Malaya has no business being in the Japanese tech-tree

image

We’ve been a crown colony since the 1700’s, better known as the Straits Settlements or British Malaya.

Our Malay, Chinese, Punjabs, Indians, Baba Nyonya, and Indigenous boys served loyally in military service to the crown. We were absorbed into their customs and embraced their language, legal and commerce traditions. Our people proudly engaged in their institutions and academia.

image
An infantry company of the Malay Regiment awaiting orders to ‘Advance to Contact’ during range and field exercises, Malaya, 1941.

Our judicial, academic, and governing institutions are all adapted from the British. We were shaped as a constitutional monarchy in homage to them, also partly to accommodate the local crown/agong - Malay monarchies. The Malayan dollar even had the British monarch’s face on it during its early years, and we used the pound sterling for a long while before the British governorate created our own monetary reserves.

Not to mention the Nepalese “Gurkhas” that served alongside us. Malayan regiments have always been under the crown’s service. We worked closely with ANZAC forces many times against the Japanese in WW2 and the subsequent Malayan emergencies.

image
A British soldier is winched up by a Westland Wessex helicopter during an operation in Borneo, August 1964

British Governorate Office circa 1800’s

Image 2:
image
Image 3:

British Governorate Office Circa 1900’s

I don’t understand the significance of Japan here. No one in Kuala Lumpur speaks Japanese, the colonial office, the central market, the city, the community, and the economy were not built by the Japanese but by the locals and the British. Without agreements between the Malayan states, including Singapore, which later left the federation, there would be no unified entity called Malaysia.


Market Square, in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

Three-storey buildings featuring British colonial architecture with ornate details on the facades.

The Malayan Emergency

image
Avro Lincoln Bomber A73-33 of No. 1 Squadron RAAF on a bombing mission over the Malayan jungle. Two 500 pound bombs can be seen falling from the aircraft.


Avro Lincoln of No. 57 Squadron, Royal Air Force, at RAF Tengah, Singapore. Aerial warfare was a key part of British military strategy to defeat communist guerrillas during the Malayan Emergency. News of non-combatants being killed by RAF saturation bombing campaigns sparked heated debates in the British House of Commons over the military tactics employed by the British as part of Britain’s counterinsurgency strategy.

We’ve been a natural ally to Australia and NZ, and we’re among the few democracies in the region. We served in each other’s interest, protecting the dominion throughout countless conflicts. There are men from the Malayan regiment who served alongside ANZAC forces in the “confrontation” war who are still alive today. Their efforts contributed greatly at halting Indonesian incursions on British Borneo.

ANZAC Day should also be celebrated here in Kuala Lumpur.

image

Malaya doesn’t have a historical relationship with Japan.

My theory on Indonesian approval of Japan wartime history:

The Imperial forces were celebrated in Indonesia, perhaps due to the attitude of the local Batavians, and this is a reference to the unnecessary cruelty and brutal policies which were pursued by the Dutch in the “East Indies”. The region served as an extraction colony for the VoC, and the policing imposed on the locals was nothing short of apartheid.

It’s no surprise how the Japanese were celebrated as “liberators” there, at least before they committed mass depredations as the zeerovers did.

Let’s take a little respite from the heavy discussion with a little treat ~


HMS Malaya departing New York after repairs, 9 July 1941

3 Likes

India should not be in british tree either, but here we are

4 Likes

I feel the main issue of moving Malaysia to the UK is that they would get a third subtree on top of the recurring Canadian and Australian vehicles in addition to the domestic stuff.

That said it is surprising that Japan got Malaysian vehicles considering the insane lineup that’s now possible.

2 Likes

Exactly, and the solution would be a merging of the British Commonwealth League of Nations as their own unique sub-tree, with prominent ANZAC representation; no one should be left behind.

In regards to Japan, they should receive their own vehicles, R2Y2’s or whatever…

It should be there. While the Straits Settlements were dubbed as the “Crown Jewel” Of the East and enjoyed the luxuries of uplifted economic conditions. India suffered from periods of severe stagnation. They sacrificed the most from British extraction policies for the sake of uplifting the wartime colonial economy of Britain, they’ve supported the crown in more ways than England could repay them. At least they should be recognised by that. There’s no replacing them.

Fyi I’m a national of said nation, hence the descriptive reference to “we” in a collective sense. It’s not intended to be that way ^-^', the only form of rp I do irl is in board games and DnD sesh. They are fun as hell!

Why post it here out of all categories?

1 Like

56 nations would be very big for a subtree. Keep in mind the tied largest subtree nations Hungary and Finland have 44 vehicles each (though this includes unobtainable stuff in Germany) and very much still underrepresented even when not counting copy paste.

I feel the Commonwealth realms could genuinely work as a separate tree as it would have enough with Canada, New Zealand and Australia having vehicles all the way up to top tier while the smaller islands can get their rep via the patrol boats.

2 Likes

Ah, how do I republish this to the appropriate category? I wasn’t aware, quite new to the forums.

I have a feeling it would either be in Machinery of war or Game discussion.

I believe the mods can move incorrectly placed topics on the right one.

1 Like

The reason is likely because Britain has many better options than Malaya

2 Likes

I see… ^-^’

You’re Malarian?

1 Like

You can ping a moderator and they’ll move it to the right category. You can try Stona, he’s the one doing that usually

1 Like