Nuclear Escalation - Sim Battles: Feedback and Suggestions

Hey guys! I just made this thread so we can share our feedback and suggestions with the devs. Feel free to express your thoughts on the new mode and what could be done to improve it further!

It’s important to show the devs that SIM has an active player base and the potential to grow and expand. It’s been ages since we last got some SIM love, so let’s not waste this opportunity!

Let’s make sure we provide useful, constructive feedback!

4 Likes

Give the mode standard rewards. This is the exact same thing as RB NE, yet for some reason we are recieving useful action… because we play sim? Truly i can’t fathom how often and seemingly forced Gaijin dropping of the ball on sim is.

This is the same mode, iust forced into first person. There is 0 reason RB and sim versions should have different rewards. The same possibilities of exploits exists in both modes.

We have waited years for literally anything to happen for sim. And when we finally do, somehow some way the devs still show us that additions to sim are nothing more then a formality with 0 actual care for the sim community (besides HMD, MFD, and cockpit devs you guys absolutely rock)

11 Likes

fully agree. And as you mentioned, I still cannot understand why they put so much effort into giving us amazing cockpits, HUD’s, MFD’s etc, but cannot work some hours to tweak SIM modes, add new maps (why the hell we still don’t have Falklands in SIM ??) etc. I can’t understand this Gaijin’s contradiction…

2 Likes

Cockpits, MFDs, and HMDs are good for videos thematics and in the last one’s case are involved in gameplay even in 3RDPV. Everything else is side effort at best to give the thinnest veneer of simulation offerings, but the bean counters refuse to let them take the minorly higher risk of less immediate earnings by doing things that purposefully benefit simulation players.

We gotta keep the pressure on them to adjust and produce things CORRECTLY for sim, not just afterthought additions after dogging AB/RB stuff.

1 Like

I bumped some old thread before u made this one, so imma just repost my feedback here.

I played the 8.7-9.7 bracket today and it is abhorrent, absolutely unplayable.
They decided that Hawk/SA-2 and Phalanx tier Shilka/VADS that shoots down bombs and missiles without breaking a sweat is a good match against things like F-84’s or MiG-15’s. Few things even have working RWRs here not to mention guided munitions or ARMs.

The only thing I saw doing good in 3-4 matches were premium J-22’s with their cruise missiles that are at 9.0 for some reason, sometimes F-117’s if the weather allowed.

This living battlefield is such a great potential but it is entirely squandered by Gajin hellbent on ignoring player feedback and maintaining that GBAD must be ridiculously overpowered. I will be trying higher BR brackets but I don’t expect any major improvement.

The OG event gave me hope, hope that has been drowned in frustration over how bad They fumbled it.

4 Likes

Useful action system needs to go. Period. There is no point in playing this mode with the broken aa and a million RWR warnings if I don’t get rewarded for more than 1 kill. Sim is hard to play and even harder to do well in, so it should feel rewarding.

4 Likes

Played a few matches, I was really excited to hear about this mode coming to sim. Tried multiple brackets, and already seeing the problems of 2 countries going against the rest. Naturally, the ai in RB mode need to pose a threat, and you have the situational awareness in 3rd person and with markers to deal with that threat. In sim mode, its extremely overpowering, and even if you can deal with it, only some weapons can actually take out a sam site. I tried with the f15e, and it has no ARMs, and was rather unsuccessful with gbu-53s because of their limited range. 5 Jsows might get 1 or 2 ai targets max, not sure why it gets 5 and f18c (late) gets 8.

Also tried the lowest bracket with the yak-39, decided to go for naval targets. I was successful, with 2 targets destroyed, and I check the leaderboard - 20 points. There isn’t even a counter for naval targets destroyed. With 20 points I can expect a whole lot of rewards with this sim based system. Tried to attack a convoy, got shredded by a moving m163 while I was low, flying at mach, and maneuvering around. Woohoo.

Imagine spending a decade playing a game intermittently, spending probably thousands of dollars, and the devs completely stop supporting the mode you play. Honestly feel ashamed that I even felt excited.

5 Likes

First of all, it is very much appreciated that now also Sim is tested with the Nuclear Escalation mechanic. It’s actually a bigger thing than many may think, as it sends a long hoped for signal to the Sim community that their beloved game mode is not forgotten!

I haven’t yet had the chance to play more than one short match, but already some things become very evident:

  1. Battlefield size and density

Even the larger of the two currently available maps is about 2.5x denser than a normal Sim EC match, meaning 2.5x more assets (mission targets, ground battles, convoys), and for the smaller map it s even 5x as dense.

On one hand it’s good to have more targets, but here the density is just too high - especially considering the fact that literally all of them are under powerful, multilayered AA cover.

  1. Overpowered AA

As mentioned under 1, AA is overpowered, especially at the lowest bracket where the player has literally nothing to counter those powerful missiles he in many cases doesn’t even know are fired at him.

Also, convoy SPAAG’s are extremely powerful and accurate - and issue already well known from Sim EC.

While both those two points are not that big of an issue per se, the fact that all this is taking place on such small, dense battlefields at the same time means one can practically not fly a 360° without being under constant threat of enemy AA, with the threat being imminent already a mere few seconds after taking off.

  1. BR brackets

The BR brackets are very poorly chosen, with no logical separation between aircraft of different capabilities: F-5E’s with no look-down capability, no IFF and only 2 rear-aspect IR-AAM’s have to go against Fox-3 equipped aircraft with vastly superior avionics exclusively, and things like that.

Different arrangement of those BR brackets could lead to much more reasonable gameplay for many aircraft that are now matched against extremely superior aircraft, and thus make currently no sense to be played.

  1. Economy

Not even necessary to mention this yet again: Sim EC has a Useful Action system, because this should supposedly work best to counter the abuse of lobby creation to farm illegally.

For this game mode however - literally at least at the moment still just RB without markers - that economy makes no sense, but it makes a lot of people shy away from even trying to contribute to this test!

  1. Current conclusion

General gameplay is very fast paced and “arcadey”, especially compared to Sim EC, where more detailed flight planning and target engagement is the norm.

In Nuclear Escalation on the other hand, it seems like it’s mainly focused on targets of opportunity, and you engage or defend depending on whatever pops int your “bubble”. Battles are dense and fast paced, making planning of deep strikes quite unecessary or even useless.

Those points mean that the whole SB-NE mode really feels (in its current iteration) like nothing else than a marker-less RB-NE, not using the strengths of Sim, but having the same shortcomings/differences as RB, and challenges of Sim, at least when seen through the Sim player’s eyes.

8 Likes

Or to sum it up: The mode per se works, but has the same issues as the RB version, with the added issue of very punishing economy.

Still: It’s fun to play! = )

3 Likes

after playing this mode for a good bit here’s what I feel like needs to be adjusted/changed or added, I will be including things that can go to both sim escalation and rb escalation with examples of possible fixes for some

MATCHMAKING

“Map Selection”
(rb/sb) Please give us the ability to choose if we want to play on southeastern city, tropical coast or both, being forced to play one or the other without a choice hurts the matchmaking since for people like me who don’t like southeastern city have to constantly go through a state of leaving and joining matches while dealing with the crew timer.

“Crew Lock”
(rb/sb) please remove the crew lock timer, I should not be punished for leaving a match that i just joined that is either almost over or on a map I dislike this not only also hurts the matchmaker but it also hurts queue times and adds frustration because if a group of people don’t spawn and leave they get affected by the crew lock and people who are not in crew lock are in a queue with few people since the people with the crew lock are no longer in rotation for the duration.

ECONOMY

“Useful Actions”
(sb) the useful actions system that currently exists handicaps the mode to an extreme degree, if a person is doing very well and they are racking up ground or air units their compensation is severely limited due to the useful actions system capping their rewards once they reach the limit in game, the way i feel like this can be fixed is by greatly increasing the limit to reward taking risks in certain engagements while at the same time having a cap to punish players who may try to take advantage and abuse the rewards.

“Munition Multipliers”
(rb/sb) The current state of escalation is very guided munition focused even at the lower tiers, this makes aircraft that are either limited in guided munition variety or lack guided munitions as a whole lag behind aircraft that have more variety of guided munitions, the way this can be fixed is by giving a multiplier for destroying certain unit/objective with a certain munition, this can give more of an incentive to use the aircraft that lack huge payloads or specific guided munitions.
(example: Kunomi killed S-300 Radar with MK-82 = destruction reward + 2x multiplier for sl/rp)

GROUND UNITS

(sb) “Fog Of War”
the current spotting system of nuclear escalation is very awkward and does not work well in the concept of simulator battles since you have to rely on sensors and very vague knowledge of where they are, this nine out of ten times will lead to searching for unnecessarily long times and lead to you accidentally flying over them without ever knowing leading to you getting shot down, the way this possibly could be adjusted is like this.
(Example 1: “if a unit is in the fov of a tgp/tv cam within a certain distance they will be spotted”)
(Example 2: “if enemy ground units come within a certain range of allied units they will be spotted”)

(sb/rb) “AA”
anti air currently is very very strong and feels very inconsistent to fight against, there have been many cases when i would be launched on and chaff will work fine and a few minutes later it will feel like it does nothing combining the fact that a lot of standoff weapons are very easily shot down if they are not things like a jsow or a gbu-39, this makes aa frustrating to play against because you have to spam off weapons without the intent of sparing, this leads to the occasional situation where you will actually spam off more weapons than needed making a2g combat feel incredibly inconsistent as a whole.

(sb/rb) “Unit Density/Amount”
The amount of ground units that exist in match makes things extremely overwhelming, this is due to the fact that the long range aa can pretty much launch on you the second you take off, this leads to aircraft with powerful rwr’s getting completely saturated with unnecessary pings and warnings making stuff confusing and overwhelming which really hurts the experience, a way this can be fixed is by decreasing the amount of ground units or spreading them out on a larger area which can be done on a larger map.

UI

(sb) “Cockpit RWR”
Most radar warning receivers that have the ability to detect and identify the radar source just comes up as unknown so when using in cockpit elements you feel situationally gimped due to the lack of info while at the same time feeling overwhelmed due to the extreme amounts of stuff being relayed to you

FINAL THOUGHTS
This mode has a lot of potential and can really elevate sim battles to a new level, people who have never played sim began playing just to experience not only escalation in sim but sim battles as a whole, if things are implemented and changed properly this could bring a whole new audience to sim battles and possibly war thunder as a whole but the issues that are really hurting this mode is preventing that from happening and is truly a brick wall that needs to be torn down

1 Like

Making this event in the middle of the week is dooming it to fail, I can’t get a match.

Leaving the abhorrent “useful actions” system in place if this is ever permanently implemented will also be dooming the mode to fail.

3 Likes

Great poins have been made thus far. I will also share some of my impressions.

1 - Maps are too small for SIM
Nuclear escalation works fine in RB, but we need a bigger map for SIM. We should have the option to spawn close to the battle, or pick far back airfields (maybe with a middle ground option too).

This could help with some situational awareness problems previously stated by other posters.

2 - Too high enemy density
There are too many enemies packed into clusters that are too close to one another. Since we mostly rely on sensors and our own eyeballs mk1, it’s really hard to identify and engage ground targets.

I think the map should be bigger, with ground target clusters spread farther apart from each other.

3 - AA is too powerful for SIM
As things stand, AA systems are far too powerful. I’m a big fan of realism, and I understand that these systems are genuinely fearsome and that aircraft have to be extremely careful when operating in areas where they are present IRL.

However, their ability to intercept virtually every munition launched at them, including ARMs, makes gameplay frustrating and arguably isn’t entirely realistic either.

IMO, some kind of chance for interception failure should be implemented. For example, AA systems could have an 80% chance of intercepting large, slow-moving munitions and a 40% chance of intercepting smaller, faster-moving ones (just an example. These need not be the final numbers).

If the playerbase or the devs find this solution unnacceptable, perhaps saturation strikes should be easier and more effective, even if Gaijin doesn’t change MCM’s interception rate of 100%.

4 Likes

The feedback already in this thread is solid, and I largely agree with it. The point I most want to reinforce is SAM capability against air-to-air missiles, and by extension the iron dome meta.

Fox 3 RCS appears to be modeled too high. In flight I have had R-77-1s intercepted by Patriot simply because the missile passed through the battery’s air-defense bubble. I have also seen Fox 3s shot down by ITO launchers when fired near an enemy airfield in normal air sim. That should not be a routine outcome.

It also feeds the iron dome meta. Outside of ideal geometry, Fox 3s should not be easy radar targets. No air force trains pilots to shoot down incoming Fox 3s as a standard tactic, because those missiles are generally too small and too hard to track for a reliable firing solution. The realistic response is notching, countermeasures, and geometry, not a hard-kill shot. SAM systems face the same problem. Outside of perfect setups, they should not reliably detect a Fox 3, let alone hold a track good enough to engage it.

To reduce iron doming and make SAM interactions feel more consistent, especially in Nuclear Escalation, air-to-air missile RCS needs to be lowered.

4 Likes

I’m getting REALLY sick of queueing for 10 minutes just to join an ongoing match that ends in 5 minutes. what a waste of a booster and time. make the matches start with like 8 people on each team, not 15. and increase ticket count

So sad :'-(