SPAA at 9.3-10.3 is hilariously OP and i see no one talking about it

This has also been a lifesaver, since it lets me know when someone is attempting to sneak all the way around the map and come from behind. However, it only works if they stray too close to the air spawn points, if they cut a very narrow line it’s still possible to sneak around there, at least on most maps. And, of course, it still leaves 270 degrees where planes can come from that give no warning if they use terrain.

Thermal targeting pods start at 10.3 on the Q-5L: Q-5L | War Thunder Wiki. So yeah at 10.x finding spaa to target first is on any non-cloudy map extremely easy.

The Q-5L in particular also has extremely long guidance time (80s and Laser+IOG+GNSS on the 250 guided bombs), so you can strike from 14+ km away with some practice on most maps, well outside of most spaa in the game.

1 Like

The British Jag GR1A gets Talid, a thermal tgp at 10.3 GRB

Oh, I thought the GR.1A was 10.7. But it’s 10.3 in GRB too yeah.

1 Like

Because Ground RB is fun while Air RB is a boring dogwater mode.

2 Likes

This is true but also combined needs to be it’s own, air can be and ground should be allowed to as well.

2 Likes

From 8.3-10.3 is a most fun BRs for me, because very limited CAS. SPAAs are OP? Yes, agreed, but not for cleaning the skies. In these BRs whole teams are SPAAs and ruined the tank gameplay. Gepard clones, ZA-35, ITPSV Leos are everywhere. Try to play some not russian style MBTs…
i like to remove the AP bullets from SPAAs, or limiting for selfdefense, like in the gepard clones APDs racks

@Beeschurger Hey I just got an new idea on lower br CAS vs higher BR AA: You see that we do have a SP reduction system when some vehicle is uptiered, covering up to -1.0 BR. So when a 9.3 is in 10.3, the system gives out ~500+ vs 130. How would the “Not compare when BR different” theory consider this?

Spaa is never op. Planes are shooting at a two dimensional target whereas spaa shoots a three dimensional. Its already far harder to hit a plane with an a spaa than a tank with a plane. People who claim spaa is op either suck ass or just don’t know what spaa is supposed to do. Spaa is supposed to stop planes

1 Like

Insert:

As in 9.3 CAS plane would be cheaper to spawn in 10.3 game?

Just make cas spawn tied to killstreaks and not points. I know people wouldn’t cap points then but no one players the objective anyway

can’t wait for people to spawn in a yak-9K for 30sp at 10.0

Were not playing CoD.

1 Like

Not cheap enough considering what it can do in the comparison, but is considered as a case sooo better not leave it there :D

And another consequence of playing CAS with all precautions, using time in going around and flying away, and focusing on AA for runs: This gets one guy out of the tank battle just as how SPAA is out of the tank battle, but the guy in the sky is usually able to gain more SP on the ground; the guy in the AA may have lost all SP and would have been out of the match if he has no AA. Or saying, a good player is being limited by someone who has been knocked out by the team.

Good thing to limit snowball effect though he can just stay on the ground, puling this back to balance issue.

And spending more time on defensives also means automatically giving up those early game advantages (I would really doubt btw. In so many games I’m having AA contacts even when flying 2min after start). Got this idea from that SPAA skill thread.

Would better have a first spawn limitation but that 50sp bt5 + 50sp i15 lineup xD

Anyways we do need <100sp ccipless helirush.

We are not playing air realistic battles either

Simply skill issue

What ? You are telling me cas is harder than spaa ?

1 Like

I’m saying SPAA is literally the most braindead easy role in the game (and even more so when you get radar and SAMs).

This issue is that SPAA is also boring and so the only people who play SPAA are.

  1. Noobs who died and don’t have the SP for a tank
  2. CAS haters (90% of CAS haters are awful at WT).
  3. People using them as light tanks, and in turn not actually performing any AA work.

Look up his stats on Statshark, he’s projecting.

1 Like