series do with having the highest by CAS. Color me surprised said nobody

Yes, I will make the raw data available.

The problem is not enough data for example, take the Helicopter charts notably the Tiger HAD Block 2 is missing. That’s because I made the cut-off at 100 kills + deaths and even in 694 replays it wasn’t seen that much. It has 6% of the data that the KA-50 has.

Tiger HAD Block 2 Data
Kills Deaths
Ground kills to Deaths 30 22
Ground Kills to Deaths from Ground Sources 30 8

What would be the best way to do this?

Data volume is how many data points each vehicle has compared to the vehicle with the most in each category. Example: T-80BVM has 1000 kills and deaths and the Leopard 2A7V has 500 kills and deaths. The Leopard 2A7V has half or 50% of the data compared to the T-80BVM.
Maybe it’s not necessary to include or I didn’t explain it well in the post. Any feedback is appreciated.

Screenshot_2025-04-15-07-35-32-17_40deb401b9ffe8e1df2f1cc5ba480b12
@GALWAYLION

Inb4 “ground” mains come in complaining how CAS is still way too OP even though they die to something else in >80% of the cases.
These are some fun stats though, thanks for sharing OP.

Ah, you mean the jet no one ever uses has a higher K/D ratio than what every noob that hasn’t figured out the countermeasure button has?

Mate, in case you haven’t figured it out, a large part of the community plays American air. That’s why when you play Premium BRs (11.0-13.0), both sides are like 50% American F4S, F-20, and F-18. Of course they are going to have a worse KD ratio compared to an obscure country that very few play (France does not have a high player base, and typically they are more skilled).

I like how it confirms, that rafale, eurofighter and F18C is much more “OP” than su30

Maybe because you are reading it wrong. The ss right above is for planes v planes only.

maybe, i wasn’t bothering to read it but just checked the screenshot

Lol all good as did I at first glance.

Interesting, thanks for sharing.

The key there is “compared to other SPAAs” it’s basically the only SPAA worth even pulling at this point. And that says more about how bad other SPAAs are than anything.