It’s close-ish, barring the filler being A-IX-12 instead of TNT. Oh, and the size of the magazine in the visual model is incorrect, it should be larger (but is yet to be corrected). Hitboxes for the magazines are claimed to be correct and larger than the visual model.
3 Likes
Sure hitbox of soyuz is few cm larger than is in game. XDD
Those are Yamatos hitboxes tho:
Not just larger but its fillying the whole of the inside of armour.
As well as its clipping thru the elevator and that is clipping thru turret.
When I get hit in turret with fire even tho missing elevator I can lit see my elevator getting orange and red in few seconds. Same with getting hit in elevator not just ammo inside elevator but outside. It just goes poof in few seconds.
https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/WtkyeKSHRDWz
Devs said “not a bug” / we are fine with yamato being unrealistic buggy and unplayable and soyuz begin op bs. Just as every other report.
Meanwhile soyuz getting hit in elevator “yes a hit” - as well as being able to survive no problem 2 / 3 ammo detonations. And other bs like sinking for hours
Well at least something got accepted. The tottaly working armor model that can get penned by cruisers XD
Devs “oh that might actually be bug huh?”
No shit?
https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/hG0pEW9mMvJe
Its exremly fast sinking also wasnt fixed at all. With over 1100 compartments and it could leight be sunk by two air torpedos sometimes in game (lost 65% buoyancy from single russian air torpedo). What a joke. IJN Musashi sunk after last attack in 4 bloody hours.
4 Likes
EDIT:
Original reply:
This link wont open for me. No idea what is going on. Test it yourself to see if it’s just me. The second bug report link worked fine though.
1 Like
Try now.
1 Like
Working 👍
1 Like
That’s just what people and tech mod say, I personally don’t believe them but :v
5 Likes
pay no attention to the hitboxes before your eyes (listen to the people abusing the op fantasy cope ship, they have YOUR interests in mind)
4 Likes
TBF thats why the snail and the emperor blessed us with the existence of the shimakaze, just to turn everyones experience in naval ec to equally bad no matter what nation youre playing and whatever op ship you might be in. The great equalizer. Hooray! (or something, if it wasnt quite sad actually that theres always gotta be something absolutely busted or possible to abuse game mechanics, well…basically only because they refuse to balance the stuff they put in the game)
1 Like
Oh there are tons of pending bug reports on the Yamato that got “accepted” ehhh which apparently just translates directly to “ignored” in russian…unfort…
Which clearly shows why “Just wait until it is on live servers, the stuff on DEV servers are subject to change, why is everyone crying about it already” is quite a risky maneuver, when everything that happens in 7 or 8 months after release is making the Yamato not explode from 2000 aa shells stored amidships instantly. BTW, you can easily get onetapped in the Yamato by the OBJ292 dart…try it in custom its hilarious. 7 kg kinetic penetrator (admittedly with enough pen to make it through your main armor belt) into your spaced out magazines -->73 000 ton ship goes “i dont wanna be here anymore” But thats probably because Japanese naval shells all have teleportation characteristics and some are just stored outside of the armored magazines but still able to explode the magazines themselves when hit, or they are schroedingers shells and are both inside the magazines and outside of the magazines at the same time or…they are covered by a whopping 11 mm of armor just above the main armor belt…
Interestingly enough by calculating the explosive mass equivalent in each of the Sojuz’ magazines which (with same amount of shells like the yamato) is much higher because obviously the Sojuz is using shells with a much more potent, mysterious sowjet explosive type. But ofc that doesnt instantly explode a sojuz, what were you thinking??? That just results in some percent of water intake and that turret not being able to shoot anymore (though i could swear some of them just kept shooting after some time but maybe ive just got ptsd from facing sojuz by now)
6 Likes
It’s almost like it has almost double the main belt’s penetration at 2km.
True, i said that it has easily enough pen to go through the main armor belt. Im still willing to bet that theres no way that a dart (after penning that massive 20° angled main belt armor), bulkheads and whatnot (that apparently are missing on the yamato) and other watertight compartments and the (i think someone stated) armored magazines which are spaced out like on no other ship, still makes that whole thing just explode instantly.
But also that doesnt rly matter, its rather just funny, since its basically irrelevant whether the APFSDS to giant battleship interaction is modelled realistically or not.
I’d be straight up embarrassed over the state of Yamato if I was the dev(s) that worked on her in warthunder, personally.
3 Likes
Not embarrassed enough to change anything meaningful about its model in the 8 months after introduction apparently. But you can ofc always just slap a second one in game.
1 Like
Between you and me; this should have been hotfixed between Dev server debut and Live server.
But developers in general seem to be allergic in portraying Yamato class accurately as Wargaming also makes her a slow, squishy behemoth.
2 Likes
Oh absolutely. Id be totally fine with it being a squishy behemoth in close ranges (where she has numerous giant disadvantages like no gun depression to hit any ships hull that is closer than 2 km, slow af gun traverse, meaningless armor) because yeah then its just a very specialized ship, meaningless for the outcome of close range rb matches, but who takes those seriously anyways? Those are won by who has the strongest and fastest coastals in his/her lineup. But it could still be effective and at least usable in a sniper role, especially in the much better EC mode.
But well not even in this role it is really usable since inaccurate ranges above 20 km with rangefinders only accurate in the km-scale, also stuff like this tends to happen:
I don’t think they care. Maybe they even get pleasure out of it? I say this, given a vehicle that may rival the Yamato in terms of terrible performance. That vehicle, being the Israeli SPYDER AIO added during the summer. From bugged radar, missiles, damage model, everything. There really needs to be a way for players to rank bugs as moderate, pressing, critical, or unable to play the game.
3 Likes
everything just getting nerfed thats russia? thats crazy
Ever heard of the Ki 102 otsu? 12 years and dozens of bug reports after its introduction, almost nothing has been done to fix it.
4 Likes
Yup, lots of bugged vehicles we are still waiting on. It’s just sad that some are released in such states that they can be perceived as being borderline unplayable.
Ahahah i even bombed one of those with a big fat IL 28 single 3000 kgs bomb… 100% to 80%… ok, it did some dmg. With 3000 kgs on your ship, that thing oneshots everything but the Soyuz.