Combat between vehicles too dissimilar in mobility fundamentally does not offer the dynamic relation between player positioning and outcome that is offered by combat between vehicles of more similar mobility. SPAA doesn’t move nearly as quickly as an air vehicle and they cannot move in 3 dimensions.
With less comparable mobility, a given period of movement from a vehicle will have a looser relation to vulnerability. With a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness or caution in positioning will have less of an effect on said vehicle’s level of risk. The more mobile vehicle can be more careless without it affecting their level of risk to a vehicle that cannot move to take advantage of said carelessness. For the less mobile vehicle, with a larger gap in mobility, prior carelessness by the less mobile vehicle will have less effect on their exposure to risk. With a larger gap in mobility, combat outcomes are more uniform regardless of player skill.
With the game needing to present a minimum level of difficulty for careless players, a larger gap in mobility will make the game uniformly punishing for careless players and skilled players alike.
Combat between SPAA and air vehicles presents a fundamental problem. Player controlled vehicles cannot coexist when their vehicle types are too dissimilar in mobility. The solution is design around overtly preventing combat across different vehicle types.
This also explains why bombers and strike aircraft in Air RB remain unplayable unless they happen to be ignored by the enemy. Beyond a minimum level of player skill, vehicles of greater mobility trivialize careful positioning by a less mobile vehicle. Unless vehicles of greater mobility are made into fodder, vehicles of lesser mobility cannot participate in combat with said more mobile vehicles. Unless vehicles of lesser mobility are made into fodder, vehicles of greater mobility cannot participate in meaningful combat with less mobile vehicles. In either case, when both vehicles are controlled by players, a player from one side of the mobility gap will be made into fodder.
Close air support in ground and naval presents a fundamental issue where combat between vehicles so dissimilar in mobility cannot occur without a player from either side of the mobility gap being made into fodder.
Close air support cannot continue to exist as a part of ground without players in helicopters, fixed wing aircraft, or ground vehicles being made into fodder. In playing to the strengths of the game mode, player controlled combat air vehicles are best removed from the game mode entirely.
Close air support cannot continue to exist as a part of naval without players in aircraft or naval vehicles being made into fodder. In playing to the strengths of the game mode, player controlled combat air vehicles are best removed from the game mode entirely.
When a vehicle on the opposite side of the mobility gap is instead controlled by AI for PvE gameplay, said vehicle on opposite side of the mobility gap can be made into fodder without creating an unplayable experience for any player. In classic air battles, ground vehicles already present as fodder for air vehicles. With the inclusion of AI controlled combat air vehicles into ground and naval battles, combat aircraft can remain part of the game mode without making any player into fodder.
Including potent AI controlled combat aircraft will leave the issue unresolved for player controlled naval and ground vehicles. In classic air battles, ground vehicles are already made into fodder by directly diminishing their weapon potency. In classic air battles, war thunder already includes PvE strike aircraft that target ground vehicles. As an early solution, ground and naval battles can include PvE strike aircraft that are of a lower BR than the given BR of player controlled vehicles. Classic air battles are able to include more detail by presenting a variety of different vehicle types as fodder. In addition to the inclusion of PvE strike aircraft, ground and naval battles can include PvE fighters and PvE dive bombers. The game has yet to include PvE helicopters, so speaking about the idea here will only be counterproductive. With the inclusion of PvE aircraft, SPAA will be able to retain their role without making any player into fodder.
With nuclear escalation being centered around PvE gameplay, the eventual inclusion of helicopters will allow them to remain playable without making any player into fodder. They will remain playable even after they are no longer allowed to participate in classic ground battles.
The issue of combat between vehicles of dissimilar mobility is fundamental to the issue of SPAA in nuclear escalation and the issue of non fighters being unplayable in classic air battles. These issues all embody the same pattern. In a prior thread, I spoke about this in greater detail. Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #25 by kevintloney; Why is Nuclear Escalation so unenjoyable? - #27 by kevintloney.