Legitimate suggestions being rejected

I know others have experienced this.

Legitimate suggestions being rejected before even being put up for discussion.
It’s not like all suggestions approved to be in the suggestion thread get approved to be forwarded on to devs…

Most of the time I see 0 conflict with the guidelines.
If a suggestion isn’t worthy for the thread then there should be feedback as to why and how they can change it to make it work. Not just disappear with no trace unless you remembered to screen shot.

There seems to be a personal vendetta or power flexing going on as perfectly legitimate and crucial suggestions regarding important topics get rejected all the time.
I believe there needs to be some moderating of the moderators.

Many of these suggestions are in hopes of obtaining relevant data regarding the feedback on these topics.

Please post/discuss your rejected legitimate suggestions here.

3 Likes

One of many examples:

uhh, okay… this suggestion is not up to standards

i can help with that.

try to elaborate and make a dew diagrams. make it seem like you put effort into your suggestion

for example, heres one of my suggestions

also you can always contact the suggestion mods and they will help you make a good one

Shall I compare it to others that have been accepted?
I’m sure you can do that on your own without someone holding your hand.

Your suggestion is not an example of a failed suggestion.

2 lines is… just not upto standards for such suggestions bro
trust me i learnt the hard way

1 Like

Trust me “Bro” I have written overly detailed suggestions that got rejected, simplifying it did not work. Whilst seen simple “2lines” accepted.

then i can only say ask the mods

Doing it publicly.
So that everyone can benefit from the information being publicly obtainable.


How can he do that… if he’s banned? Eh?
If he’s the one, then there’s no way they can ban him, right?
Some sort of a miracle…

Suggestions based around mechanics aren’t really comparable to vehicle suggestions.

Example of how I do suggestions


Note the date I submitted it.

Note today’s date.

3 Likes

maybe not, but my point was to put more effort into it
which you did.
he didnt

1 Like

wot?

If it’s a in-game mechanic as you attached a image for a proposal for a suggestion of changing and amling the new aiming system for naval arcade battles an optional thing,

You should think about a good reason, how it should be implemented and why you think, it’s a very complicated and I try not to suggest nothing regarding game mechanics as it tend to take more time to formulate a thread rather than a vehicle.

You can DM a suggestion mod and they will tell you the reason for denial and provide you with a copy of your suggestion to if needed.

Ive been waiting over a month for 1 of my 2 suggestions to be looked at.

1 Like

NGL that sounds deliberate as they reject mine within 30 mins.