I don’t know of any SPAA in the game with caliber >105mm
It would be based on tnt filler, not caliber
I don’t see why that’s necessary.
Thats how shockwaves are made
Sorry, I did not understand what you meant earlier. I thought you meant the way it looked.
Yes and currently nothing ingame is modeled to produce a shock effect.
The statement you replied to is not related to current systems in-game. Try again
If tnt is how shockwaves are made and shockwaves cause stun, tnt would be the factor for the stun
Yes which is why your requisite of placing the effect based off of filler is illogical.
If you want a stun mechanic, it would have to be added based on the source of the shockwave. Aka tnt
Shell type and caliber.
Additionally majority of definitions of “model” are looks and appearance rather than the functionality. I did not mean to confuse or insult you otherwise
None of those are a major factor in creating the shockwave.
Yes, War Thunder is a game liberties must be taken.
I guess you just answered your thread
“should War Thunder be balanced?”
Your answer dictates whether or not your statement is true.
Did some digging, and it turns out the US actually did a study of the effect of the blast caused by HEAT shells on people inside an cramped space. Turns out, outside significant ear damage and some mild internal damage, there’s comparably little, and in a relatively confined space around the blast.
Certainly not a lot of fun for the occupants, but outside of some immediate hearing loss, nothing considered incapacitating to the simulated crew. Also, in game crew members are capable of tanking far worse than that with no ill effect, I don’t see a reason to model this particular phenomenon.
It’s not a perfect study, I question the use of internal blast chrages as a stand-in for a penetrator, since that pressure is likely to be lower and more focused in a single direction, but I’ll assume they know something I don’t.
Depends. Your definition of balanced or mine?
So was this a thing or not?
Mechanical shock.
To be fair, i feel like AP hit electorics would also not be good for it