This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
Poland has already been denied as Subtree for Germany. Besides that Poland should be it’s own tree considering how big it would be
3 Likes
Germany already has Switzerland and if they get another it would probably be Austria.
Poland would make a far better standalone tree, either as a home for other unrepresented WARSAW pact nations or as part of a WARSAW pact TT under another nation, in a similar way that Sweden is the “Scandanvia” tree with Finland, Denmark and Norway.
6 Likes
didn’t know that
Ewww-
Not only did Germany not need a sub-tree, but it already has one; it doesn’t need two(not with the tree already being made of 5+ nations). Poland can and should work as its own tree (at worst with Czechoslovakia).
Plus, like the BeNeLux, allied nations should never be sub-trees to the leader of the Axis.
6 Likes
This is one of the most disgusting justifications I’ve seen for a subtree proposal.
Your argument basically boils down to: “Germany occupied Poland, therefore Polish aircraft should go to Germany.” Do you understand how insane that sounds?
Germany and Prussia occupying Polish lands was not some harmless historical connection, it involved partitions, suppression of Polish language and culture, and centuries of attempts to erase Polish identity.
Using that history as a justification to shove Polish vehicles into Germany is beyond tone-deaf.
If you want to argue Germany needs aircraft, fine. Argue gameplay, BR gaps, balance, export ties, joint development, anything. But trying to use the history of occupation and cultural suppression as your “historical accuracy” argument is genuinely revolting.
You don’t disguist me, you disguist all of us.
14 Likes
Germany should be French sub-tree because of Napoleon.
7 Likes
Only tree I would ever even consider Poland being a subtree for is Britain or France
Britain because of extremely close ties in WW2 (Polish army pledged allegiance to both British king and 2nd Republic in exile)
France because they have been a close ally practically since Napoleonic times.
Though the best option would be independent tree, for one because both these nations already have a subtree, and second because there are still numerous historical issues.
1 Like
Also according to your logic, Russia should be a subtree for Poland because we occupied Russia/USSR many times throughout history
2 Likes
Wait, WTH, mate.
In that justification, Germany should be the Soviet Sub-tree because you lads lost a bloody war in may 1945.
5 Likes
Every nation is French subtree because Napoleon lmao