The Panther II is physically possible again… A simple turret ring enlargement is all it takes, besides, those vehicles are ALREADY in the game.
1 Like
And just assuming the turret ring could be expanded isn’t ridiculous?
They were removed and won’t come back because of exactly what I said. Your suggesting a modified hull and a new turret which makes what your suggesting completely made up so doesn’t fit the games rules.
Simply they aren’t coming back. The accurate museum piece maybe some day but not fake / impossible tanks
So we’re just forgetting this was an actual project then?
I don’t agree with those reasons. They were added in the first place so everybody should have a chance. King Panther as i like to call it isn’t impossible, Flakpanzer 341 isn’t either. The KT105 is indeed impossible in its current state, but again, it’s already in the game and players are able to use it, so everybody should at least have 1 chance to get them too.
It is impossible, even the Germans decided it was. Just accept it and move on.
There was no project to mount the long 88 on the Panther II.
You should accept the fact that a turret ring enlargement would make it possible.
1 Like
But there was a project to mount the 88mm in a Schmalturm. War Thunder Panther II is not a real design, but it’s not an impossible one. And it is Already in the game. As long as these vehicles can still be played by players you will have persons like me claiming the right to get a chance at getting them too.
1 Like
There was no plan to mount the long 88 on the Panther II. Arguing that the Panther II should get it because there was a proposal to mount it in a turret the Panther may have gotten, if it’s turret ring was enlarged but that never happened, is ridiculous.
I’m not arguing it should. I’m saying the already in-game Panther II should be able to be obtained in some way or another by new players, while correcting you on the fact that the Panther II isn’t an impossible tank, even if it is a “Fake” one. It seems like you are reading my posts sideways.
The Panther II is only possible if you combine multiple unrelated projects and increase the turret ring diameter, which never happened.
Only if i can get the P-39Q-15 (USSR) and TU-2
Thus is the goal of achieving Vehicle Ubiquity.
Everyone did have a chance. For many years.
Yes they should bring them back.Warthunder is a fantasy game now and now we have Sweden in WW2 who cares if these vehicles didnt really fight in it ?
1 Like
That’s not necessarily true, you can’t just make turret rings bigger. Not only that but there were no plans to do it either so it would be as made up as what we got already. May as well go play wot if you want made up stuff.
Given Panther 2 work seemingly stopped before August 1943, its likely that for a “what if completed” Finished prototype it would be using the Panther D turret.
Since Panther A production came to in August onwards, and Panther D turrets would likely be the available ones.
Would make for an interesting 5.7
Edit: i am aware the one the americans assembled used a Panther G turret.
There is no doubt that the implementations of the vehicles in game is fake, and if gaijin does not want fake vehicles in the game then they are free to not add any more. When you look at all the vehicles that have been added to replace the Coelian, they are about as real as the Coelian itsself, but that is by the by. These vehicles, as well as the Chinese Pt-76 and all the other TT vehicles that have been removed like the Gladiator F and S, and the Yer-2’s and Sb-2’s, should never have been removed. When a vehicle is added to the game, it should be there to stay. These vehicles are useful for lineups, even if they are not meta defining, they are absolutely beneficial to own, and there are many people who started playing the game after they were removed who never got the chance to own them. More options for the player is always good, and it is simply not fair that some people have vehicles that others have not had any chance of getting. In the same vein, they should also introduce a way to bring back the event/BP vehicles that were not couponable, such as the HMS Cadiz and Ro.57. Players will not complain about having more content available to them, and the people who are trying to gatekeep these vehicles because they already have them and want to feel special should just be ignored, it is not a valid reason to deny other players content that is already in the game.
One implementation to allow players to get access to these vehicles would be allowing people to purchase a ticket with warbonds, which allows a player to grind X amount of score over Y days, based on the vehicle the ticket is for, and after they complete the score challenge, they get access to the vehicle. This allows people to get these vehicles effectively without paying, but enourages people to engage in the battle passes and buy levels to get extra warbonds if they want. So for example, there may be in the warbond shop a new section that include all these old vehicles, and you can purchase a ticket for the Ersatz M10 for 2500 warbonds, which then requires you to complete 5 marks of distinction, each one taking 40K mission score and being available for 2 days. When the 10 days are up and if you have completed all 5 marks, you get access to the vehicle.
4 Likes
Yeah no,they got removed so they shouldnt come magically back. And Ersatz was in SL crates,imo shouldnt have been there either. Should stay exclusive like E-100 was from tournament only.