A fifth-generation fighter is defined by the integration of stealth, advanced sensors, electronic warfare and networked combat capabilities, not by impressive aerobatics and a manufacturer calling it fifth generation.
Honestly, this reads more like Sukhoi marketing material than an objective technical assessment.
Let’s start with those RCS figures of 0.006 m² and 0.017 m². Where exactly do they come from? You already admitted in post #18 that these were your own estimates and that you weren’t even sure how accurate they were.
Without knowing the radar frequency, aspect angle, material properties or methodology, those numbers are practically meaningless. And somehow you conclude that the Su-57 is almost as stealthy as an F-35?
The aircraft also has some pretty obvious design compromises. Its engine compressor faces aren’t completely concealed by serpentine intakes, and those conventional circular thrust-vectoring nozzles aren’t exactly ideal for reducing rear-aspect signatures. RAM coatings can’t magically compensate for everything.
Then there’s the avionics. Having an AESA radar, IRST and additional radar arrays doesn’t automatically mean you have F-35-level sensor fusion. Where’s the evidence of comparable integrated situational awareness, electronic warfare capabilities or network-centric combat performance? The Su-57 has its own datalink systems, sure, but there’s no publicly demonstrated evidence of networking capabilities comparable to the F-35’s overall architecture.
And the engines? The Su-57 entered service with AL-41F1 engines closely related to earlier Flanker technology, while its intended next-generation engines have suffered years of delays. Thrust vectoring looks great at airshows, but modern BVR combat isn’t an aerobatics competition.
Even RUSI, which actually employs aerospace and military aviation specialists, has highlighted the Su-57’s significantly greater radar signature compared to Western VLO fighters and questioned aspects of its avionics maturity.
Nobody is arguing that the Su-57 isn’t an improvement over previous Russian fighters. Of course it is. But that’s a very different claim from saying it’s comparable to the F-22 or F-35 in stealth, sensor fusion and survivability.
Until there’s credible evidence supporting those claims, calling it an advanced 4.5++ generation fighter with some fifth-generation features is a perfectly reasonable assessment.
And no, repeating Russian marketing claims doesn’t count as technical evidence.
Sources:
RUSI – Russian and Chinese Combat Air Trends (2020):
RUSI – Official publication: