First of all, it is very much appreciated that now also Sim is tested with the Nuclear Escalation mechanic. It’s actually a bigger thing than many may think, as it sends a long hoped for signal to the Sim community that their beloved game mode is not forgotten!
I haven’t yet had the chance to play more than one short match, but already some things become very evident:
- Battlefield size and density
Even the larger of the two currently available maps is about 2.5x denser than a normal Sim EC match, meaning 2.5x more assets (mission targets, ground battles, convoys), and for the smaller map it s even 5x as dense.
On one hand it’s good to have more targets, but here the density is just too high - especially considering the fact that literally all of them are under powerful, multilayered AA cover.
- Overpowered AA
As mentioned under 1, AA is overpowered, especially at the lowest bracket where the player has literally nothing to counter those powerful missiles he in many cases doesn’t even know are fired at him.
Also, convoy SPAAG’s are extremely powerful and accurate - and issue already well known from Sim EC.
While both those two points are not that big of an issue per se, the fact that all this is taking place on such small, dense battlefields at the same time means one can practically not fly a 360° without being under constant threat of enemy AA, with the threat being imminent already a mere few seconds after taking off.
- BR brackets
The BR brackets are very poorly chosen, with no logical separation between aircraft of different capabilities: F-5E’s with no look-down capability, no IFF and only 2 rear-aspect IR-AAM’s have to go against Fox-3 equipped aircraft with vastly superior avionics exclusively, and things like that.
Different arrangement of those BR brackets could lead to much more reasonable gameplay for many aircraft that are now matched against extremely superior aircraft, and thus make currently no sense to be played.
- Economy
Not even necessary to mention this yet again: Sim EC has a Useful Action system, because this should supposedly work best to counter the abuse of lobby creation to farm illegally.
For this game mode however - literally at least at the moment still just RB without markers - that economy makes no sense, but it makes a lot of people shy away from even trying to contribute to this test!
- Current conclusion
General gameplay is very fast paced and “arcadey”, especially compared to Sim EC, where more detailed flight planning and target engagement is the norm.
In Nuclear Escalation on the other hand, it seems like it’s mainly focused on targets of opportunity, and you engage or defend depending on whatever pops int your “bubble”. Battles are dense and fast paced, making planning of deep strikes quite unecessary or even useless.
Those points mean that the whole SB-NE mode really feels (in its current iteration) like nothing else than a marker-less RB-NE, not using the strengths of Sim, but having the same shortcomings/differences as RB, and challenges of Sim, at least when seen through the Sim player’s eyes.