Please Give Us Back the Original Panther II, Flakpanzer 341 "Coelian," and Tiger II 10.5cm KwK

Bro its a game, gaijin dosent balence tanks based off what they do, they balenced them based on how players play them, for example the super pershing, it can see German Pattons, T-54s, and Conquerors when in real life it saw panzers. I understand what you mean about historical accuracy but at the end of the day its still just a game that gaijin needs to make “fun and fair”

I don’t see any fairness in the data provided.

Vehicles designed according to the World War II concept are being pitted against machines produced between 1950 and 1960—vehicles that are superior in every respect.

My guess is that the Tiger II (H) is chosen simply due to a lack of other options, and the statistics show that those who select these vehicles mostly end up losing in simulation battles.

Please answer my questions, thanks!

I was being sarcastic in that part, but like I said before gaijin balences tanks based on players who play them, thats why the tiger can see tanks produced in the 50-60’s, what i find funny about that is you can see people advocating for the Tiger II (H) to be in 7.0

As far as I can see, no one is raising any objections.

I suppose they are content with the situation.

And from what I can tell, the game seems to have found a decent balance—good or bad as it may be.

However, the problem must have arisen from the removal of the vehicles in question.

@Gurme31, I have a question to raise.

What did you mean when you said this?

Do you want to know how you can fix this whole medium tank problem really easily? Play Japan in that bracket.

Multiple 6.7 medium tank options on your team, and they are much more realistic than wanting to larp in your fictional 1946 super panther. You refer to the allied team as one country, complaining about vehicles from every nation on that side, yet discount that you have your own team with Japan and Italy, both of which with much more mobile equipment

3 Likes

People can play with whatever tools they like. Mind your own business. Don’t go around giving advice to others.

I think I’ve come up with a solution—like a true inventor!

https://share.google/jGmEa1jntI2arpV29

This vehicle seems to be the outcome of the time-wasting, multi-page debates you’ve been having.

Gaijin has presented a similar model, though the turret section differs.

Having been forced to read through dozens of your pointless arguments, I’ve reached the following conclusion:

Certain ships and vehicles have been added to the game even when no physical components were ever manufactured, or when only some parts were produced on the assembly line. Many examples have already been cited, so I won’t repeat them here.

Yet, for some reason, this particular vehicle is being dismissed as purely imaginary.

In reality, it doesn’t seem imaginary at all; it is essentially a reflection of the E-50 project—a direct continuation of the Panther II design.

Furthermore, both the hull and the components you referred to as being made of “wood” serve as evidence of the actual development work undertaken for this vehicle.

My conclusion is that this vehicle should be returned to the game, with the necessary modifications to its turret.

I know the same points will be raised again—the same things will be written—but that doesn’t really concern me.

Oh my god what are we even doing here

Sure remove the 88mm, the upgraded engine and transmission and it can come back.

which in this case do not involve a medium tank

2 Likes

We have went over this many times…
Every ship in war thunder has had some physical construction.
The grounds for addition of planes and tanks requires a unique compotent built in its intended form. It also requires hard evidence of what the design of the vehicle was supposed to be, which isn’t really a problem usually

Because it is an amalgamation of many different projects. The chances of that ever coming to fruition hypothetically are 0. And as such, it never happened in real life.

Specifically, the 88mm Panther is not valid for war thunder addition, as no compotent unique to an 88mm Panther was ever finished, let alone started.

This is twisting the truth. The E-50 was not a continuation of the Panther II, but rather a derivative of the Panther series to be more economical. This does not matter as the E-50 is not valid for addition either, as that whole program went nowhere.

As we know from Flakpanzer 341 and Ho-Ri, a wooden model is not enough for addition to war thunder.

This is very ironic because you dismiss any counterargument and just repeat the same things we have proved incorrect dozens of times.

Making this whole message I am writing useless

2 Likes

There are many other vehicles that were added as projects; they haven’t reached a final state either, yet they remain in the game.

There is no reason why this vehicle shouldn’t be added as well.

Just like the other ships and vehicles, it meets the same requirements.

So, if I understand you correctly, you’re suggesting that these engineers—working on the Schmalturm turret, the 100 mm hull, and the turret design drafted by Daimler—did all of this just as a hobby?

These are simply the result of production mandates. Why are you choosing to ignore that?

such as

They did it to stuff onto a Panther F. But you already know that. And it would be viable if that design had a physical outcome, but it didn’t. And you know that too

Yes, but the final state for the panther 2 is with a 75mm gun, are you suggesting that the germans engineers how designed with a 75mm knew less than you about the panther 2?

This is from MAN not Daimler.

Was no notification given regarding their joint work?

Please.

It wasnt “joint” work they were separated proyects they didnt even run concurently to each other, and they still these companies still compete with each other. So who are you to know better than the own engineers that designed the panther II to be mounted with a 75mm gun.

Fact of the matter is you have no proof that any 88 panther turret was built in metal, no proof it was intended for the Panther II, and no proof the Panther II was even in consideration by 1945

2 Likes

We should all pitch in and buy Irz a 1:16 model kit of the H.39 or the Sovetsky Soyuz. Extra points if the kit can be stashed in the wrong box and it says “Panther II”

1 Like