How To Fix Nuclear Escalation - My Short Thesis

They could add AI aerial targets such as AWACS, tankers, cargo, helicopters, drones etc.

1 Like

Yeah but that would be useless since the long range spaa would destroy the missiles before they reach the awacs etc…

Better to make the games last longer by making the SP for nukes higher which would make players to engage in ground or PVP gameplay in order to earn that… and to top that off 20% less spaa’s covering convoys or make them more realistic to not have 100% succes in intercepting and it will be fine and dandy

So you just lobotomize the SAMs so they can’t shoot down ordinance…?

More realism =/= better gameplay all the time, we all know this too well. Look at top tier jets being a MCM fest, or prior eras of Helicopters prematurely detonating incoming SAMs with unguided rocket pods or even still today using their guided ordinance.

IDGAF if its unrealistic, all forms of MCM from any platform are just lazy, bad gameplay.

why are you jumping into hardcore conclusions? nothing realistic in saclos spaa intercepting mach 2 missiles xD

MCM who cares about that in air rb when we are talking about NE in which that case is less obvious and people don’t use that as often…

Sams should have less of a chance to intercept munitions ships as well but not lobotomize because you jump into a conclusion…

Make the game more fun for multirole playstyle instead of making people go pvp because ground pounding is hardcore for nations without a big set of fnf missiles.

1 Like

Because I see people effectively complaining about two flavors of the exact same problem?

Jet A vs Jet B when MCM exists always favors Jet A if Jet A has more ready-to-fire missiles.

Helicopter A vs SAM B when ATGM-vs-SAM or Heli Rocket Wall-vs-SAM existed/still exists always favors the platform with more ready-to-fire missiles to out-slugfest the other.

Hence my scorched-earth solution - just nuke all of it as its impossible to make into balanced, nevermind fun, gameplay.

this is nuclear escalation no helicopers xD

Change topics my dude nobody is talking about mcm in NE …

How my argument relates to NE is simple - the SAMs are oppressive and they swat down the very weapons designed explicitly to kill them. They shoot you through mountains. They open fire with their radars off due to being omniscient AI that sees you regardless.

Hence my proposal, linking to identical problems in other modes, of making ordinance not trigger other ordinance entirely so ARMs always work to kill the damn SAMs.

MCM in NE is not the topic since it is AI vs Player not PvP …

Go bant on other topics exclusive for PvP MCM not here in which we don’t have that problem in NE …

When russians had more missiles then USA and MCM was there nobody complained but now that USA has the top dog suddenly MCM is a problem… well is it a problem? For me no…

I don’t fly high and drop all missiles I fly low and go into medium range battlles in which MCM is far less usable…

1 Like

I’m just looking at it from the simple fact that if weapons specifically designed to counter SAMs don’t work due to idiotic game mechanics enabling blatantly unrealistic shit, you remove the unrealistic mechanic altogether.

ARMs are supposed to be small and fast enough that SAMs intercepting them is a fool’s errand. Yet ingame the SAMs are omniscient gods that can do things under AI control no player operating the same SAM could hope to do.

What’s wrong with simply wanting weapons to operate as they damn well should?

you are talking about pvp MCM in general and just hitchhiking on ARM vs SPAA to try and make your point which is nothing close to what is happening right now in NE

Why do people keep thinking that increasing the focus on PVP just turns the game into air RB with respawns complete with air RB’s problems? It’s like everyone responding to my post forgets that 1: the problem with air RB is the tiny maps combined with a kill all players victory condition making playing fighters the only viable option and 2: that I address this problem further in my original post by suggesting a variety of ground based strike objectives required to win the match thus making a2a pvp an aspect of defending your objectives but not the way to win, thus solving the air rb problem.

1 Like

TBF there was some talk about reducing long range AA or moving it further back so it didn’t cover the entire map. As a result it could make aerial objectives more reasonable.

I like how the OHP is currently able to shoot down 4 harpoons in 5 seconds with just the 76mm gun and whatever shot down my sea eagle in the attached screenshot, very cool gaijin.

because even the NE maps are too small? You take off and already are in range to fire off all your fnf fox 3’s making anyone trying to go ground pounding and playing the objective go defensive with you and 15 spaa’s targeting him? that makes the ground pounding useless and much easier to get missiles of score a kill or two and make more profit? again we are talking here stricly on nuclear eslcalation nto air rb…

1 Like

Why do ppl like this insist on ruining NE

It’s hardly them ruining it as much as the mode already being ruined. It wouldn’t be dissimilar to Gaijin just leaving GRB map spots completely unrestricted.

Your proposal would only bring back the climb to win meta. It amounts to Air RB with fewer players spread over a larger area. Nuclear escalation has no purpose existing if it is too similar to classic Air RB. If they wanted to focus on PvP and air superiority, they already have classic Air RB and classic Air Arcade. The infinite respawns of nuclear escalation would go a long way to address the issue of snowballing in classic Air RB and classic Air Arcade. Yet, that change alone is not sufficient for a different game mode like nuclear escalation to retain minimum relevancy. A change like that would be more meaningful as an improvement to classic Air RB and classic Air Arcade.

With sufficiently enjoyable PvE targets, it won’t matter whether a target is AI or a player as long as it is enjoyable. The issue with nuclear escalation is that minimum PvE difficulty is being provided by PvE vehicles that embody mobility too dissimilar from the vehicles being controlled by players. Air vehicles are too dissimilar in mobility to SPAA to a point where it becomes impossible to present minimum difficulty for careless players without making the players into fodder regardless of skill.

Combat between vehicles too dissimilar in mobility fundamentally does not offer the dynamic relation between player positioning and outcome that is offered by combat between vehicles of more similar mobility. SPAA doesn’t move nearly as quickly as an air vehicle and they cannot move in 3 dimensions.

With less comparable mobility, a given period of movement from a vehicle will have a looser relation to vulnerability. With a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness or caution in positioning will have less of an effect on said vehicle’s level of risk. The more mobile vehicle can be more careless without it affecting their level of risk to a vehicle that cannot move to take advantage of said carelessness. For the less mobile vehicle, with a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness by the less mobile vehicle will have less effect on their exposure to risk. With a larger gap in mobility, combat outcomes are more uniform regardless of player skill.

With the game needing to present a minimum level of difficulty for careless players, a larger gap in mobility will make the game uniformly punishing for careless players and skilled players alike.

Combat between SPAA and air vehicles presents a fundamental problem.

With a game that needs to maintain a minimum difficulty of progression for careless players, SPAA based PvE difficulty will make rewards from the game mode uniformly limited for careless players and skilled players alike. SPAA based PvE difficulty compromises access to rewards and said SPAA based difficulty is not fundamental what makes Nuclear Escalation unique from classic air battle.

In a prior thread, I spoke in greater detail specifically on the issue of combat between vehicles too dissimilar in mobility. Helicopters MITL needs a rebalanced or Removed from the game - #472 by kevintloney

As for the nuclear aspect of nuclear escalation, such potent weapons loosen the relation between player vulnerability, how much care was put into a player’s movement, and the risk a player poses to the enemy. Nuclear weapons diminish how tightly player action relates to match outcome. With the game needing to present a minimum level of difficulty for careless players, nuclear weapons will make the game uniformly punishing for careless players and skilled players alike. With a game that needs to maintain a minimum difficulty of progression for careless players, nuclear weapons will make rewards from the game mode uniformly limited for careless players and skilled players alike. Nuclear weapons are the least interesting aspect of the game mode and they compromise access to rewards.

A future version of the game mode with greater density of meaningful PvE will allow for Gaijin to eventually remove nuclear weapons to ensure game outcomes are more consistently attached to player input. PvE aircraft with their more similar mobility to the player will tighten the relation between player action and match outcome. PvE aircraft are the solution to the problems of PvE in nuclear escalation. With the game needing to present a minimum level of difficulty for careless players, PvE aircraft will make the game less punishing for minimally careful players. With a game that needs to maintain a minimum difficulty of progression for careless players, PvE aircraft will make rewards from the game mode more available for minimally careful players. In a prior thread, I spoke in greater detail about how PvE aircraft are the solution to the problems of classic air battles and subsequently how PvE aircraft will make rewards from PvE more available for minimally careful players. Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #25 by kevintloney; Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #27 by kevintloney;

With said game mode, the presence of PvE aircraft would allow aircraft types other than fighter aircraft to become playable. PvE aircraft would offer more for a player to do while also making their actions more meaningful to the match outcome. The player can fly fighter escort or play as a strike aircraft without being overwhelmed by enemy players in the climb to win meta. The game could then better retain relevancy even after they run out of new aircraft to add. The game can then take more time between updates to improve game functionality and work on new maps and historical scenarios.

I previously spoke in greater detail about nuclear escalation being defined by PvE and how said mode will retain minimum relevancy beyond 2028. What campaigns would you like to see? - #13 by kevintloney

With nuclear weapons being gated behind prior snowballing, they only make the issue of snowballing into victory that much worse. For this exact reason, they already removed spawn points from naval enduring confrontation. The title of the nuclear escalation is only a trivial detail that can be subject to change, so any concern over it would be counterproductive. Nuclear weapons and SPAA based difficulty only serve to maintain minimum interest until more meaningful PvE can be implemented.

Gaijin has destroyed the red team in 8.7-9.7 after removing all of the guided weapons from J22M1A, even the laser-guided rocket, now the red team can’t even destroy the M163 safety lmao

1 Like

i agree with you, it is a gamemode with a lot of potential, but real life war strategy is missing, such as Jammers as you say (a su24 armed with only jammers existed so it would be an exuse to add a new plane btw).
the anti aicraft its maybe almost realistically strong, so one of the real life strategy used is basically saturate the anti aicraft with targets, so, i would add in this regard, decoy drones and a way to send them to specific positions


decoy drones where also launched by ships, and this would give the ships an actual purpose to the game instead of just being targets