Well, why don’t you mention the P-51’s top speed, its diving speed, its armament (the 12.7mm—which is actually more effective than a 20mm cannon, a real joke that is), its incredible maneuverability at high speeds, and the fact that it retains energy better even during turns?
Look, even in the values you’ve provided here, they are nearly equal. In fact, since the P-51 almost always operates at higher speeds, it’s consistently the one with the advantage.
You’re framing this as a 1v1 scenario. A P-51 pilot generally won’t engage in a duel with you; they’ll just fly away—that’s what these planes are designed for. All this talk about spiral climbs or spiral dives? Pilots who truly understand their aircraft don’t bother with that nonsense; they execute a dive, pull away, and leave you trailing far behind, empty-handed.
For instance, I once out-turned and shot down a Bf 109 G-2 while flying a D-10—even though the D-10 is heavier. We were both at low speeds during that duel. And the opponent who shot you down while you were in a P-47? They were flying a Bf 109 G-2, which has roughly the same level of flight performance as the one I used in my duel.
You’ve effectively exposed yourself with these charts.
The P-51 C-10 entered service in early 1944. It has a Battle Rating (BR) of 4.0.
The Bf 109 F-4 entered service in June 1941.
The P-51 C-10 is objectively superior to the F-4. With this aircraft, the Americans picked off the Germans with ease; only the K-4, Ta 152, and D-9 were somewhat capable of standing up to it.
You’re acting more like a than an actual German. And don’t even try to bring up things like fuel shortages—stop looking at this through an emotional lens.
The year of production absolutely has an impact on performance. You shouldn’t evaluate an aircraft solely based on its maneuverability; factors like armament, high-speed handling, and many others also come into play.
Following your logic, the I-16 would be a better aircraft than the F4 because it’s more maneuverable. But how does it fare in terms of acceleration, armament, climb rate, and turn performance at high speeds?
An aircraft’s Battle Rating (BR) in the game isn’t determined by your 1v1 duels.
In short, the P-51 C-10 is an aircraft that entered service in early 1944. Even if it were to perform slightly worse than the F-4 (which entered service in June 1941)—as your dubious little charts might suggest—it is, in fact, a vastly superior aircraft. It consistently maintains higher speeds, which compensates for any minor performance gaps; it is capable of incredible maneuvers at high speeds, performs better in a dive, is significantly faster, and boasts a higher top speed.
Given that it isn’t an intermediate or transitional variant, its Battle Rating (BR) should be 4.7—the same level as the G-6.