One of the things that bothers me most about War Thunder’s Air Realistic Battles is the number of situations where I feel the outcome of a fight doesn’t depend on my skill, but rather on luck.
I’ve encountered countless scenarios where I do everything I’m supposed to do to evade a missile—flying nap-of-the-earth, maintaining proper defensive geometry, keeping an eye on the incoming missile, and executing the necessary maneuvers—yet I still get hit. What’s most frustrating is that in other matches, while doing essentially the same thing against the same type of threat, I manage to escape without any real difficulty.
And that is precisely the problem: a lack of consistency.
I understand that real-world aerial combat is imperfect and involves many unpredictable factors. But this is a game that aims to simulate aerial combat; I expect its mechanics to function consistently, especially when it comes to systems as critical as radar-guided missiles.
The “multipath” effect is a prime example of this frustration. The mechanic is intended to represent interference caused by radar waves reflecting off the ground, but in practice, it often feels impossible to know whether I’ll actually be able to evade a missile, even when flying at an extremely low altitude. There are times when I manage to avoid impact, and other times when I get hit despite performing what appears to be an identical defensive maneuver.
This effectively turns certain situations into a gamble. Instead of reflecting on how I could have executed a better maneuver, studied the missile’s behavior, or identified where I went wrong, I’m left wondering if I was simply unlucky that time.
To be honest, I would love a PvE mode that allows me to research aircraft without ever having to play Realistic Battles again—a mode that, as it stands, feels like it’s based entirely on luck. I once ran a test using the AV-8 with a Fox-3 missile, together with a friend. We set up two scenarios—one flying at high altitude and the other flying low and slow—keeping the position, the missile, and the aircraft identical. The missile missed several times but managed to hit twice; there were over seven misses, yet nothing—not the angle, the speed, or any other variable—had changed. Even so, I got two different outcomes. To me, multiplayer feels like pure luck: I’ve been killed while flying just 2 meters off the ground, and I’ve missed a target while flying at 58 meters. If it’s all down to luck, I might as well go to a casino.
Seriously, the multipatching mechanic needs to either be removed or reworked to be much less random—or at the very least, made realistic. It’s better to play a game that is frustrating but realistic than one that is frustrating in an “arcade” way (which is what War Thunder’s “realistic” air battles currently are).