Historical Battle Rating discussion

This will never work balance wise.

Some nations, especially the big 3, will have a field day, while the smaller nations will get their teeth kicked in in every match.

And the balance between the big 3 wouldn’t even be that good.

Nah that will make small nations unplayable.

Exactly. Imagine playing shermans and facing maus, king tiger and me262…

I would actually be T29, T30, T34, Late war pershings, and late war mustangs (P-51H-5) and corsairs

M36B2 can kill the maus and its in the 1945 BR

Historical battles arent a bad idea for events but the way you’ve suggested it being laid out is terrible. I wouldnt even go near the menu option to select it as a battle if that was the case. Not being mean but how its suggested as is, is very bad.

Well I’m working on a 2.0, so get ready

Concept 3 going from 4.3 to 8.7 is a bit much

1 Like

Technically 9.0 thats when it had its trial

1 Like

It has decent penetration, just gotta flank

Thanks for the info.

That’s atrocious

1 Like

Light tanks are flankers, what do you expect, still gotta flank with the concept 3 in normal matches

This Br would be absolutely hilarious, we would have only 6 planes, the Mig-23, the F-8U, the F-111A, the G-91A, the Milan and the Stikmaster, it would be so unbalanced

2 Likes

We will se when i complete my chart

1 Like

XD Historically correct would be Ha-Go vs M26. Have fun playing historically Japanese, Ki-27 vs B-29 or Chi-Nu vs Jumbo or Pershing. So would Pz. II and Pz. 38 vs KV-1 and T-34.

Could work for sim, events instead of the brackets. Problem is balancing spawns, there is no penalty for leaving a match so anything i can think off the top of my head wont work because players would just leave the match. Grind aspect also eats into possibilities.

Only thing I can really think of is incentivising people playing weaker vehicles in battles by awarding hefty multipliers to rewards ie you get significantly more rp/sl for taking out a tiger in your 57 sherman than a hellcat or killing a jumbo in pz4 vs panther etc…

This would also help with iff, gaijin doesnt want to do anything about it and vocal people in the sim community are against anything making iff easier and content with having a gamemode less popular than naval realistic.

1 Like

No, this chart is only based of year of introduction Ha Go 2.0, M26 3.7, KI-27 2.3, B-29 3.3-3.7, Chi-nu 3.3, Panzer II 2.0, Panzer 38t 2.3, KV-2 2.7, T-34 2.3

Yes, beautiful game Chi-Nu vs Tiger 1/2, Panther, pershing etc.

1 Like

this means F-22 in 12.7 and Su-57 in 14.3

This system simply does not work. People have already given plenty of examples, it’s just not possible.

5 Likes