The funny thing is that K2 PL dosent have a place to go to rn, as much as it sounds good to Germany its rather obvious is not going to germany nor anyone, it’s probably gonna be in it’s own TT, also ur not one to talk about it when the same was done with the canadian 2A4M but at least the 2A4M did have an originary tech tree it could go at
1 Like
Yeah, no.
It should be in german tech tree as polish vehicle. Poland is currently using this tank. Also, poland is setting up factories to produce K2 tank domestically
There is practically no reason for Polish stuff to come to Germany though, with exceptions to their Leopards as an example.
Independent Polish concept is in many aspects a far superior idea.
3 Likes
There is not enough tanks for independent tech tree.
Only a subtree would be possible. But looking at polish history, one subtree in one nation is not reallly viable.
I mean, 1-2 era tanks, like TKS, 7TP, 9TP (maybe even 14TP prototype) should go to british tech tree -
it’s only logical for polish ww2 tanks to fight german and russian tanks, as poland was invaded by both of them in 1939.
for era 3-4 we do not really have anything new. - only british machines, shermans that were used by polish, as well as some T-34s.
for post war era we can put polish subtree to russian tech tree, as poland were occupied by ussr and only had what they were allowed by ussr. So T55s, BMPs, BRDMs, 2S6, PT76, T72 - copy pastes.
Maybe SKOT could be a fun addition. Or T55AM Merida - polish version of t55.
Next, we come to modern era, when Poland finally gain independence. Poland joined NATO and fits more into german tech tree, as Poland was acquiring Leopard tanks. We currently have polish Leo in game.
We could also have PT91 Twardy - polish version of T72 with thermals, KTO Rosomak as TT IFV, and maybe KRAB spg, wihch is basically polish VIDAR.
And now, Poland got K2 tanks (also building factories to produce it in Poland) and M1A2 abrams.
So yeah, there are couple machines that could be added, but not enough material for full independent tech tree.
I largely disgree.
At every rank at least something Polish can be found.
While there is clear foreign influence everywhere bar the lowest tiers, Poland still has quite of lot of interesting modifications for mid tier and beyond.
Think of their BWP modifications as an example of good tier V and VI additions. Sopel is another such example.
Additionally, this is an exclusively ground oriented view.
Poland is one of the only countries still not represented in game to a large extent that had a decent aviation history.
They would have unique aircraft throughout all tiers bar the very top as well as they would have a unique helicopter in the W-3.
Especially if combined with Czechoslovakia it would make for a very potent and quite unique tree with a good amount of longevity for the future.
2 Likes
poland at the very least is a better independed tree then switzerland, as well with the potential for sub trees if necesary, which switzerland doesnt realy have
3 Likes
What can you find for era 3 and 4? We do not want a copy paste with white and red checkerboard on turret
buddy give it up, poland is a no for germany as much as u want it.
Did u look at recent sub tree additions or the coming one? Do you seriously think gajin cares one bit about copy paste? every tree from now on is pretty much copy paste at one point or completly in some sense
1 Like
So you do not have anything for era 3 or 4, just as i thought.
Besides, gaijin will not add anything polish to the game anyways, since “2022 situation”
i am one of main german guys here on the forum, i dont realy care about poland, and poland has nothing to do with the 2022 situation either
besides that genius the hell is era 3 or 4, there is no explosive reactive armor 3 or 4.
At least use the right words u problem mean tier 3 or 4, or u mean the age 3 or 4 which makes even less sense
1 Like
poland has ah 64s, arbams and f-16 with your definition poland should go to the US rather then germany as well just saying
1 Like
i don’t really care about your main nation.
And yeah, poland have a lot to do with 2022 situation. gaijin is russian company, and russians now do not really like poles, because of poland involvement in 2022 situation
So, going back to topic - we ALREADY have Leopard 2PL in game as TT in german tech tree.
It is only logical, to put K2 tank into german tech tree as polish tank - SAME AS Leo2PL.
just as much involvement as any other nato nation
and like 3 polish vehicles in the UK tree, meaning poland should go to the UK.
Seriously u brought not a single argument for poland to go to germany yet. Every argument you brought another nation would have more claim to it
1 Like
And what exactly is the issue with one or two tiers being sub-par when the rest of the tree is good and also has unique aviation and heli support?
Should France not belong in game because they have the same issues at the same tiers?
1 Like
You are really not reading here.
Your argument about 3 polish vehicles in UK tree? What WW2 tanks have to do with K2? Or maybe lets put it to sovied tree, because poland have couple polish decals in soviet tree.
We already got polish top tier tank - leopart 2 PL in german tech tree. It IS there. You can look it up.
Only logical place in game right now to bring SECOND polish top tier tank is THE SAME TREE as leo2pl. So then YOU WOULD BE ABLE to form a lineup with 2 POLISH tanks.
I mean, really, it’s not rocket science dude
i can destroy that whole argument quickly. The canadian leo 2a4m can premium is coming to germany, with your argument it would need to go to UK to be played with the canadian 11.7 top tier spaa ADATS, which is not the case.
Gajin does not care for line ups its easy as that, seriously pls just do some research beforehand
1 Like
We are talking about polish K2 tank, not canadian 2a4m.
Do not mix it up.
Do you really not see any logical error you are making?
simple case:
You have top tier modern polish tank in game in GERMAN tech tree.
You are adding second top tier modern polish tank into the game.
Which tree do you add it in?
1 Like
You have top tier modern Canadian tank in game in UK tech tree.
You are adding second top tier modern canadian tank into the game.
Which tree do you add it in?
Straight back to you , exact same situation
Yes, canadian tank should go to uk tree
What are you even arguing about…