Bro… you spelled USS Northampton wrong bruh in the spreadsheet
While we’re on the topic of improving naval, could we please get a fix to kill credits? Because it’s really annoying to do the entire work of bringing a ship down to being nearly sunk all by yourself only for the secondaries of an AI ship to get the kill.
The kill should go to the person who did the most damage to the ship, not the one who got the last hit.
10 Likes
Overall very good. Exept scharnhorst should go to 7.7 too imo.
1 Like
Absolutely not. Colorado is way more 7.7 than Mutsu and Amagi which both have worse armour and no AA.
To be honest nah. IJN Kako is pretty much IJN Furutake (which yes it deserves 5.3 not 5.7) only Kako has different gun arangement, kinda akward torpedo sending and a worse AA I think 5.0 Kako and 5.3 furutaka is fair.
You’re completely forgetting to mention that both Mutsu and Amagi have a significantly higher RoF and that Amagi has an additional turret. No one would take better AA over much higher DPM.
mustsu can 1 tap ammo rack scarn same with colorado scarn cant do that unless shes close
-
Why are you bringing up Schanhorst in a discussion about Mutsu, Amagi and Colorado?
-
Scharnhorst is one of the best (if not the best) performer at its BR. There’s absolutely no reason to cry about its performance.
Yeah, would be a good idea for Talismans to be refunded if the Rank of a vehicle changes
I dont know if I entirely agree with that. I can happily go toe to toe with any Light or heavy cruiser in Belfast. But I do think it going to 6.0 in a Vacuum is rather stupid.
Suuuure nobody wants to have AA and better armour for few sec slower reload. Only when you get bombed by plane which there gonna be cold war era planes at those brs.
Nah man stuff like Colorado or Rodney are very much deserving of 7.7 even more than Mutsu or Amagi.
But id add Scharnhorst, Kronshtadt and Dunkerque class to 7.7 club too.
those that might have been a worry have moved up and it just means you need to be a little smarter about where you go and not to over-extend if you have more limited self-defence.
But in a fight between Rodney and Amagi. The Amagi definetly holds a lot of the cards
Wdym? Its quided bombs cant even pen the deck?
No thanks. Modern ships and modern planes have no place in same battle with ww2 ships.
Also what is this nonsece? 7.3 scharnhorst and 8.0 mutsu?
4 Likes
Uhhhhh so, I for one ALWAYS like having better AA 😂 All of my lineups for US and RU give strong preference to botes with better AA. NOW, I hardly have any Japan botes, so I really cannot add to this debate. BUT I just wanted to say that I personally LOVE better AA on botes.
Basically all stronk AA US botes (THOUGH I suppose it can be argued that these all still have high ROF’s lul)
RU Botes with gud AA, the Marat and Kerch do not have gud AA, but the Blag and Smelyi have awesome AA (tho again, high ROF 🤣 )
EDIT: I would just encourage everyone here to try and work together as much as possible to help allow for the best matches for Naval. We have been wanting decompression for a LONG time. So, I hope we can be as reasonable as possible, and debate ideas, and not attack each other. Cheers bote bros 🍻
1 Like
some guy said it should be 7.7 thats why
1 more round per minute and in the case of Amagi a whole additional turret is not “a few sec”, come on now.
AA is useful when there’s a plane making an attack, and you can mitigate your bad AA by sticking close to allies who have better AA than you do. Main gun DPM is useful literally all the time.
You cannot seriously think that the Dunkerque-class, which is worse in every single way to Mutsu and Amagi (which according to you aren’t 7.7 material) should be at the same BR. That’s just pure insanity.
6 Likes
Let alone the fact that on a ship like Rodney. All 3 turrets are clustered together and could be mostly surpressed by an Amagi with half decent aim. Almost impossible for the Rodney to do the same to the Amagi
Plenty of people did, because it should. It’s one of the best performing battleship in the game and it outperforms any of the BBs in the new 7.3 BR bracket. At 7.7 it just wouldn’t be as brain dead to play as it is now.
True, especially with the DPM difference.
That being said Rodney is a very strong performer currently, so I suppose we’ll have to see how it performs in its new bracket.
1 Like
it isnt though as one fire almost instantly ammo racks you and your guns dont do very much damage to larger boats like Colorado