I’m somebody, who reads some history documents, and there was no plan to mount the 88mm on the Panther II.
Maybe instead of insult other players here, you should read some documents and get some knowledge first…
I’m somebody, who reads some history documents, and there was no plan to mount the 88mm on the Panther II.
Maybe instead of insult other players here, you should read some documents and get some knowledge first…
If your talking about the ships, all of them were at least laid down and classify as the equivalent of unfinished prototypes.
The only tank that could feasibly return if changed is the Panther II. 341 had no unique parts (although the mockup had a functional chassis) and the Tiger II that was removed was an amalgamation of plans that never came to be.
(I will say the Soyuz should be corrected to be one of the plans and not a mish mash of multiple).
Delete them outright
I believe it was the A or G turret.

The US mount a G turret for testing the hull, but the plan was for the Schmalturm.
I see chin on the mantlet.
I have never personally built a ship. But i dont think they would hand the dock crews material and blueprints then go “yeah so we actually have not decided what the ship will look like. Just uh…start building.”
this is false
No it wasn’t
What was then planed?
traditional panther style turret but an extra 20mm of protection generally speaking across the board. Panther F turret came later. Got to see the panther F remainants on saturday, not a good design ngl it would have been horrifically cramped, then again the base panther is kinda underwhelming in person too.
Panzer Tracts 05-4 Panther Ausf. F and Panther II
mentioned a Schmalturm design, also drawings inside
Nevermind, turned out the leaks were fake. CyberStonka confirmed it.
Shame. Where was this confirmed/debunked?
It’s a schmalturm, but an earlier version of the concept, rather than the one ultimately proposed for the Ausf F.
The Panther II was canned well before that turret design existed.


This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
Ships have separate rules, as long as a ship was laid down it’s fair game. Planned conversions are also allowed for completed ships. From what I thought, Tiger II (Sla.16) counts as an unfinished prototype iirc as it has a unique part that wasn’t reused elsewhere.
Flakpanzer 341 had no unique parts made. It got to a full scale mock-up with a standard panther chassis and a mockup turret. Panther II in game is a hybrid of different plans that don’t match either the final German plans or the post war USA conversion. 10.5cm Tiger II from what I heard is also a amalgamation of projects.
Forgive me if I’m missing something but I’m not sure why these tanks are being brought up? Ones a MBT from the 1980s, another only went to blueprints during the cold war and the last tank is Czechoslovakian.
It’s gajins rules that realistically will only allow the Panther II to return in a different configuration. If the mock-up was treated as a partial prototype, the 341 could’ve also returned.
The argument is that the two projects wouldn’t be combined because one of them was canceled, well before the other one even made it to the mock-up stage. It doesn’t make much sense to allocated resources into a dead-end, one-off prototype that doesn’t have any established production for spare parts. They would prioritize the vehicle with established production that can quickly accept the new turret and gun to make an actual impact.
You’re asking us to entertain a made-up kit bash of real projects just because it’s hypothetically, technically, theoretically possible, rather than something they expressly wanted to do. It’s basically World of Tanks logic.
I’d be down for a Panther II with the intended turret, and I could even get behind a faithfully recreated Panther F with the new turret and 88 mm L/71, but the latter simply wasn’t conceived for the former.
Don’t bother with this guy. We have explained it multiple times clearly and he just willfully ignores anything people say and repeats the same talking points. He should get banned because this is an alt account after the original was banned
I’m not too familiar with the 88mm panther, did it actually progress beyond paper/mock-up? I kinda assumed it didn’t reach partial prototype.