Vehicle F-5E
Mode: Air Simulator Battles
Requested BR: 11.3 → 10.7–10.3 (in sim)
I strongly believe the American F-5E is overtiered in Air Simulator Battles.
Its excellent close-range maneuverability does not compensate for its overall limitations against the aircraft it currently faces. These include its limited air-to-air missile loadout and missile capability, limited countermeasures, radar limitations and lack of IFF, as well as its fuel and payload limitations.In Simulator Battles, situational awareness and the ability to identify and engage targets are much more important than in Realistic Battles. The lack of IFF and the limitations of its radar can force the pilot to approach unknown contacts, wasting time and energy while increasing exposure to enemy aircraft.I believe the F-5E should be evaluated according to its overall effectiveness in Simulator Battles, rather than having its rating determined primarily by its close-range flight performance. A BR around 10.7–10.3 would be worth considering, with the final rating determined by its actual performance against the aircraft it would face at that range.
I would appreciate feedback from other Simulator pilots who have experience flying the American F-5E against aircraft in its current BR bracket.
At least you can easily run away from it, despite the MiG-21MF being at a lower BR. It’s not like the MiG-21MF is suffering with its decent FM and 4x R-60
Half the problem is that 11.3 is just stupidly compressed. The first step is to move the FG1/FGR2 and all the Mig-23s to 11.7. that would immediately make 11.3 waaaaaay more playable for everything else.
No, you can’t. Especially in sim. But even in ARB the F-5E has exceptional MER and the 21 is the opposite. In both air rb and sim, the 21MF is useless against a F-5E, just full stop, no upsides all massive downsides
Or just rat. F5 doesnt have a PD radar, so wont be able to see a low flying Mig-21, and being faster, you can always catch up. Its sim, probably wont see you coming. Then its just guns or missiles to the butt with no warning
Only explanation I have to why a LOT of aircraft are even remotely close to their current BRs in ASB
I think you are RB player body I’m speaking about Sim mode
Cuz in Sim a whole different story without enough missiles and terrible radar without IFF you’re cooked 90% of the kill in Sim mode is hit and run less than 10% of the action happens in dogfights
The mig 21bis it’s so much better like it’s not even close
Yeah, now I’m pretty sure you have no idea how Sim works
Cuz with no IFF and only two rear aspect only 20G missiles and with all that your slow against almost all11.0 planes
So u basically useless at 11.0 and higher
That’s why I said the F5-E belongs at 10.7 and lower
Have you ever heard of guns and furballs? That’s the whole point of the plane dude, you only played the thing 5 times. Why should I or anyone else think you know what you’re doing.
Poisoning the well here, I literally played sim more than you have
Bro come on it’s not only me you can search
There is another players also discussed about the F5 E battle rank
Specially sim mode
Dude, it’s like the sun. You can’t hide it the F5 it’s so underpowered and can’t stand against much stronger on paper and or reality planes.